3 ms·
Let me first agree with you that the first link was not very HNish. But I don't think it was mere snark. It was mockery, of quite a high order. In case its n
by emmelaich 15y ago
Let me first agree with you that the first link was not very HNish.
But I don't think it was mere snark. It was mockery, of quite a high order. In case its not obvious most of the words quoted are actually Chomsky, from http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/200307--.htm http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/200307--.htm
But let me draw some parallels.
PW paraphrases Chomsky as saying "Language has nothing much to do with language"
Norvig paraphrases Chomsky as saying "Observed use of language ... may provide evidence ... but surely cannot constitute the subject-matter of linguistics"
Not so different.
Lastly, you could say Chomsky might even take more offense at Norvigs calling him 'Mystic' and likening him to Bill O'Reilly!
Anyway, I don't take PW so seriously, but he is quite entertaining.
- charlieok 15y agofair enough :)