2 ms·
"It was totally legal to build the technology to make deepfakes. It doesn't mean that it was ethical." We're not debating if it was ethical, only if it was neu
by giantg2 3y ago
"It was totally legal to build the technology to make deepfakes. It doesn't mean that it was ethical."
We're not debating if it was ethical, only if it was neutral. Technology is applied by people so it's always a people problem. If there exists a state where it is good and a state where it is evil, then it's neutral. If it has only one state, them it is not neutral (either it's good or bad; either of those is rare).
- palata 3y ago> If there exists a state where it is good and a state where it is evil, then it's neutral. Is that a formal definition coming from an official source, or is it your personal opinion? You seem to say "good = 1, neutral = 0, bad = -1, hence good + bad = neutral". What if a technology has a "good" score of 1 and a "bad" score of -1000? Does "good + bad" make it neutral then?
- giantg2 3y agoYep, the tech is still neutral and it's an application/people problem. You can look up neutral in the dictionary - if it doesn't belong to one side or the other then its neutral. Better to think of it as a 0-1 probability scale. If you're a 0 or a 1, then you belong to one side or the other. Anything in-between is neutral since its not a certainty nor exclusively aligned with one side or the other.
- palata 3y agoHmm I feel like somehow we ended up debating the definition of "neutral". I don't really care about that. My initial point was that IMO, we should always think about the impact a technology may have on society before we build it. I am not completely sure what the technology behind deepfakes brings to society, but I clearly see serious problems. If a technology makes significantly more harm than good, maybe it should not be built in the first place. Maybe I need another word to make you understand my point, because "neutral" clearly did not work.