3 ms·
I still don't get how "storytelling" and "entertainment" have anything to do with investigative reporting and blowing the whistle on alleged workplace abuses.
by r00fus 15y ago
I still don't get how "storytelling" and "entertainment" have anything to do with investigative reporting and blowing the whistle on alleged workplace abuses.
Daisey did Foxconn employees and all emerging-market workers a dis-service with his mistruths... all in the name of "entertainment" and his bottom line.
The real danger is that someone who really questioned the labor conditions at the factory that produces Apple (and Dell, Microsoft and many other companies) products is now left confused as to whether it's really a problem.
- bonch 15y agoI believe Mike Daisey was attempting to insert himself into the situation. He fell in love with the idea of being a spokesperson for labor rights.
- flurie 15y agoGiven that the subject of worker treatment in China hasn't died down as Daisey has pointed out it so often did, even in light of the retractions and apologies, can we say yet whether he's done those workers a disservice? I think it's too early to tell.
- MartinCron 15y agoIf you look at the fabrications, they weren't even necessary to make the story more entertaining. Lies like "the guards had guns" and "I met the hexane-n victims" just make him look more heroic, daring, and groundbreaking than he actually was. The true story would have been entertaining enough for me, but apparently wasn't good enough for Mike Daisey's vanity.
- skilesare 15y agoI'd encourage you to listen to his georgetown talk. He admits his vanity and talks about how those things seeped into the show. It actually made me think of startups and raising money. Person after person after person asking questions, making suggestions, framing questions that have really detailed answers, but sometimes it is easier to nod and be seen in a better/bigger light than to clarify.
- MartinCron 15y agoThanks for the heads up. I'm eager to hear the Georgetown talk now. In most contexts, I don't have any trouble with vanity. If you need to stretch the truth to make a better stage show or memoir, that's great. I loved "The Social Network" even though I knew that a lot of the story was stretched to fit a traditional film narrative. I'm OK with that. The only thing that really went wrong was when he let his story be presented in the wrong context, and how he deliberately misled the TAL folks during fact checking.