3 ms·
> I have mixed feelings about the IRS too but people need to remember they are chartered to enforce the law as it is defined. The issue is that they're classif
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> I have mixed feelings about the IRS too but people need to remember they are chartered to enforce the law as it is defined.
The issue is that they're classifying it as an investment instead of a currency but the rules for investments make in impractical to use as a currency.
Conceivably this could be better suited to new legislation, but it's not obvious that they couldn't have done something more sensible, such as treating large holdings as investments and small holdings as currency.
> we can see now by the traditional investment community trying to offer bitcoin ETFs, etc.
Banks will do whatever makes them money. Offering ETFs of any kind where they get a vig makes them money. Replacing existing payment networks where they currently get $0.30 + 2.9% with new ones where the transaction fees are lower and go to someone else costs them money.
> With the scheme you have described there are obvious avoision loopholes, such as people avoiding taxable events altogether by just executing all of their trades in amounts under the threshold.
This is not a new problem. There is a $200 personal exemption for foreign currency. If you have a million dollars worth of Euros and the Euro is up against the dollar and you execute 5025 separate trades of Euros for US dollars in the amount of $199 each, what do you imagine happens?
> The other issue is knock-on effects - this regulation would have to apply evenly across other asset classes as any language to specifically exempt crypto would also be nebulous and very gameable.
It would be great to be able to use fractional shares of market ETFs as a global digital currency too.
> It's clear people don't want to use it, they want to gamble.
The gamblers want to gamble. I'm still not clear on why a global digital payments system with lower transaction fees than credit cards should have no market in a non-adversarial regulatory environment. That seems like something people would want.