4 ms·
"A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away," is beginning to sound a lot more plausible. How could there not be a few Death Stars inhabited by English-speaking
by jrockway 15y ago
"A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away," is beginning to sound a lot more plausible.
How could there not be a few Death Stars inhabited by English-speaking humans somewhere in one of those galaxies?
- paraschopra 15y agoWhat I find interesting about this question is that it is at once fascinating and silly. Fascinating because it would be incredibly cool to have someone like us somewhere out there. Silly because the distances involved are mind boggling, so it is highly unlikely they would ever be able to contact us. So is there any real difference between they not existing at all and they existing and we (probably) never been able to know that they exist? All we can hope is to hopelessly theorize and write science fiction stories about them.
- losvedir 15y ago> How could there not be a few Death Stars inhabited by English-speaking humans somewhere in one of those galaxies? I know this is just a tongue in cheek comment, but I actually thought it somewhat reasonable until recently when I spent a moment with the numbers and saw its impossibility. Basically, there's only ~100 billion galaxies with ~100 billion stars each (to an approximation of several orders of magnitude...), while the space of possible societies, languages, histories, etc, grows exponentially. Even if there were 10^100 stars, log_2(10^100) is still only about 330. This means all those stars can only accomodate 330 forks in history where it could have gone one way or the other with equal probability. Or, in computer science terminology, all those stars can only encode 330 bits of information. And describing English alone takes far, far more than 330 bits. (Depending on how inevitable language of a certain type is.)
- mikeash 15y agoNote that your numbers apply to the observable universe. The universe as a whole is likely to be infinite. Not that there is much practical difference between "the universe" and "the observable universe".
- lee 15y ago> This means all those stars can only accomodate 330 forks in history where it could have gone one way or the other with equal probability. Or, in computer science terminology, all those stars can only encode 330 bits of information. And describing English alone takes far, far more than 330 bits. There's a huge gap in your logic here. The number of bits to represent all the stars in the universe has nothing to do with the possibility that there is some English speaking society out there.