4 ms·
> For starter regarding filecoin the number of nodes you must expect to lose is “almost all of them” because they can stop operating if the economics isn't even
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> For starter regarding filecoin the number of nodes you must expect to lose is “almost all of them” because they can stop operating if the economics isn't even good enough to cover their OpEx
You don't expect to lose "almost all of them" at the same time. Even if the price crashes, you would expect capacity to go down over a period of days or weeks, not minutes. And then if a fraction of the data is lost but is less than the number of erasure blocks, you promptly reconstruct it and put it on a different node.
Meanwhile you would expect an equilibrium here. The price going down forces some providers out of the market, but providers leaving the market brings the price back up. As long as the customer is offering as much as some providers need to stay in the market, somebody is hosting the data. That only stops if the customer won't bid what the providers need to get, at which point the customer transfers their data out of the system so they can stop paying more than they're willing to.
Now, you can screw this up if you make your system sufficiently convoluted so the price signal doesn't make it from the customer to the provider or vice versa, and I'm not familiar enough with the specific implementation in Filecoin to comment, but screwing that up isn't inherently necessary for this category of system.
> the problem is that a node could voluntarily fuck up the calculations when/if it advantages them.
Which is why you duplicate some of them at random, and don't tell them when you're going to do it. The calculations are deterministic. If you distribute one to two random nodes and they don't get the same result, but they've each signed their own result, now you know one of them defected and can prove which one by doing that calculation yourself or doing some other potentially expensive operation that only happens when there is an inconsistency. At which point the defector is found out, you can prove it, and their reputation is in ashes.
> Yet barely anyone uses it, which empirically question its “usefulness”.
It seems to be storing more than a exabyte of data for someone.
> their capital is essentially illiquid[1]
> [1] and I don't get were you got the idea that storage was “fungible”, the failure rate going up exponentially over time makes storage a poor fit for the second-hand market, especially if people know that you've been running stressful proof of space-time on it, and if you're trying to fire-sale a Petabyte of storage, chances are high that people will figure that out
It's fungible because a used hard drive is a commodity product with a wide customer base. That new ones cost more than the used ones doesn't make it not a commodity; you could have bought the used ones to begin if you're content to continue running them at their current age.
Let me know if you're aware of some place you can buy working >=16TB drives, used or otherwise, for less than ~$100 each in 2023.
- littlestymaar 3y ago> Meanwhile you would expect an equilibrium here. The price going down forces some providers out of the market, but providers leaving the market brings the price back up. Bringing the XIXth century equilibrium economics here is kind of hilarious, when it has been far out of the equilibrium price for the past two years. Node runners are already losing money, and have been doing so since the end of the bull run. The value of the FIL token isn't so much derived from an equilibrium in the supply and demand for storage, it's driven by the supply and demands of the coin on the crypto market, and if nodes start to give up in any meaningful fashion over the course of a few days or weeks, the crypto market will likely negatively react, driving the price of the token even lower. In the crypto markets, Keynes' animal spirit is in charge, nobody makes rational utility calculation. > At which point the defector is found out, you can prove it, and their reputation is in ashes. If I can make more money out of a single adversarial attack than it costs me to build up reputation, then who cares, I'll be doing it over and over again any day. > It seems to be storing more than a exabyte of data for someone. It is in fact storing a exabyte of “data” for “someone”. Compare that with BitTorrent, that was used by everyone and their mom before governments started to fight it. BitTorrent was voluntary only and was a massive success. Filecoin is for profit and a failure. > It's fungible because a used hard drive is a commodity product with a wide customer base. Try and sell 10PB of PoST-worn-out hard drives and see how long it takes. It's far from liquid.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The value of the FIL token isn't so much derived from an equilibrium in the supply and demand for storage, it's driven by the supply and demands of the coin on the crypto market, and if nodes start to give up in any meaningful fashion over the course of a few days or weeks, the crypto market will likely negatively react, driving the price of the token even lower. The reason for this is that the price of FIL was initially too high for the amount of customer demand for storage it currently has, resulting in oversupply. But you only lose data as a result of sudden undersupply. If the network could lose 90% of its capacity over a month and still store all of the data it currently does, and then that happens, so what? Whereas if it actually lost enough capacity to create scarcity given the existing demand for storage, then demand for storage would drive the price of the coin back up, right? > If I can make more money out of a single adversarial attack than it costs me to build up reputation, then who cares, I'll be doing it over and over again any day. How are you going to do that with AI training or something? As soon as you get caught once, people go back and retroactively verify everything you've previously done, and then you not only lose any payment received for each calculation you forged, the model you screwed up gets recomputed using the money you didn't get to keep or had to stake in order to be trusted to do computations with lower frequency verification. > Compare that with BitTorrent, that was used by everyone and their mom before governments started to fight it. BitTorrent was voluntary only and was a massive success. BitTorrent is a great success for large, popular data. It's pretty much useless for storing anything with a low number of downloads. > Try and sell 10PB of PoST-worn-out hard drives and see how long it takes. It's far from liquid. Put functional 16TB hard drives on Amazon and eBay for $99.99. See how long they last. I'd guess less than six months before you've sold 10PB worth.