5 ms·
MIT stacks solar panels like pancakes, increases their power output by up to 20x
- DanBC 15y agoA much better version: (http://www.newsroomamerica.com/story/228653.html http://www.newsroomamerica.com/story/228653.html) (http://news.cnet.com/8301-11386_3-57404585-76/accordion-shaped-solar-tower-captures-more-light/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-11386_3-57404585-76/accordion-shap...) (http://news.techeye.net/science/3d-solar-cells-could-increase-energy-output-twenty-fold http://news.techeye.net/science/3d-solar-cells-could-increas...)
- draggnar 15y agoI didn't really get the pancake reference, accordion makes much more sense.
- wtvanhest 15y agoAmazingly, the results from the structures they’ve tested show power output ranging from double to more than 20 times that of fixed flat panels with the same base area. Lets say the current design takes up 1 cubic meter. (I can't tell from the photo). Lets say you have a 10,000 square meter roof, 100x100 meters. Does this mean you can put 10,000 of them up there or a number far lower since they need space in between them to let the light in? The article isn't clear whether an arrangement of 20 of them is more efficient then the space required, but it does hit at it when it says: Then, to confirm their model’s predictions, they built and tested three different arrangements of solar cells on the roof of an MIT laboratory building for several weeks.
- DanBC 15y agoMore testing and simulation is needed. > So far, the team has modeled individual 3-D modules. A next step is to study a collection of such towers, accounting for the shadows that one tower would cast on others at different times of day. In general, 3-D shapes could have a big advantage in any location where space is limited, such as flat-rooftop installations or in urban environments, they say. Such shapes could also be used in larger-scale applications, such as solar farms, once shading effects between towers are carefully minimized.
- wtvanhest 15y agoI have no idea how I missed that. But it is the most crucial part of the article. The equivalent would be putting a solar panel upright and saying it gets more energ per SM than one laying flat. Seems pretty obvious.
- aaronhoffman 15y agoReminds me of this: https://www.google.com/search?q=solar+panel+tree https://www.google.com/search?q=solar+panel+tree Which it appears now has been debunked.
- moonchrome 15y agoI think when you type in that sort of stuff in to Google they should offer advertisements for magic beans.
- ctdonath 15y agoFresnel lenses come to mind. Another head-slapping moment.
- jacquesm 15y ago(1) You can't improve on solar panels by a factor of more than 5 because 'regular' photovoltaic cells are already ~20% efficient. (2) any geometric arrangement of solar cells that includes the 'third dimension' will shade an area behind it that is proportional to the height of the stack, that dead zone should we taken into account when calculating efficiency. In other words, the total surface area of the stack is what counts, not just the footprint. And placing these panels at a 45 degree angle actually decreases their efficiency. The total output will go up but the cost per Watt will go up as well (and it will go up more than the power output). Why is it that every announcement about solar panels is always accompanied by either gross exaggeration or inaccuracies? This really gives a bad rap to the whole renewables industry, if I had a 1% increase of efficiency on PV panels for every 10x announcement I'd be at 300% efficiency by now... MIT really hurts their reputation with announcements like these.
- pilsetnieks 15y agoRegarding the first point - they increased overall panel efficiency not cell efficiency. There are a lot more cells in these 3D panels than in a flat panel and considering that in the accordion layout a lot of them don't see light unless sun is low (morning, evening, winter), the average output per cell is lower than in a conventional panel. But apparently it's the output per panel that counts.
- jacquesm 15y agoPanels are arrangements of cells. Panel efficiency is measured in $/Watt or as a percentage of incident light over the total area taken up by the array including shade, not in output per square unit of area under the array. If you want to do a really nice job in measuring panel efficiency you set up equal area arrays (equal areas of cells with the same packing density on the cells themselves) and measure them side-by-side over the course of a year. The 'control' should be a non-tracking array that you correct for elevation once every month and that points due South on the Northern hemisphere and vice versa.
- brudgers 15y ago
- backprojection 15y agoIt's starting to get to the point where, if the title of the post begins with 'MIT', I put my expect-the-BS hat on. Edit: to be clear, I think it's because MIT's PR departement is hyper-inflatory, which you can hardly blame them for. But maybe due to it's reputation, the regular press picks up on like it's golden.
- sbierwagen 15y agoIs it me, or have we been seeing more garbage stories like these since PG disabled flagging for people who flag a lot? (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3689185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3689185)
- kappaknight 15y agoWe must eat really different pancakes cause I don't get it...
- veguss 15y agoYou'd be blocking the view of someone else.