4 ms·
It's not LLM's writing for us, it's just autocomplete. If the suggestion doesn't match what you were already planning on saying, you just ignore it. The human
by crazygringo 3y ago
It's not LLM's writing for us, it's just autocomplete.
If the suggestion doesn't match what you were already planning on saying, you just ignore it.
The human desire to be original and authentic is always going to be stronger.
(It's much less effort to ignore it and keep typing your original thought, than it is to think about it, compare with what you were going to say, decide its version is better, and then accept it.)
- WirelessGigabit 3y ago2 problems with suggestions: 1) there is a sort order to them. And we don't know how the 'recommendations' work. What is a recommendation? Why is Google recommending something over something else? 2) it bogs down creativity. You end up not thinking and accepting the suggestion as 'good' enough.
- Tagbert 3y agoMost writing does not need creativity. It is wrote communication. If you want to put some creativity into something or write something where you want to write with some personality, then turn off the predictions or use it just for spell check.
- maroonblazer 3y agoMy job requires me to correspond with dozens of people over email, Teams, and Slack every day. We're all trying to get work done and need our communications to be as succinct as possible. Sure, occasionally I might dress it up to add some humor, but that's ~1% of cases. An AI, with access to my entire corpus of work-related communication, could likely very easily predict most of my communications, since they fall into a small set of categories. "When can I expect to get $workproduct?" "Here's when I can commit to getting you $workproduct" "What's the estimated date for $milestone?" "Here's the project plan for $initiative" "I can't make this meeting, can you be sure to record it?" I welcome any tool that can predict what I want to type and does it for me. I'm not sure if it's my imagination or not but Outlook and Teams seem to have gotten better in this regard. I'll take more of that.
- nojs 3y ago> it bogs down creativity. You end up not thinking and accepting the suggestion as 'good' enough. This is why I stopped using copilot autocomplete in my IDE. Once you see a suggestion, you can’t make your brain un-see it.
- fulladder 3y ago> The human desire to be original and authentic is always going to be stronger. Authenticity didn't start to become a thing people cared about until about the early 1990s, and it didn't blow up and take over the mainstream culture until the 2000s and 2010s. Prior to the 1990s, there was a lot of interest in professionalism. People spoke and wrote in overly formal, jargony ways that they perceived as being a marker for competence in some specialized professional domain. Being too honest/authentic would have been seen as unsophisticated and lower class. Just pointing out that what people strive to emulate can change over time. Once LLM writing becomes commonplace, it will probably become trendy to write in the exact opposite way that an LLM does!
- CharlesW 3y ago> Authenticity didn't start to become a thing people cared about until about the early 1990s… In your lifetime, but… Another common theme in the philosophy of both Dostoevsky and Descartes is the idea of authenticity. Dostoevsky believed that people must live authentically, in accordance with their true selves, and that this is essential for their happiness and well-being. Descartes, on the other hand, argued that the path to knowledge and certainty begins with the rejection of all previous beliefs and the adoption of a completely new and authentic perspective.¹ And of course, the U.S. counterculture movement of the 1960s was deeply preoccupied with authenticity: You note three themes underlying the American hippie experience: authenticity, individualism and community. Why did these concepts stand out, and what did they mean in the context of the hippie/counterculture movement? / W.R.: Although hippies often disagreed about beliefs and practices, they shared a desire to be authentic. Members of the counterculture condemned mainstream society for being conformist, rule-driven and uptight. Authenticity meant “doing your own thing.” Because freaks distrusted both society and government, individual decisions were applauded as the most authentic.² ¹ https://vocal.media/geeks/freedom-authenticity-and-the-mind https://vocal.media/geeks/freedom-authenticity-and-the-mind ² https://www.washington.edu/news/2015/08/17/uw-historian-william-rorabaugh-explores-60s-counterculture-in-american-hippies/ https://www.washington.edu/news/2015/08/17/uw-historian-will...
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoOne of the most famous American essays of the 19th Century is about authenticity. Self-Reliance, by Ralph Waldo Emerson (1841): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-Reliance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-Reliance