3 ms·
This is pretty underwhelming without Zigbee or any "exotic" smart-home-specific hardware which would've been the main selling point of a HA-specific device. As
by Nextgrid 3y ago
This is pretty underwhelming without Zigbee or any "exotic" smart-home-specific hardware which would've been the main selling point of a HA-specific device.
As it stands, this seems no better (nor cheaper!) than selling Raspberry Pis with preloaded SD cards (or any Wi-Fi/Bluetooth-enabled general purpose computer for that matter), and is actually worse because RPis have much better ecosystem support (outside of Hass) and are easier to source if a replacement is needed.
I'm looking forwards to a turnkey Home Assistant hub that magically works with most consumer-grade smart home protocols (Zigbee, and upcoming Thread/Matter), but this is not it. "Buy this extra dongle to actually control your Hue/Ikea lights" is not going to compete with proprietary hubs that manage to do everything all-in-one and that most people already have in their house.
Big fan of Home Assistant in general, but this is a disappointment for me.
- dundarious 3y agoThe green seems to be targeted at people who could probably get a Pi and install an OS and install basic HA and schedule/manually do OS/HA upgrades and whatnot, but would rather just buy a box that does all that work for them. I know lots of people who can sweat their way through everything up to but not including upgrades, so for them, it's a good product.
- cbsks 3y agoSounds like you are looking for the Home Assistant Yellow: https://www.crowdsupply.com/nabu-casa/home-assistant-yellow https://www.crowdsupply.com/nabu-casa/home-assistant-yellow It has Zigbee 3.0, OpenThread, and Matter; a DAC; and an M.2 socket.