4 ms·
Well at least in close combat we know who turns first: "F 16 vs. F 35 - Turn Comparison" - https://youtu.be/SPqUvCnWcrk https://youtu.be/SPqUvCnWcrk
by belter 3y ago
Well at least in close combat we know who turns first: "F 16 vs. F 35 - Turn Comparison" - https://youtu.be/SPqUvCnWcrk https://youtu.be/SPqUvCnWcrk
- slavboj 3y agoThe entire point of the airplane is to never get into close combat. It's like asking which navy has better bayonets.
- belter 3y agoA theory pushed constantly by the F-35 program, but quickly dismissed by the Ukrainian War. "Dogfight Over Ukraine Shows The Air War Is Still Very Much Being Fought" - https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/dogfight-over-ukraine-shows-the-air-war-is-still-very-much-being-fought https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/dogfight-over-ukraine-...
- dncornholio 3y agoThis is a video of a fighter plane launching 2 missiles. It doesn't dismiss anything.
- dylan604 3y agoJust because the F-35 was designed to be a strike aircraft more than a dogfighter doesn't mean that it won't be put in those situations. We've been using butter knives as screwdrivers for as long as we've had a butter knife but no screwdriver.
- some_random 3y agoThat dogfight is newsworthy because it's exceptional, and even still it's not a turning duel by any stretch of the imagination. The real takeaway from the Ukrainian war is that stealth and engagement range are paramount.
- dgroshev 3y ago…plus SEAD/DEAD are incredibly important and (AFAIK) there is only one air force on the planet that systematically develops and deploys tech and trains for it.
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> theory pushed constantly by the F-35 program Because F-35 operation manual, chapter 1, "Combat prerequisites": Lob anti-SAM missiles till the enemy wouldn't have any operational SAM, then you can fly in on your fancy F-35. /s but only slightly
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xjlin0 3y agoF-4 Phantom was a great fighter serving US Navy, Marine and Air Force. It equipped with missiles to kill enemies in the beyond visual range, didn't equip internal guns in the first generation because "it shouldn't get into close combat" .....
- cityhall 3y agoAnd the F-15's design slogan was "Not a pound for air to ground". Guess what it's being used for now?
- justsomehnguy 3y agoQuite amusingly, Su-27 was an air superiority fighter at it's infancy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 3y agoSame with the F-16, which started life as a skunkworks project that prioritized dogfighting but is today heavily used for close air support and bombing.
- dragonwriter 3y agoWhile the skunkworks project and even the initial government Lightweight Fighter project had an air-to-air dogfighting focus, the program under which the F-16 development was conpleted and it was eventually purchased was for a multirole fighter, that wasn't a post-purchase usage evolution.
- dragonwriter 3y agoThe F-15E Strike Eagle is a different, significantly heavier and higher payload was produced by a separate, later project abd competition from the original air-to-air F-15 (its competitor was thr F-16XL, which would have been the F-16E/F if selected.) And the F-15EX Eagle II is an even newer aircraft. The F-15C/D are still air-to-air fighters.
- dylan604 3y agowhat in the world is that proving? it's 2 separate videos taken at totally different times. I'm not saying that the F35 is better than the F16 at turn radius, but this video is worthless as evidence of anything other than people are bad at tracking jets with a video camera.
- u10 3y agoFirst, there are very few aircraft that could beat an F-16 in a rate fight, but the likelihood that 2 aircraft enter a merge are extremely low, and even if everything went wrong and two aircraft entered the merge the ability for modern missiles to fire absurd off-bore shots kind of negates the requirement to get nose on. You might point to the early days of the Ukrainian War as a sign that BCM is not dead but that wouldn't track these days. Russia is sitting with MiG-31's flying over Belarus and Western Russia firing extremely long rage missiles. The enviroment is simply not permissive enough for the type of aggressive CAP that might result in BCM.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mrguyorama 3y agoIf you actually talk to pilots who have been in dogfights with F35s, they will tell you the radar-assisted guns basically could not properly target the F35 even at dogfighting range. It doesn't do a lot of good that, in order to fight the F35 you have to remember how aviation gunnery worked in 1944, before you had a computer doing most of the ballistics for you.