4 ms·
75% of Americans Believe AI Will Reduce Jobs
- mgdev 3y agoAs with ever other major innovation, it will both destroy and create jobs. Whether AI creates more good than harm will be hard to actually evaluate. Like every innovation, there will be general disagreement on what constitutes "good".
- ytoawwhra92 3y ago> As with ever other major innovation, it will both destroy and create jobs. Yep. Major innovations change economic equilibriums and as the economy shifts accordingly winners and losers are produced. Economic losers who see what's happening get angry and oppose the innovation. In extreme cases this leads to social problems. IMO a key role of government is shepharding societies through major economic shifts while minimising social instability. IMO it's more productive to accept change and plan for it than try to prevent it. > Whether AI creates more good than harm will be hard to actually evaluate. Perhaps I'm excessively fatalist, but I think that's largely irrelevant. Even if we had an oracle which could tell us that a given innovation will be a net negative in the long term, any innovation still presents opportunities for individuals and groups to gain advantages over others in the short to medium term. WMD proliferation is the only example I can think of of a collective decision to slow development of a particular technology due to a belief it will ultimately be a net negative. Even then we haven't stopped, we only slowed after major players consolidated their positions, and we've yet to see how successful that slowing will ultimately be. As in - did we put the cat back in the bag permanently, or will it get out again? Climate action might be heading that way, too, but I don't think the cat's even back in the bag yet.
- mptest 3y agoThe problem is, it doesn't take much destroying. Hitler rose to power off the back of 3 years of 25% unemployment.[0] It just doesn't need to replace all jobs, nor does it need to replace them permanently to have drastic, world changing repercussions. [0]Fantastic discussion with Suleyman and Yuval Harari https://youtu.be/7JkPWHr7sTY https://youtu.be/7JkPWHr7sTY
- paulpauper 3y agono doubt the media plays a role this too with endless headlines and forecasts by 'experts' about how AI will destroy jobs
- idopmstuff 3y agoMy take is that the real societal shift will come when we have AI-powered bipedal robots, a la Agility Robotics' Digit or Tesla's Optimus, at something like <$100,000 a pop. AI in knowledge work will probably see the sort of changes people talk about - jobs destroyed but new jobs created. A robot that can do cleaning, construction, even retail sales - that's going to wipe out swathes of jobs. You'll have armies of workers that can work nonstop, don't steal, don't want raises, don't have a bad day at work, and can be retrained as quickly as you can install new software. I don't see that there's any reason we won't be able to have those kinds of robots in, conservatively, 20 years, and I don't see how we get close to replacing the number of jobs they take.
- killbot5000 3y ago> don't have a bad day at work All systems break. Complex systems break in complex ways. Robots will definitely have bad days.
- idopmstuff 3y agoYeah, that's totally fair. I suppose I see it as different than human problems for two reasons. First, workers become fungible - right now if John who's the expert on the particular machine we need to use today just got dumped and is doing a bad job, we have to either work with him in his downtrodden state or find someone else with his expertise. With robots, when one starts malfunctioning you swap it out. Second, you can diagnose and fix it. I can't fix my employee's broken heart or lack of sleep because they have a small child at home. Whatever is wrong with the robot, I can fix.
- dTal 3y agoI cannot wrap my head around how far awry society has gone, that "eliminating tedious labor that no one really wants to do" gets reframed as "destroying jobs". Obviously in reality the benefits do not immediately flow to the people relieved of work, yet this obvious critical flaw of capitalism is always blamed on the automation in question. Yet few suggest we destroy our existing automation, no matter how many wonderful jobs it would recreate such as "washerwoman" and "water carrier". Society is clearly wealthier, the more "jobs" we eliminate.
- butterlover 3y agothe 25 percent work in IT and know the average groundbreaking innovation is mostly marketing noise with very little substance
- idatum 3y agoI kindly ask: Provide numbers, how this survey was conducted, some math. Please.
- DanielHB 3y agoThe brightest side of AI in my opinion is that the jobs created will be of _lower_ technical skill compared to the jobs created by the computer revolution. It will be _easier_ to take advantage of AI than it was to take advantage of a computer. This means the new jobs could potentially be ones that more people can perform and the jobs eliminated will be some of the highly-technical ones.
- technick 3y agoThe irony is my company is starting it's annual hackathon week. The company has gone out of its way to make Google AI available for us, met with Google employees who are rolling out the red carpet to give us access to unreleased tools, features and experimental apps. We were already tightly partnered with google before this, so it all makes sense google wants to see we very successful, meaning we can never leave them for AWS or Azure. I feel like each team is looking for a way to optimize another teams work, making them more expendable after we fully adopt AI systems. Really feels like a race to the bottom, luckily only a handful of people know what I do and they don't have access to my systems to even start trying to figure out how I can be replaced. That's called job security my friends... I believe anyone saying AI isn't going to reduce jobs is full of crap, it's going to happen.
- Justsignedup 3y agoI already see ai replacing jobs of people who tend to handle communication where a friend of mine is doing the work of 5 by generating 90 percent of their comms and hand modifying the output. Basically if your job involves finding a way to tell people information you are replaceable by current ai models. If your job requires creative thinking, you're safe, ai ain't even close to that.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoLiterary translation is a field where machines have already threatened creative thinking jobs. Already even some respectable publishers in various countries are machine-translating novels, giving them a light copyediting (not always a deep editing -- the industry has been cutting back on that for years) by someone who doesn't speak the source language, and selling them to the public. It is not that machine translation can already think so creatively, it is just that the cost savings are so great that human creativity is viewed as an unaffordable luxury and the market tolerates the quality hit.
- Justsignedup 3y agoI agree here. This is always the way. I mean literally most companies I work for are all about "how do we take a human process and make it automated, and thus more accurate and better!"