3 ms·
> And further incentivize divorce? One way to give them more money and not incentivize single parenthood (which is the issue, not divorce, and treating them as
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> And further incentivize divorce?
One way to give them more money and not incentivize single parenthood (which is the issue, not divorce, and treating them as equivalent has always been wrong and is increasingly so as marriage rates drops) is to go to UBI instead of means-tested aid, or, if using means testing, use a means-testing formula which doesn't punish two-parent families.
> Children being raised by single mothers is not a good outcome.
Its a lot better than children being raised by two parents together, one of which is abusing them and/or the other parent, which any change which does more to avoid incentivizing divorce or single-parenthood more than eliminating any two-parent penalty would incentivize, especially for the poor.
- codexb 3y ago> UBI UBI still incentivizes divorce. It offers unconditional financial support to single mothers. > Abuse We're talking about no-fault divorces. Divorce, with cause, has always been legal -- abuse, neglect, abandonment, sterility, addiction -- there have always been ways to deal with these issues. More than half of all children will be raised in divorced households. The idea that 50% of fathers are abusing the children is absurd. There is a very clear lack of awareness on how severe each of these issues are. Yes, abuse by parents
- dragonwriter 3y ago> UBI still incentivizes divorce. It offers unconditional financial support to single mothers. No, it is neutral on divorce, because the support is unconditional. > More than half of all children will be raised in divorced households. Will be... when? And where's the evidence? The entire increase in single-mother families from the 1970s to 2019 was driven by the increase in parents who never married, not an increase in divorce-with-children. [0] > The idea that 50% of fathers are abusing the children is absurd. No one said that all divorce was due to abuse, but its interesting that aside from your invented numbers and inventing the claim of universality, you also changed divorce involving abuse of the other partner or a child to being exclusively about fathers and exclusively about abusing children. [0] https://ifstudies.org/blog/children-first-why-family-structure-and-stability-matter-for-children#:~:text=This%20trend%20was%20entirely%20driven,to%2018%20percent%20in%202019 https://ifstudies.org/blog/children-first-why-family-structu....
- codexb 3y ago> No, it is neutral on divorce, because the support is unconditional. Any government support subsidizes divorce. You are ignoring the fact that in the default state, without UBI (or government assistance), divorce would be naturally disincentivized because of the added financial burden on the caretaker. It substitutes the government as the provider instead of the father. It's precisely what the entire article is about. > No one said that all divorce was due to abuse You used it as a red herring to claim that divorce shouldn't be disincentivized. The fact that there are valid cases for divorce doesn't negate that fact that even in those cases there should be massive disincentives against it and that the overwhelming majority of divorces today likely should not be allowed because there is no valid reason for them. There's a lack of awareness about how destructive broken households and families are to children and society.
- em-bee 3y agoThe fact that there are valid cases for divorce doesn't negate that fact that even in those cases there should be massive disincentives against it and that the overwhelming majority of divorces today likely should not be allowed because there is no valid reason for them. There's a lack of awareness about how destructive broken households and families are to children and society. uhm, what? either there is a valid case for divorce or there isn't. you can't have it both ways. if there is a valid case for divorce then absolutely nothing should stand in the way. preventing divorce on its own does not help fix broken households. i do agree that as a socety we should do everything in our power to fix broken households. and by doing that, divorces will be reduced. but this is not done by disincentivizing divorce. it is done by removing the things that are the cause for the household to break. "Money arguments are the second leading cause of divorce, behind infidelity" the infidelity issue is addressed by better education (teach children that when they get married, their responsibility is to take care of each other (and teach them how to do that)) and the money issue is addressed by financial support for parents. it doesn't have to be UBI, but it should be to make sure that couples have enough money to live and raise children. in germany this is achieved by guaranteeing an existence minimum, and by unconditional extra money of around 200euro per child. disincentivizing divorce by not financially supporting the single parent is a very bad idea because it forces them to remain in an abusive relationship.