6 ms·
>Kim was obviously thumbing his nose at US copyright law I don't think providing a DMCA takedown process which was removing tens of thousands of files a day co
by Karunamon 15y ago
>Kim was obviously thumbing his nose at US copyright law
I don't think providing a DMCA takedown process which was removing tens of thousands of files a day counts as "thumbing his nose at US copyright law"
- naner 15y agoThe site still appears to have been hosting mostly infringing content. Not a business I'd consider getting into if I had a wife/kid.
- droithomme 15y agoYouTube has now and has had far more infringing content than Megaupload ever did. But Megaupload isn't owned by a corporation with Al Gore and other rich politically connected Americans as senior advisors and/or on the board of directors.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoYou can't compare YouTube to MegaUpload. YouTube has Google levels of traffic which MegaUpload did not. YouTube lets you watch and listen but you can't take what you see and hear home with you (read: download it). YouTube is damn quick and transparent with their takedowns and has never encouraged piracy either directly or implicitly. MegaUpload, at the very core of the idea behind it, really was a legit file locker service but that's not how it exactly worked in practice. MegaUpload has always been one of the go-to places for pirating media. They had ads on all the popular torrent sites that linked to the same files you'd download as a torrent. Everyone knew what MegaUpload was all about and anyone claiming they were just a poor innocent file locker service must be kidding themselves. I have a hunting knife. I use it to hunt. No one will begrudge me my knife because I use it legitimately. If I kill a man walking down the street with it however someone is going to try to stop me and take my knife. I'll protest "but it's a hunting knife, it has a perfectly legitimate use!" but it won't matter because I crossed a line just like Mega did.
- tripzilch 15y ago> YouTube lets you watch and listen but you can't take what you see and hear home with you (read: download it). Yes you can, and most non-tech-savvy people I know actually prefer to do that, than to download their music from torrents or "download sites". Which I can imagine because they're much less likely to get a virus and they just need a firefox extension and everybody knows how to find their favourite tunes on YouTube.
- joering2 15y ago> You can't compare YouTube to MegaUpload. YouTube has Google levels of traffic which MegaUpload did not. What on Earth do traffic numbers have to do with whether a site is infringing copyrights on not?? > has never encouraged piracy either directly or implicitly. What the Viacom vs YT/Google tough us is that the YT owners were fully aware of the files uploaded being pirated. There have been long emails transcriptions where YT owners talk with each other how long should they keep the files online to "help traffic numbers grow" before putting files down. Lookup the court case, I am short on time to look right now.
- cbr 15y ago> What on Earth do traffic numbers have to do with whether a site is infringing copyrights on not? That was in response to "YouTube has now and has had far more infringing content than Megaupload ever did." I believe billpatrianakos is arguing that what matters is the proportion of infringing files. YouTube could have more infringing content than MegaUpload with a much lower proportion of infringing content because they have "Google levels of traffic".
- billpatrianakos 15y agoYes, thank you. This. I was talking about proportion. I'm aware raw traffic means nothing.
- joering2 15y agook thanks for explaining me. so where you getting this one from: > has never encouraged piracy either directly or implicitly.
- brazzy 15y ago"YouTube has now and has had far more infringing content than Megaupload ever did." Do you have any reference to back that up, or did you just make a wild-ass assertion?
- Karunamon 15y agoDepends, do you have one that states the majority of MU's content was infringing?
- Karunamon 15y ago> The site still appears to have been hosting mostly infringing content. That hasn't been proven, for one. And even if that is ever objectively proven, whither Rapidshare? YouTube? Hotfile?
- tptacek 15y agoRapidshare, Youtube, Hotfile. Which of these things is not like the others? These kinds of razzle-dazzle arguments don't make you sound more convincing. "MegaUpload wasn't mostly infringing content". "Youtube is just like Rapidshare". This is Hacker News, not a court of law; who's mind do you think you're changing with statements like that?
- Karunamon 15y ago>Rapidshare, Youtube, Hotfile. Which of these things is not like the others? 2 are general file repositories, one is specialized toward video? All 3 are very popular and heavily trafficked sites that host infringing content, but also a non-trivial portion of non infringing content? >who's mind do you think you're changing with statements like that? You're right. I shouldn't bother trying to change the mind of the MafiAA believer crowd. I still try anyways.
- tptacek 15y agoName calling? Really? Google is a business partner of the content industry. Serious (high-fidelity, in-release-window, substitutable commercial product) infringing content on Youtube is a headache for Google. That same content is the reason Rapidshare and MegaUpload exist.
- Karunamon 15y agoHow is it name calling if you parrot the arguments of the recording industry? Just because a number of the hacker type finds them distasteful doesn't mean you're not making the same BS arguments they are. Stop parroting their arguments and I'll stop calling a spade a spade. >That same content is the reason Rapidshare and MegaUpload exist. Bullshit. Or put another way, citation needed.
- tripzilch 15y ago> The site still appears to have been hosting mostly infringing content. How??! It's 25 petabytes. How many movies did the MPAA (Disney+Sony+Viacom+NewsCorp+NBCUniversal+Warner) produce, that need to have been uploaded as how many duplicates in what sort of quality?? According to Wikipedia there have been about 3500 titles released on BluRay in the US (which are by no means all represented by the MPAA, but it's an upper limit). Generally these hi-res movies are uploaded in 10GB versions, but even if they all used the full dual layer disc (50GB), that's still 3500x50GB = 175 terabyte = 0.175 petabyte. And this is being extremely generous just to get a ballpark estimate to show just by how much they miss the order of magnitude. It's probably about a fifth of this number. Movies before BluRay have not been released or uploaded in this resolution, they're generally not bigger than 1GB (the vast majority being 700-800MB). How many movies did the Big Six produce? It's quite hard to find that number, actually. But I'll do you one better: One number I could find, is that there were 9157 movies produced in 1995-2012 (summing these numbers: http://www.the-numbers.com/market/MPAARatings/ http://www.the-numbers.com/market/MPAARatings/ ) which amounts to about 538 movies per year. Times 70 years of copyright is max 37660 movie titles that might still be copyrighted, times 50GB a piece cause they're all magically uploaded as raw BluRay rips even if they don't exist in that format, is 1,883,000 gigabytes of data. That's 1.9 petabytes. So, that means that every movie that's been made that is still under copyright, must have had 13 duplicates in the absolute highest 50GB/BluRay format to make up for 25 petabytes of data on MegaUpload. Except that's not right because even on BluRay you can't just inflate the quality like that until you fill 50GB, you need to fill it with actual minutes of video material so even on BluRay these movies can't have been that big. Also I'm fairly sure that the number of movies produced between 1995 and 2012 is a rather high estimate of movie production in the past 70 years. And then there's the fact that 13 duplicate different format rips of a movie is quite a rare sight, and most different format encodings are going to be much, much smaller than the BluRay version. So really, there's just no way anything more than a few percent of the data on MegaUpload could have been infringing on the MPAA's rights. But they took it all offline, just to make sure. And the more I try to wrap my head around these calculations (petabytes are HUGE!!) I'm not even sure if they could have filled it up with porn either ... what IS in those 25 petabytes, I'm getting rather curious now :)
- tptacek 15y ago
- dlikhten 15y agoFurthermore he fully complied with DMCA which only required links removed. He followed the law to the letter, more he even gave tools that go above and beyond the law. It is not his fault the industry was not willing to properly police. Now devil's advocate: the MPAA and affiliates CANNOT possibly go over every single website which hosts content and provides different ways of inspecting that information and filter. It is just impossible. They would spend all their money 10x over just policing. Which of course begs the question: are they evolving with changes in tech or just doing everything in their power not to.
- brazzy 15y agoHa actually did none of that.
- joejohnson 15y agoSo he's lying in the interview with TorrentFreak? Can you support this claim?
- tptacek 15y agoYes: the DoJ built a case for almost 2 years again MU, and subpoenaed and obtained huge amounts of intracompany email in which MU repeatedly admitted knowledge of and financial benefit from piracy. For instance, when an outsider complained that MegaVideo's hosting of the Showtime pay-tv series "Dexter" had desynchronized audio/video, instead of taking down "Dexter", Kim Schmitz fired off mail saying that fixing the AV problem was a priority. That's just one of many many instances; see up and downthread for others.
- angersock 15y agoCare to elaborate? Because, you know, he actually mentions in the article upping the delete quota for Warner Bros.
- tptacek 15y agoI see no mention anywhere in the DMCA of "reasonable limits" to the number of infringement notices a provider needs to deal with, only the statutory language demanding that providers act expeditiously to react to those notices. Why was there a "quota" at all?
- brazzy 15y agoA DMCA takedown process with was a sham and was not actaully removing anything counts as exactly that. Especially when internal mails reveal that the daily cap for takedown notices was determined by what wouldn't impact revenue.
- Karunamon 15y ago>A DMCA takedown process with was a sham and was not actaully removing anything As described ad nauseum elsewhere, the DMCA only requires removing infringing links. Imagine 5 people upload a copy of a copyrighted song. 4 of those copies are for backup or personal use, one of them ends up on a file sharing site. The 1 is DMCA'd. Why would you remove the other 4? *edit This becomes even more crucial when you have any kind of sane deduping in place, where each link, in effect, points to a single piece of data.
- brazzy 15y ago"4 of those copies are for backup or personal use" If they're for personal use, why are the publically accessible (and actually being downloaded by hundreds or thousands of different users) and not restricted to the account that uploaded them?
- Karunamon 15y ago>If they're for personal use, why are the publically accessible Because it becomes "publicly accessible" the moment the link to the file is generated when the upload completes. I.e. you can access the file if you know the URL. The law does not require you to do this kind of research, besides.
- tptacek 15y agoThe DMCA requires service providers with actual knowledge of their hosting of infringing material to act "expedititously" to remove or disable access to the material. I don't know where this argument about "links" comes from. This whole argument seems like a bit of a red herring. What the DMCA actually says is that service providers aren't liable iff (a) they don't have actual knowledge of infringement --- and that if they themselves become aware of infringement they themselves without prompting remove infringing content, (b) don't have a financial interest in infringement, AND (c) respond to takedown notices. It beggars belief that MegaUpload could pass (a) and (b). All three need to apply to avoid liability.
- tptacek 15y agoThe site had millions of users. Is the allusion to "tens of thousands" of files supposed to be convincing? Why was there a limit at all? This is a site that had to deal with (say) 10,000 takedowns a day; clearly, it had a rampant piracy problem.
- viraptor 15y ago> Why was there a limit at all? Maybe to limit the Warner and other companies' actions. They're trying to sue for obvious test files now. What are the chances that given unlimited access they wouldn't worry so much about verification of what's legal/what belongs to them? It's a completely different thing if they reached the limit every single day, were rejected higher quotas and have a big queue of files to remove... But why didn't they say so?
- tptacek 15y agoYou think a jury will reasonably believe that Warner was sending tends of thousands of bogus takedowns every day? I don't.
- viraptor 15y agoI can only hope they kept logs of all takedown requests. Now they only need to find a reasonable sample. Honestly, I believe that even if they tried hard not to make mistakes, at this volume they would get some false-positives - and that's as good explanation as I can imagine. Now the question is - can Mega* guys prove enough of cases like that. Or maybe they have other explanation for the quotas - I don't know - I'm eager to hear more about it.
- onemoreact 15y agoAssuming the limit was close to the average number of take down requests it's reasonable protection to prevent a buggy third party script from harming their site.
- nkassis 15y ago
- Nelson69 15y agoThere are a lot of missing variables here, 10s of thousands of files a day sure does sound like a lot to a lot of people though, for all we know that's just a drop in the bucket. How many DMCA take down requests does a company like google/youtube get a day? Anyone know? Just out of curiosity. It all sort of proves the point though, Megaupload had a ton of piracy and all parties involved knew it. I think that might matter more than a lot of people think, they may have complied with the literal letter of the law but can't courts deem it not enough? Napster was ordered by a court to monitor it's use and restrict illegal use and they were ultimately unable to. There are already cases on the books for that, the fact that MU gave out access to tools like direct delete just shows that they knew the extent of the problem. Still, no reason to skip due process, but I don't know what all the evidence is either.