3 ms·
> What confuses me so much is society's inability to outgrow a lot of these recent YA novels. The same way I'm confused about how Taylor Swift is still so popul
by watwut 3y ago
> What confuses me so much is society's inability to outgrow a lot of these recent YA novels. The same way I'm confused about how Taylor Swift is still so popular with her original demographic.
Why is it weird? People liking what they encountered in their youth was normal. Generation that grew up on Beatles kept liking Beatles while their kids moved on something else. Generation that grew up on Jazz, kept liking Jazz while their kids moved on. And people who liked westerns as a young adults kept watching westerns as adults.
It is "outgrowing" only if you are moving into something more valuable in some sense. It is outgrowing only if maturity somehow precludes enjoyment of that thing. What happens with these however is that maturity is not preventing enjoyment at all, so people stay.
Also, Wheel of Time or Song of Fire and Ice were meant for adults. They are literature written with mature adults as audience.
- COGlory 3y ago>Why is it weird? People liking what they encountered in their youth was normal. Generation that grew up on Beatles kept liking Beatles while their kids moved on something else. Generation that grew up on Jazz, kept liking Jazz while their kids moved on. And people who liked westerns as a young adults kept watching westerns as adults. Because, in a way jazz (and the Beatles) wasn't, Taylor Swift was music engineered for young adults. Her songs wrote about being in highschool, she has an album titled 19.
- watwut 3y agoI went through all Taylor Swift albums on wikipedia and none of them is titled 19? The latest album is called Midnight and is basically all about relationships. Sometimes with adult twists, like loosing one because of focusing on career.
- allturtles 3y agoGrandparent must be thinking of Adele [0]. But I wouldn´t say her music was engineered for young adults either. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/19_(Adele_album) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/19_(Adele_album)
- COGlory 3y agoI am - embarrassing. I think the album I was thinking of was 1989.