3 ms·
I got a ticket due to a poorly designed "smart" parking meter. I parked and put change in the meter and it didn't seem to register. I was a little confused, a
by m463 3y ago
I got a ticket due to a poorly designed "smart" parking meter.
I parked and put change in the meter and it didn't seem to register. I was a little confused, and put it in the meter for the adjacent car and a coin would register and increment the time.
Ugh. So I put a post-it note on the windshield describing the problem and went to eat.
Came back, and you guessed it: post-it gone, replaced by parking ticket.
It wasn't obvious what was happening, and I kind of put it all together afterwards.
The parking meter seems to have some sort of occupancy sensor. I suspect it might reset your time to zero if you leave the spot. reading your comment, it might be a max time in spot sensor? who knows.
I think it needed my car to be detected to add time to the meter. Because it was too far away or not reflective, or whatever, the coins were not accepted to add time. But it did keep the quarters. geez.
I complained on the ticket when it came. Had to pre-pay, but went in and pled my case at the parking authority court. Took two witnesses. They filed something to talk to engineers and said they'd let me know.
And then they denied it. I had the ability to appeal, but by then it was several hours of my time taking off in the middle of the day and I just let them keep the $40.
jerks.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoDepending on where you live it could be as simple as you're not allowed to park at a broken meter. It's possible but unlikely that there's any sort of occupancy sensor. https://sf.streetsblog.org/2011/01/13/should-parking-be-allowed-at-broken-meters https://sf.streetsblog.org/2011/01/13/should-parking-be-allo...
- m463 3y agothere was definitely a sensor facing the car - three little windows and one of them blinking an led.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoYeah that's almost certainly not an occupancy sensor. Out here the single space meters have green LEDs for when it's legal to park (e.g. non-metered hours, or metered hours and the meter has been paid) and red for when the it's not legal to park there. This is so that someone passing by can quickly identify which meters to focus on. Of all the ways you could detect the presence of a car most would be easily obstructed if they're looking from the POV of the meter. Maybe a camera would work, but even if you ignore the ease with which it's obstructed you still run into issues processing the photos. Sure you could also probably fit a small SBC into there, but you'd have no room for a battery powerful enough to run for any meaningful amount of time. When I was doing that sort of thing professionally we kept the stuff in the meter very simple and our whole thing was built on super low power comms (think lower power consumption than Zigbee). While batteries are easy enough to change out in a meter, having to change them out frequently adds to the operational cost. The costs of trying to determine occupancy outweigh the benefits. Typically what I've seen is that adding money to the meter just resets the session. Dollars to donuts you just came across a busted meter.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> And then they denied it. Sounds like The Simpsons. Homer gets a parking ticket, with a number to call for an automated appeals process. He calls. "Thank you for appealing your parking ticket. Your appeal has been [no pause] Denied. Have a nice day. [click]"