3 ms·
I think the bigger problem is we have no idea what the necessary or sufficient requirements are, neither for qualia nor for intelligence. (Not sure why you thin
by ben_w 3y ago
I think the bigger problem is we have no idea what the necessary or sufficient requirements are, neither for qualia nor for intelligence. (Not sure why you think it's np rather than just lots?)
With intelligence we can at least tell when we've achieved it, to whatever standard we like.
Emotions could probably be a thing where we can map some internal state to some emotional affect display, eventually; but what about any question of emotional qualia?
AFAICT, we don't even have a good grasp of the question yet. We each have access only the one inside our own head, and minimal capacity to even share what these are like with each other. When did you learn about aphantasia, for example? Is there a word for equivalents for that for other senses besides vision? I can "visualise" sounds and totally override the direction of down coming from my inner ears, but I can't "visualise" smells, and I don't have a non-visually oriented word for the idea, as both "visualise" and "imagine" clearly are and "idea" itself more subtly also is.
- _0ffh 3y ago"Qualia" are really just a reframing of (an aspect of) consciousness, which has been speculated to be purely epiphenomenal. Maybe we're just along for the ride, and our actions merely happen to mirror our decisions - or the other way around, same difference.
- ben_w 3y agoQualia is how to discuss the problem of consciousness without a pointless discussion about if this is the opposite of unconscious, the opposite of subconscious, something that needs a soul, or any of the other things that go wrong if you don't taboo the "c" word. We don't know the answers (nor, I assert, the correct questions), though "what even is this?" and "what has it?" were already relevant to animal rights questions (qualia might have started with humans, but there's no reason to assume that) well before current AI, and even if we find a convenient proof that current AI definitely can't and that's fine… some of us want to advance the AI to at least as far as brain uploading where the qualia is the goal, though virtual hells like in the novel Surface Detail seem to me to be an extremely plausible dystopian outcome if uploads ever actually happen.