4 ms·
Sometimes when I hear discussions like this, I can't help but think back to several places I've lived or stayed where using a car was not possible. It sucked.
by m463 3y ago
Sometimes when I hear discussions like this, I can't help but think back to several places I've lived or stayed where using a car was not possible.
It sucked.
Yes, living in the exact center of a bustling city should be efficient - you should be able to walk everywhere for all your needs and it should be efficient.
But the reality was that you couldn't and it wasn't. It took a tremendous toll on your time and the effort to live life was higher.
I think the way people lived a decent life walking and taking public transportation was to live a smaller life, and put up with the inefficiency of slower transportation and more limited choices of jobs to have, places to shop and things to do.
Am I wrong? Do I not understand? Has anyone moved from a semi-dense area where just about anything was within a 10 minute drive, to a situation where they didn't use a car and still lived a decent efficient life?
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> Sometimes when I hear discussions like this, I can't help but think back to several places I've lived or stayed where using a car was not possible. Example? Us in New York are going by fine taking the train or biking, and if we really need a car we call a cab or an Uber, and that we have to pay extra makes us really think if we need that car or is that just us being lazy. I won't ever understand the joy of punting that bill of your joyrides to the next generation, I guess.
- CharlesW 3y agoSimilarly, being car-less in Chicago is the way to go. Even pre-Uber it was far better — it can take an hour to find a parking space in certain neighborhoods at certain times.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe train blows since the pandemic. Blue line is coming like once every 10 minutes during rush hour so you can't count on ever actually getting on due to crowding.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWhat are some examples of such car-free places?
- davidw 3y agoFor most people, it's not really binary. For instance, when I lived in Italy, we did have one car for our family of four. We used it to go see the in-laws and stay late at dinner when there were no public transit options to get home. But we took the tram downtown with our small kids. And I rode my bike to work often. And my wife and I would go out on dates riding our bikes. And I'd walk our kids to school. And if we wanted to go hiking out in the hills, we'd drive. So it wasn't so much about a zero-car lifestyle as a 'right tool for the job'.
- midoridensha 3y agoYeah, I moved to Tokyo from suburban US. It's great here. Far more convenient than living in America. What kind of crappy places did you live where having a car wasn't possible, yet there was no decent public transit? Furthermore, living in the built-up suburbs of a large metro in the US, not much was within a 10 minute drive. Sure, the grocery store was, and some shitty chain restaurants, but that's about it. Everything else was much longer because of traffic.
- lokar 3y agoI lived in Manhattan without a car. It was great. There was like 3 of every kind of thing within a short walk.
- c-cube 3y ago> you couldn't and it wasn't What are you talking about, millions of people do it and live without cars in cities. I did it for years in Paris and it's not a "smaller life" — the main things that are smaller are your transportation budget and stress levels.
- JambalayaJim 3y agoAbsolutely agreed. Just about everything within 10 minutes drive is a total fantasy in my experience. Whether you’re in the suburbs driving or walking in the urban centre. The only difference is that walking is much more pleasant. That said, if you expand your time radius to 15 minutes, and allow the use of bikes and/or a good subway system, “just about everything” becomes very realistic.
- Vaslo 3y agoNot everyone can or wants to ride a bike everywhere. Stop this fallacious thinking. Many people don’t care about and will never care about using bikes, nor should they be forced to. I also have no interest in waiting around for a subway car. It’s nice to just hop into my car and get to my destination (most within 15 minutes of my home) and get back. I don’t have time to wait around or ride a bike in the rain. The entire northern suburbs in my city have been designed around my “evil” car beliefs. It’s worked so well that our city population keeps declining and my area just keeps adding more and more houses and businesses. You like your way, I’ll live mine.
- Eldt 3y agoIf only there were other factors to consider other than your convenience...
- JambalayaJim 3y agoWhere in my comment did I prescribe my way of living onto you?
- DrDroop 3y agoI've lived as a foreigner in a big metropole in Australia and I fell that all places that I could go where tourist traps. Simple life hacks like buying groceries for a week was impossible, the closest cheap grocery store was too much of walk and too hilly for a bike loaded with bags. I do agree that cars make the city worse for the people living there, but I am not a fan in how cities limit your lifestyle. People that live in the city are sometimes blind to this and don't understand that someone might prefer to live another life.
- simonw 3y agoWhich places? I've lived without a car in London and San Francisco and it's been fantastic. I lived without a car in Mountain View and it was pretty awful.
- kaashif 3y agoYeah, I've lived in London and New York (not in the suburbs of either) without a car and there was multiple of everything within a short walk, and huge amounts of stuff (literally thousands upon thousands of things to do) everywhere in less than half an hour on the train. It was and is great. Not sure which cities the person you're replying to is talking about. I imagine a lot of American cities just suck without a car, even if they "have" public transportation.
- rout39574 3y agoI think "Just about anything" within a 10 minute drive is probably not a carefully considered standard. Can you name a specific place in which you think this standard obtains? I think the only way to think objectively about this sort of thing is with a very careful analytical framework. Think about the amenities you need, and how you acquire them, and then really -measure-, rather than just "think back" about the burden of acquiring them. Not many people live 10 minutes from their work, for instance. Google thinks the average is just under a half hour each way. If you try to analyze the number of jobs within <x minutes> of a particular domicile, it's my expectation that you'll find more, not fewer, options in urban setting. I reccomend https://app.traveltime.com/ https://app.traveltime.com/ as a way to tinker with your expectations there. Toss a 10 minute drive around your town. You might be surprised at how modest that span is.
- dalke 3y agoI can name one: a house at Monterey Place, Santa Fe, New Mexico, US According to Google Maps it's no more than 10 minutes to any edge of the city. It's also near stores and a rail station with service to Albuquerque. While I lived north-east of there, most places I went to in Santa Fe were within a 10 minute drive of where I lived. I rarely went to the SW corner of town. I worked from home.
- elyobo 3y agoYeah, I live in the Melbourne CBD and it's great. I don't even need to cross a street to access all essentials.
- dalke 3y ago> Has anyone moved from a semi-dense area where just about anything was within a 10 minute drive, to a situation where they didn't use a car and still lived a decent efficient life? I used to live in Sante Fe, New Mexico in the US. The city was founded in 1610. The city core for the first 300 years was of course walkable, but the last grocery store downtown closed around 2000 so it's a mile walk to the nearest store (biking isn't really an option in Santa Fe). When I lived there the population was about 65K. I lived in a post-war suburb about a 30 minute walk from the center of town. When built it was on the outskirts of town, connected to downtown via a gravel road. It's all paved now, and a great place to live with a car as just about everything was a 10 minute drive away (though I would need to pay for parking downtown). The city extends many miles away from the center of town. Going along Cerrillos Road you can see the effect of zoning changes over time. In the center parking is very tight. Further out there are stores with a few parking spots, until you get to the more modern big box stores surrounded by a sea of parking. After I moved away I came back for a month and tried living without a car. I chose the very best rental location I could, about 13 minute walk to the center of town. While I managed, it required a lot of walking to get to the places I wanted to visit, "a tremendous toll on [my] time" as you say". Santa Fe does have a bus service, but running once per hour and only a few routes. I would not have lived without a car long-term. I now live in Trollhättan, Sweden, population 60K. While people have lived here for a long time, it didn't become a city proper until a bit over 100 years ago. Sweden was a pretty poor country and it wasn't until the post-war era that people could afford cars. The modern city core was built before widespread car ownership. The apartment building I live in was built around 1960. It's literally on Main Street ("Storgatan" in Swedish). There are two grocery stores in the city center, plus a few others within a mile radius. Both kids (ages 4 and 6) walk to school, which are 3/4 mile away. The city library, our medical center, the dentist, bank, and more are all within 1/2 mile. That option was not possible in Santa Fe. I had to do a 10 minute drive. Sweden has become a wealthy country and many Swedes have a single family home with one or two cars. Trollhättan has a lot of suburbs which are not as central as where we live. But they do have frequent bus service with a good network. During peak time I think some of the lines run at 10 minute headways. The regular public busses are also used to carry kids to/from school - Sweden doesn't have dedicated school busses. We also have big box stores, about 3 miles from where I live, surrounded by a sea of parking. And I can see how it's drawing stores away from the center of town. But unlike Santa Fe, in Trollhättan I can get on the bus (2 blocks away), get a direct bus to the complex, and be dropped off in the middle of the complex area. And those stores are mostly side-by-side and walkable, not separate islands in the sea. See https://www.google.com/maps/place/Överby/@58.313516,12.2946416,1359m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m15!1m8!3m7!1s0x46453cc87d46bc95:0x57b8e3ec7015bd6e!2s461+70+Överby,+Sweden!3b1!8m2!3d58.318664!4d12.3132199!16s%2Fg%2F11dylbyl3!3m5!1s0x46453cc52550a929:0xf0d457c8a18dec41!8m2!3d58.315006!4d12.302922!16s%2Fg%2F1vb9bnfb?entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/place/Överby/@58.313516,12.29464... . We've lived here now for 10 years, without a car, and I think it's a decent efficient life.
- DanielHB 3y agoYes, I moved from a car-centric place to Stockholm and having a car here is a luxury (mostly because parking is prohibitively expensive) and most people don't. Helps that the public transport is really good, even people who own cars they often use it only during weekends. Supermarkets are present in pretty much every single station so you just stop by when commuting and make more frequent visits but buying less items on each visit. People who live far away from metro/train stations (where parking is actually affordable, or free if they live in a house with a personal garage) usually just drive to the station and then board a train when commuting. Taking the train is faster than the car.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoMy pattern of life is very different in the one situation vs the other. As a pedestrian in a city I just pop out to the corner grocer; I step outside and take a walk (often to the park); I go to nearby restaurants; I get a coffee. Sometimes I ride the bus for no reason. All this is easy. On the other hand, going to IKEA is an all-day adventure. And I do overpay for some groceries. When I am a car-bound suburbanite, I instead organize trips once or twice a week to the grocery store, where I load up on supplies; I maybe drive to meet someone and go out to eat on one day of the weekend; and otherwise I sit in my house, until I plan an "outing". In general, suburban life seems to require more intention and planning for all the little things, but it makes some big things easier, like "I need to go buy a sofa". In the urban environment, I save money on a car, but spend more on rent. And dining/entertainment can be cheaper -- it varies -- but I consume more of it. Life just adapts to whatever environment it finds itself in.