8 ms·
After reading this article as well as the relevant Wikipedia entry [1], I still don't get what's supposedly "wrong" with the triune brain model. In fact, this
by crazygringo 3y ago
After reading this article as well as the relevant Wikipedia entry [1], I still don't get what's supposedly "wrong" with the triune brain model.
In fact, this article seems to set it up as a bit of a straw man. The main rebuttals in this article are 1) that evolution is branched rather than linear, 2) that larger brains aren't necessarily more complex, and 3) that evolution modifies existing brain structures in addition to adding new layers.
But all of that seems rather obvious, and doesn't really refute the triune brain theory at all.
Isn't it scientifically true that we have a basal ganglia which evolved from reptiles, a limbic system also present mammals, and a neocortex that works similarly to that in other primates, dolphins, and elephants? And each of those map to certain types of behaviors, that we see in these species?
The triune brain hypothesis doesn't seem "wrong", it just seems like a simple categorization that is useful for making big-picture distinctions.
Am I missing something? I literally don't understand what is even being "refuted" here, because the refutations don't seem to match the claims at all.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triune_brain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triune_brain
- csours 3y ago> "The triune brain hypothesis doesn't seem "wrong", it just seems like a simple categorization that is useful to the layperson." Yes. Anything this simple will be wrong. Almost everything you learn in school before graduate level courses will be wrong. Most of it won't matter to you unless you start working in that field.
- nuancebydefault 3y ago[1] is a nice book that explains in the first chapter why all science is wrong and gets replaced by a less wrong model, in steps. In fact the author argues that all those wrong models are perfectly fine and usable, for their period of time and applications. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Is_Not_What_It_Seems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Is_Not_What_It_Seems
- KMag 3y ago"All models are wrong, but some are useful" - George Box
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Almost everything you learn in school before graduate level courses will be wrong. From what I understand, in many fields its pretty clear that most of the stuff in graduate courses is, too, its just that then next step toward right is less clear and more disputed than for the earlier wrong stuff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xg15 3y ago> and 3) that evolution modifies existing brain structures in addition to adding new layers. As I understood it, their point was that evolution does not add new layers, evolution of the brain always happens by modifying the existing structure. Which is why a "stratified" view of the brain with evolutionary older layers near the center and newer layers near the surface is incorrect. The implications of this belief then led to incorrect assumptions about both humans and (non-human) animals: That the human brain is an "animal brain plus something else" and therefore automatically superior - and inversely that animal brains are "human brains minus something" and therefore automatically inferior. The article argues against both positions.
- Terr_ 3y agoAlso, it's not clear why we should accept that the brain would develop with locked-in "old strata" to a degree that we do not see in all sorts of other organs and systems. As much as people joke about having a separate stomach for ice-cream, I've never heard anyone suggest that their "lizard stomach" would handle certain foods.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dahfizz 3y agoBecause the brain physically, anatomically, has these "old strata". Lizard brains are pretty much just a basal ganglia. Humans have a basal ganglia, and then extra stuff on top. Mammals, and only mammals, have a neocortex "strata" to their brain as well. I am not qualified to argue for or against the Triune brain, but it seems easy to see why the brain is different from the stomach in this regard.
- snek_case 3y agoIn addition to this... Sure, evolution modifies existing structures, but if you compare a cat's heart and stomach to a pig heart and stomach, the difference is not that big, even though the nearest evolutionary ancestor was tens (hundreds?) of millions of years ago. Once a structure is in place and works well, you can certainly tweak it, but it's easier to mostly just keep it. Humans have a neocortex, but if you play with a cat or dog, you can recognize and understand the emotions they are feeling. Fear, anger, joy, anxiety, relaxation, etc. That suggests the structures responsible for those things in us are probably not that different from them.
- rexpop 3y ago> we have a basal ganglia which evolved from reptiles And do living reptiles, today, not also "have a basal ganglia which evolved from reptiles?" seems we've a name collision, here. Perhaps we should refer to our ancestors as "proto-reptiles," or else our contemporaneous cousins as "post-reptiles" whose brains have had just as many years' time to depart from our common reptilique ancestor.
- nextaccountic 3y agoWe're reptiles (as are all mammals, all birds, etc). My understanding of that is that all reptiles have a basal ganglia, because it was inherited from the common ancestor of reptiles. And non-reptiles don't have a basal ganglia because their ancestors didn't have one.
- dillydogg 3y agoWhat? Mammals appear in a separate branch of amniotes apart from Reptiles/Birds/Crocodilians Mammals and reptiles share a common ancestor with an ancient amniote, not a reptile
- gowld 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synapsid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synapsid > Synapsids[a] are one of the two major clades of vertebrate animals that evolved from basal amniotes, the other being the sauropsids, which include reptiles (turtles, crocodilians and lepidosaurs) and birds. > the only extant group that survived into the Cenozoic are the mammals. > The animals (basal amniotes) from which non-mammalian synapsids evolved were traditionally called "reptiles". > It is now known that all extant animals traditionally called "reptiles" are more closely related to each other than to synapsids, so the word "reptile" has been re-defined to mean only members of Sauropsida (bird-line Amniota) or even just an under-clade thereof
- hasmanean 3y agoHumans have this ability to obfuscate any issue. When there is a simple pattern for things some people always take edge cases and argue that the pattern is really not true. They don’t understand how models of the world work. Of course it’s not ideal but it’s a useful framework for understanding things. I imagine the reason Newton’s laws never developed before was because of all the influential know-it-alls who took empirical data (moving objects stop! Gaseous balloons rise!) and drew the wrong conclusions from it (gases want to rise up to be with all the other gases…solids want to be at rest.) It took Newton to do a thought experiment of a projectile moving in outer space to deduce his laws of motion. The fact is that newtons laws aren’t really observable on earth, unless you have the imagination to see it and do the mental bookkeeping of accounting for friction as a separate force.
- EricMausler 3y agoI'm not sure which side you are arguing for? Is the simple metaphor of 3 layers in the brain equivalent to saying gasses want to be together and solids want to rest? I think part of the debate in the comment section is on what kind of order / pattern we are trying to capture with the analogy. Does it make more sense to be analogous to the structural observations, or a more functional equivalency? You could say an ocean is like a desert in that they are vast and empty with respect to surface structures observed by a human traveller, but obviously from a functional /environmental perspective the two almost couldn't be more dissimilar
- xzsinu 3y agoThe triune model of the brain is not just a simplification, but one that promotes antiquated biases about human intelligence in how human intelligence differs from non-human intelligence, how intelligence is distributed among humans themselves, and what is essential to defining human intelligence itself. The lizard, small mammal, human distinction maps pretty deceptively onto Aristotle's distinctions between the souls: vegetative (plant), sensitive (animal), and rational (human). So if one is trying to pinpoint the seat of intelligence, it seems to follow that we can ignore the two lower sections of the brain in favor of the higher one. Franz Joseph Gall, the founder of phrenology, himself did that, writing off the cerebellum as relevant only for producing the sexual drive [1]. Scientific theories of self-control which were nothing more than Christian dualist arguments evolved out of Gall's work and argued that intelligence involved suppression of the lower faculties, which provided cover for eugenicist and supremacist arguments throughout the 20th century and still shows up today in popular theories about how the 'limbic system' subverts the rational capacities of individuals and is used to manipulate the masses (Elon loves this theory). Current work funded at the intersection of artificial intelligence and neuroscience still prioritizes the neocortex as the seat of rationality, with some like Jeff Hawkins (Palm founder turned brain scientist) arguing that "intelligence is an algorithm found in the neocortex". Singularity arguments rely in part on the assumption that intelligence in humans is mostly limited by the other parts of the brain, not empowered by them, and that a form of intelligence freed of embodiment will inevitably exterminate those that are embodied by right. The truth is, neglected sub-regions such as the "lizard" cerebellum actually contain the vast majority of neurons, have been shown to have evolved disproportionately larger within early hominins [2], and are theorized to be equally involved in abstract cognition as in bodily manipulation [3]. This is something of a paradigm shift that has only been able to take shape since the late 20th-century (through the work of Jeremy Schmahmann, Peter Strick and others[4]), even though hints of it have been present in the data since it was collected, and that's because of how compelling the triune brain model has been. Research in this direction can directly address mental illnesses such as schizophrenia, but it has to be funded first [5]. [1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnana.2019.00040/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnana.2019.0004... [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25283776/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25283776/ [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0304394018304671 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03043... [4] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0896627319301667 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089662731... [5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5UUqKuhvTk0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5UUqKuhvTk0
- civilized 3y agoLooking at this as an amateur, it seems like the key question here is "does the human brain have substructures that are similar enough to brain structures from ancestral species that it makes sense to consider them as the 'same' entity with the same name?"
- tiberious726 3y agoIt's not TFA's actual thesis, but here's a _much_ more powerful rebuttal of the triune brain and similar mental models if you're interested (from the perspective of what is the sheer idea of rationality) Matthew Boyle's "Tack-on Theories of Rationality": https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/8641840/Additive_theories.pdf https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/8641840/Additive...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- achrono 3y agoNo, your self-appellation aside, you are not missing anything unless there is some really secret 'nuance' hidden in the paper. If the triune brain model was completely false (as stated by the caricature of "brain is not an onion with a tiny reptile"), it would not be straightforward to even identify the neocortex -- how do you know it is 'neo', what is it a 'neo' of and so on? So the fact that we can meaningfully talk about these areas of the brain suggests that there is in fact continuity and building-upon happening in our evolutionary journey, although of course it's not like the cartoon they show (which I have never seen before from anyone seriously talking about this topic, I might add).
- lolinder 3y ago> If the triune brain model was completely false (as stated by the caricature of "brain is not an onion with a tiny reptile"), it would not be straightforward to even identify the neocortex -- how do you know it is 'neo', what is it a 'neo' of and so on? This is a sort of proof-by-etymology and it isn't very persuasive. We have all kinds of words that derive from misunderstandings that have stuck, even long after the original misunderstanding was resolved. The geographical equivalent of this would be to say "we call them Indians, so they must have originated from India at some point!" It's entirely possible that as our understanding of the brain evolves, this layered-over-time model will be seen as a quaint misunderstanding, but we'll still use the original names for the sub-organs because there's too much inertia to change them.
- armada651 3y ago> If the triune brain model was completely false (as stated by the caricature of "brain is not an onion with a tiny reptile"), it would not be straightforward to even identify the neocortex -- how do you know it is 'neo', what is it a 'neo' of and so on? I don't think that the intention of the article is to say it's completely false. It's that there is no neat evolutionary separation between the different parts of the brain. The "reptile" brain in humans is not truly the brain of a tiny reptile. We inherited a similar structure, but it evolved with us just like the rest of our brain. The same goes for the tiny reptiles we see today, their brains also evolved alongside them. If we truly had a tiny reptile inside our brain then logically we could simply study the behavior of tiny reptiles if we wanted to study that part of the human brain. Which is probably the kind of misconception the authors of the article want to refute.
- cosmojg 3y ago> But all of that seems rather obvious, and doesn't really refute the triune brain theory at all. > The triune brain hypothesis doesn't seem "wrong", it just seems like a simple categorization that is useful for making big-picture distinctions. Right, but having worked in the field, I can assure you that there are, in fact, too many practicing psychologists, cognitive scientists, and even neuroscientists who believe the triune model of the brain to be literally and, sometimes, absolutely true. These are the types of people whom the linked paper is trying to reach. Misunderstandings based on these oversimplified models are driving the current debate around modular versus distributed computation in the brain[1]. Obviously, a more accurate model of the brain would account for both ideas, but there is growing concern in the neuroscientific community over the amount of grant money going toward defending older, dead-end modular models instead of improving newer, more promising distributed models, mostly as a result of entrenched interests prioritizing the maintenance of prestige over the pursuit of truth. In short, putting bad models on blast is good and necessary for the advancement of science. You can get a lot done with the plum pudding model[2] of the atom, but you can get far more done with the Bohr model[3] which emerged only after Rutherford, Bohr, and several other physicists published several iterative takedowns of the former, and yes, they too had to deal with entrenched interests who operated under the assumption that the plum pudding model was literally and absolutely true. It took a decade of experiments and several increasingly correct models before academic consensus shifted enough to accept the existence of subatomic particles and academic consensus began its collective investment in quantum mechanics. We're now in a similar place with neuroscience in the tension between modular computational models, which includes the triune brain model, and distributed computational models, which are showing promise in rescuing fMRI studies with their strong modular tradition from the replication crisis[4]. [1] https://www.cell.com/trends/cognitive-sciences/fulltext/S1364-6613(22)00332-1 https://www.cell.com/trends/cognitive-sciences/fulltext/S136... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plum_pudding_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plum_pudding_model [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_model [4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5457304/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5457304/
- JohnAaronNelson 3y agoThank you for your contributions. Am I correct that you are asserting there are substantial numbers of practicing psychologists that literally and absolutely believe inner structures of the brain are unchanged over hundreds of millions of years, and they can and will be reached by this paper? If anyone doesn't understand "All models are wrong, but some are useful" I don't know if you'll reach them with this paper. Maybe it needs to be said. It's possible the most useful papers are those that assert obvious things in ways that refute our basic models so we can see things differently. It's also possible this is a clickbait paper that isn't saying anything new, just trying to be controversial.
- epgui 3y agoThis article is simply based on an uncharitable interpretation of the triune brain model. Literally nobody I know in the field believes in the cartoon-like description given by the article, and none of my introductory textbooks (I have quite a few which touch on this, from embryology to biopsychology to neuroanatomy) explain it in such a silly way as in the article.
- joveian 3y agoIf you want a detailed argument see Chapter 2 of Pierre Gloor's "The Temporal Lobe and Limbic System" where he argues against the (unfortunately still common) paleo/archi/neocortex terminology in favor if the allo/meso/isocortex terminology in the context of describing comparative anatomy. It is out of print but the Internet Archive has it available to borrow: https://archive.org/details/temporallobelimb0000gloo/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/temporallobelimb0000gloo/mode/2u... Your "isn't it true" paragraph is all incorrect (unless it is considered in a uselessly general way). For instance, Gloor notes that all mammals have an isocortex (that seems to have started in olfactory cortex). The "reptiles" that humans evolved from is just a catch all terminology for a diverse group of life and not closely related to current reptiles. He starts the chapter noting that ancestral brains are not available for direct study.
- lolinder 3y ago> we have a basal ganglia which evolved from reptiles I took this as the key point addressed in the introduction—this model of evolution is widely understood to be wrong. We did not evolve from reptiles, we evolved alongside reptiles from a common ancestor. Modern reptile brains have also changed in form and function since our common ancestor, and we don't have whole divisions of the brain that exist in humans but not in reptiles. Essentially, the triune brain theory goes right alongside that classic image of the monkey evolving into a man. It's not actually how evolution works, but it's a catchy simplification that's hard to get rid of. From the caption to the first diagram: > The evolutionary tree (c) illustrates the correct view that animals do not linearly increase in complexity but evolve from common ancestors. The corresponding view of brain evolution (d) illustrates that all vertebrates possess the same basic brain regions, here divided into the forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain. Coloring is arbitrary but illustrates that the same brain regions evolve in form; large divisions have not been added over the course of vertibrate evolution.
- ragtagtag 3y agoThe title definitely seems like a strawman, but it is the best use of a strawman that I've seen in an academic article: an outrageous and amusing title that makes me want to read the paper! (The rest of the article seems much more defensible to me: well-written without quite verging into strawman territory. But I'm no expert in the field.)
- JKCalhoun 3y ago> In fact, this article seems to set it up as a bit of a straw man. The title hints at what's coming. I mean of course no one thinks there's a "tiny reptile" inside our brains, ha ha.
- damethos 3y agoI recommend reading Seven and a Half Lessons About the Brain by Lisa Feldman Barrett
- michaelcampbell 3y agoSo, "all models are wrong, but some are useful" in another form. I agree, FWIW; this sort of criticism the article forwards seems a bit nitpicky.