4 ms·

Ask HN: Is there any good open-source alternative to MinIO?

13 points by ingoaf 3y ago

MinIO has got some heavy licensing costs for commercial use. I was wondering if there is any object storage with an S3 API - ideally with a UI and something that could be run easily in a container.

nik736 3y ago
SeaweedFS and Garage.
- Cwizard 3y ago
  Have you used Garage in production/professional? What has your experience been like?
  - nik736 3y ago
    We were trying it out for quite some time and it worked well apart from two things: anonymous access and the bigger blocker for us was AGPL. Minio and Garage having the same license means I would always prefer Minio.
- ingoaf 3y ago
  I would also be interested in your experience. Besides, they both don't have a UI, don't they?
  - ies7 3y ago
    We use seaweed in production, inserting 1-4 million small images per day. It comes with a web based UI. We migrate from minio to seaweed around 2020/2021. At that time our minio server have problem handling hundreds of thousands small files. Btw if you only need to store and serve a few TB, Backblaze B2 is way cheaper and easier.
  - nik736 3y ago
    We used it for around 2yrs with the s3 gateway and it was very stable for around 50 TB of data mostly very small files (50-200kb).
- meotimdihia 3y ago
  I am using Seaweedfs with 40+ TB data and ~100M files. Serve 100-200k+ users daily with servers that just have HDD.
wmf 3y ago
Ceph/Rook?
speedgoose 3y ago
Have you considered the Open-source version or MinIO? I know the AGPL-v3 is scary to many people but having to release the source code and your very unlikely patches under AGPLv3 doesn’t sound that bad. Otherwise I played with garage and it was fine but it had no GUI and no configuration file to configure it when I tried it (you need to use the CLI). I would probably favour Ceph in production. Garage is a bit young.
josephcsible 3y ago
MinIO is open-source, and like everything else that's open-source, you don't have to pay to use it commercially. Are you confused by what they call a "commercial license"? It's not necessary for commercial purposes; it's just their name for what the FSF calls "selling exceptions". As long as you comply with the AGPL, you don't need to buy it.
- ingoaf 3y ago
  I didn't explain enough and thank you for clarification! I think the problem will be that I will not get the project which is using MinIO right now to comply with AGPL.
tracy12 3y ago
[flagged]
ddorian43 3y ago
There is also Apache Ozone https://ozone.apache.org/ https://ozone.apache.org/
ezedv 3y ago
If you're looking for an open-source alternative to MinIO for object storage, you might want to consider projects like Ceph and OpenIO. Ceph offers scalable and high-performance storage, while OpenIO focuses on an object storage solution with a decentralized approach. Both have active communities and can be suitable options depending on your specific requirements. It's worth exploring their features to see which aligns best with your needs.
salmawisoky 3y ago
[dead]

13 points by ingoaf 3y ago

MinIO has got some heavy licensing costs for commercial use. I was wondering if there is any object storage with an S3 API - ideally with a UI and something that could be run easily in a container.

nik736 3y ago

SeaweedFS and Garage.

Cwizard 3y ago
Have you used Garage in production/professional? What has your experience been like?
- nik736 3y ago
  We were trying it out for quite some time and it worked well apart from two things: anonymous access and the bigger blocker for us was AGPL. Minio and Garage having the same license means I would always prefer Minio.
ingoaf 3y ago
I would also be interested in your experience. Besides, they both don't have a UI, don't they?
- ies7 3y ago
  We use seaweed in production, inserting 1-4 million small images per day. It comes with a web based UI. We migrate from minio to seaweed around 2020/2021. At that time our minio server have problem handling hundreds of thousands small files. Btw if you only need to store and serve a few TB, Backblaze B2 is way cheaper and easier.
- nik736 3y ago
  We used it for around 2yrs with the s3 gateway and it was very stable for around 50 TB of data mostly very small files (50-200kb).
meotimdihia 3y ago
I am using Seaweedfs with 40+ TB data and ~100M files. Serve 100-200k+ users daily with servers that just have HDD.

wmf 3y ago

Ceph/Rook?

speedgoose 3y ago

Have you considered the Open-source version or MinIO? I know the AGPL-v3 is scary to many people but having to release the source code and your very unlikely patches under AGPLv3 doesn’t sound that bad. Otherwise I played with garage and it was fine but it had no GUI and no configuration file to configure it when I tried it (you need to use the CLI). I would probably favour Ceph in production. Garage is a bit young.

josephcsible 3y ago

MinIO is open-source, and like everything else that's open-source, you don't have to pay to use it commercially. Are you confused by what they call a "commercial license"? It's not necessary for commercial purposes; it's just their name for what the FSF calls "selling exceptions". As long as you comply with the AGPL, you don't need to buy it.

ingoaf 3y ago
I didn't explain enough and thank you for clarification! I think the problem will be that I will not get the project which is using MinIO right now to comply with AGPL.

tracy12 3y ago

[flagged]

ddorian43 3y ago

There is also Apache Ozone https://ozone.apache.org/ https://ozone.apache.org/

ezedv 3y ago

If you're looking for an open-source alternative to MinIO for object storage, you might want to consider projects like Ceph and OpenIO. Ceph offers scalable and high-performance storage, while OpenIO focuses on an object storage solution with a decentralized approach. Both have active communities and can be suitable options depending on your specific requirements. It's worth exploring their features to see which aligns best with your needs.

salmawisoky 3y ago

[dead]