3 ms·
Is the neocortex not an outer layer? That is not present in reptiles? So how is the stratified model incorrect as a high-level structural categorization? The t
by crazygringo 3y ago
Is the neocortex not an outer layer? That is not present in reptiles? So how is the stratified model incorrect as a high-level structural categorization?
The triune model doesn't claim our brain grows additively in rings like trees. It's merely an observation about the primary evolutionary origins of the three parts. Just those three.
And the superior/inferior characterization is not part of the triune model. You are free to interpret it that way if you want, but it's not part of it, so it's not a rebuttal.
- shevis 3y ago> Is the neocortex not an outer layer? It seems like this is what they are refuting. It is not so much a new layer as it is an evolution of existing structure.
- crazygringo 3y agoOf course it's a layer. It's a layer that itself is made up of 6 sublayers. This is not up for debate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocortex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocortex It clearly states: > The six-layer cortex appears to be a distinguishing feature of mammals; it has been found in the brains of all mammals, but not in any other animals. What it evolved out of is entirely irrelevant -- everything evolves out of something else in some fashion.
- civilitty 3y agoWhile the neocortex does have distinct layers, the neocortex itself is not “layered” around the rest of the brain - it’s deeply integrated all over the place with the rest of the brain and nervous system. There is no hierarchical relationship between the neocortex and different systems it integrates with. The reptilian equivalent to the neocortex is the dorsal ventricular ridge which evolved separately and in parallel. This presents two problems to the hypothesis: first the much simpler DVR serves much of the same purpose as the neocortex which was completely unknown at the time and second the most interesting bird species (the smartest ones) often don’t have an equivalent structure at all. There isn’t even a clear relationship between intelligence, complexity, evolutionary age, etc. After 250 million years of evolution any similarities are accidents of random convergence.
- xg15 3y ago> Is the neocortex not an outer layer? That is not present in reptiles? So how is the stratified model incorrect as a high-level structural categorization? Not sure about reptiles, but the author write this about mammals: > Neurobiologists do not debate whether any cortical regions are evolutionarily newer in some mammals than others. To be clear, even the prefrontal cortex, a region associated with reason and action planning, is not a uniquely human structure. Although there is debate concerning the relative size of the prefrontal cortex in humans compared with nonhuman animals (Passingham & Smaers, 2014; Sherwood, Bauernfeind, Bianchi, Raghanti, & Hof, 2012; Teffer & Semendeferi, 2012), all mammals have a prefrontal cortex. I also read some interesting papers a few years ago about corvids - particular New Caledonian Crows: Those animals do not have a neocortex and hence were thought incapable of many higher-level cognitive tasks, such as planning, tool use, etc. Turned out the crows were in fact capable of them. One hypothesis I read suggested that, as crow brains are structured differently, another structure may have taken the role that the neocortex has in humans. So even if it's an anatomical distinction, it's an unreliable indicator of mental capacity.
- crazygringo 3y agoOK, but again -- none of that refutes the triune brain hypothesis at all. Literally nobody is claiming that only humans have neocortexes. Nor is anyone claiming it's an indicator of mental capacity. The recent discoveries about crows were interesting, but that doesn't have anything to do with the fact that the neocortex in mammals plays a particular, functional, well-recognized role.
- theptip 3y agoThe refutation is of the idea that it’s a strictly chronological layering, with the old layers inside and intact. The correct view is that while the neocortex is indeed mostly new, the “older” more central structures were modified throughout evolution.
- JohnAaronNelson 3y agoNo one thinks the older structures are static. No one is arguing that. It's a simplified model about the origin. This argument is akin to saying we're not "newer" apes ala > The refutation is of the idea that it’s a strictly chronological ordering of species, with the old species still inside and intact. The correct view is that while homosapiens are indeed mostly "newer", the “older” apes were also modified throughout evolution Obviously.
- lukeasrodgers 3y ago- The superior/inferior characterize actually is part of the triune model, Maclean's book is replete with language like "advanced" vs "primitive". - The point of the criticism is not that the neocortex is not a "layer" at all, but that it is not the case that if you were to remove the neocortex layer, you would essentially get the brain of a lower-order animal--but this is what is implied by the triune theory.