2 ms·
OK, but again -- none of that refutes the triune brain hypothesis at all. Literally nobody is claiming that only humans have neocortexes. Nor is anyone claimi
by crazygringo 3y ago
OK, but again -- none of that refutes the triune brain hypothesis at all.
Literally nobody is claiming that only humans have neocortexes.
Nor is anyone claiming it's an indicator of mental capacity. The recent discoveries about crows were interesting, but that doesn't have anything to do with the fact that the neocortex in mammals plays a particular, functional, well-recognized role.
- theptip 3y agoThe refutation is of the idea that it’s a strictly chronological layering, with the old layers inside and intact. The correct view is that while the neocortex is indeed mostly new, the “older” more central structures were modified throughout evolution.
- JohnAaronNelson 3y agoNo one thinks the older structures are static. No one is arguing that. It's a simplified model about the origin. This argument is akin to saying we're not "newer" apes ala > The refutation is of the idea that it’s a strictly chronological ordering of species, with the old species still inside and intact. The correct view is that while homosapiens are indeed mostly "newer", the “older” apes were also modified throughout evolution Obviously.
- theptip 3y agoI mean… the quote from TFA that they are arguing against is > As Paul MacLean (1964), originator of the triune-brain theory, stated, >> man, it appears, has inherited essentially three brains. Frugal Nature in developing her paragon threw nothing away. The oldest of his brains is basically reptilian; the second has been inherited from lower mammals; and the third and newest brain is a late mammalian development which reaches a pinnacle in man and gives him his unique power of symbolic language. And they quote other textbooks that are making claims along these lines too; this is right at the beginning of TFA. So I think you are wrong that “no one thinks that”. Of course they don’t think the old brains are 100% static but there are claims that they are largely conserved.
- Retric 3y agoIt’s an incorrect and misleading model about the origin. Bat wings and bird wings share many traits but the common answer didn’t fly it’s simply convergent evolution. The brain structures of that same common ancestor is only vaguely related to modern structures in mammals and reptiles. Modern reptiles, birds, and humans have experienced the same amount of evolution. There’s similar traits, but we don’t call whale flippers hands because that’s what the structures was in some of their ancestors or even what it is in related species. Similarly we don’t call human hands flippers because that’s what the structure started out as even further back and it’s still preforming that function in modern fish. The human visual cortex is larger than most creatures entire brain, it’s a wildly different structure than you find on a frog which plays a wider role in cognition than just decoding vision.
- aeternum 3y agoBut you could say that whale flippers are 'basically' their hands. Every scientific model and analogy is flawed in some way, but many are still useful.
- Retric 3y agoHow exactly is this theory useful? Yes, frogs and humans process visual information because they both have eyes. That’s about all those structures have in common.
- aeternum 3y agoFor nearly all of human history everyone thought that those frog vs. human eyes were completely separate and designed by some magical being living up in the cloud. By noticing that while they have significant differences, those structures also have significant similarities, we were able to correctly answer one of the greatest questions of all time: where did humans come from? Of all models, this one is particularly useful.
- Retric 3y agoTo be useful models must accurately represent some aspect of reality, Reptiles don’t represent the brain of our common assessor particularly well. So this model is just wildly wrong without any predictive power. Compare the giant spheres used by snakes, bird, frog etc to process visual information and try and map that to a rodent, bat, or human. Hint you’re not going to be able to locate an obvious sphere because the fundamental morphology is just different. You can say we both have areas of the brain devoted to processing vision but so do fruit flies.
- liquidpele 3y ago> No one thinks the older structures are static. It would seem enough people did to warrant this person to write about the topic.
- makeitdouble 3y agoFrom the wikipedia: > The triune brain consists of the reptilian complex (basal ganglia), the paleomammalian complex (limbic system), and the neomammalian complex (neocortex), viewed each as independently conscious, and as structures sequentially added to the forebrain in the course of evolution. According to the model, the basal ganglia are in charge of our primal instincts, the limbic system is in charge of our emotions and the neocortex is responsible for objective or rational thoughts. We disproved: - the sequentially added nature - what these zones are responsible for So in the end we're only left with a semi-arbitrary split of the brain in 3 zones and none of the hypothised implications. That to me refutes the hypothesis as a whole, and we're keeping the zone naming by sheer inertia.