11 ms·
California woman loses limbs after battling bacterial infection from tilapia
- labrador 3y agoDamn, I live in San Jose and eat a lot of tilapia cooked various ways since I had Covid and can't stand the taste of animal meat anymore. I think I'll try salmon.
- footy 3y agoThis is a very interesting sentence, because fish are animals.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoDenis Leary - Animal Auditions, Cute vs. Food https://youtu.be/gq0tHt3qf-s https://youtu.be/gq0tHt3qf-s
- labrador 3y agoYou are right. I first wrote mammal but change it to animal, because I've never thought of fish as animals. I've never heard anyone refer to them as animals. I have never read anything that refered to them as animals. Edit: The Surprising Answer: Are Fish Truly Animals? Exploring the Debate Around Fish as Animals https://jerrysfishingblog.com/the-surprising-answer-are-fish-truly-animals https://jerrysfishingblog.com/the-surprising-answer-are-fish...
- greenyoda 3y agoFor reference, here's the scientific definition of "animal" - which is broad enough to include insects and various microorganisms as well as humans and other mammals: > Animals are multicellular, eukaryotic organisms in the biological kingdom Animalia. With few exceptions, animals consume organic material, breathe oxygen, have myocytes and are able to move, can reproduce sexually, and grow from a hollow sphere of cells, the blastula, during embryonic development. As of 2022, 2.16 million living animal species have been described — of which around 1.05 million are insects, over 85,000 are molluscs, and around 65,000 are vertebrates. It has been estimated there are around 7.77 million animal species. Animals range in length from 8.5 micrometres (0.00033 in) to 33.6 metres (110 ft). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal (Fish are in the category of vertebrates.)
- ritwikgupta 3y agoOut of curiosity, are you a Christian who observes Lent? Many of my Christian friends do not consider fish to be “meat” as that is not allowed during Lent, but fish is allowed, therefore fish != meat.
- labrador 3y agoNo but my Irish ancestors were Catholic
- DangitBobby 3y agoYou probably rarely hear them referred to as animals because people use the word "fish" to talk about them. But they are certainly animals.
- CalRobert 3y agoHumans are animals too for that matter
- drt5b7j 3y ago[flagged]
- labrador 3y agoIn a class room setting sure, but in every day conversation, no. Not on the West Coast of the United States. Kurt Cobain made the distinction and didn't think fish had feelings: And the animals I've trapped Have all become my pets And I'm living off of grass And the drippings from my ceiling It's okay to eat fish Cause they don't have any feelings - Something in the way Could you give me some samples of how you and your friends refer to fish as animals?
- drt5b7j 3y agoFriend 1: what kind of animals do you keep in your fish tank? Friend 2: In my fish tank I have fish, turtles, and snails.
- labrador 3y agoAccording to Google, you are the first person in the Universe to say "what kind of animals do you keep in your fish tank?"
- hydrok9 3y agoWhat people would say is: "What kind of fish do you keep in your fish tank?" "Oh, well, I actually have more (animals) than just fish in there." "Oh really? What else (what "other animals") do you have? "Turtles and frogs."
- drt5b7j 3y agoIf you use exact match, and craft a phrase that is 11 words long, it's almost guaranteed that you'll be the first person in the universe. You're just being disingenuous. Why don't you ask Google if fish are animals? You absolute moron.
- antonvs 3y agoThat “Jerry’s Fishing Blog” just demonstrates the problem with using google to try to support a point. It way overstates the “debate” on the subject. At least since Linnæus developed his biological taxonomy in the 1700s, fish have been considered animals. Here’s what Linnaeus wrote around 1758 (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pisces_in_the_10th_edition_of_Systema_Naturae https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pisces_in_the_10th_edition_of_... ): > Always inhabiting the waters; are swift in their motion and voracious in their appetites. They breathe by means of gills, which are generally united by a bony arch; swim by means of radiate fins, and are mostly covered over with cartilaginous scales. Besides the parts they have in common with other animals, they are furnished with a nictitant membrane, and most of them with a swim-bladder, by the contraction or dilatation of which, they can raise or sink themselves in their element at pleasure. And here’s a modern take, from https://manoa.hawaii.edu/exploringourfluidearth/biological/fish/what-fish https://manoa.hawaii.edu/exploringourfluidearth/biological/f... : > Fish are aquatic vertebrate animals that have gills but lack limbs with digits, like fingers or toes. Recall that vertebrates are animals with internal backbones.
- satvikpendem 3y agoYou have never heard of or read about fish being referred to as animals? Not even in your biology classes at school? That you haven't is extremely strange to me, I understand what people mean when they say fish aren't animals, in terms of the colloquial usage when referring to meat, but I didn't think that most people thought that fish literally weren't animals at all.
- footy 3y agoThere's no debate about fish being part of the animal Kingdom. If you've never heard anyone refer to fish as animals, you probably never took biology in grade school. I mean no offense, but literal children with single-digit ages know that fish are animals.
- mongol 3y agoYes and is not meat animal flesh? So it is double interesting.
- maxbond 3y agoMost product taxonomies will categorize them separately. Here's two examples trying to categorize tilapia. Google Product Taxonomy: Food, Beverages, & Tobacco > Food Items > Meat, Seafood & Eggs Note the distinction between meat and seafood. GPC: Food/Beverage/Tobacco > Fish - Prepared/Processed (Frozen) > Attribute: Type of Fish = Tilapia Whereas meat in the GPC is defined separately: Food/Beverage/Tobacco > Meat/Poultry/Other animals - Prepared/processed> ... Your local grocery store probably is organized the same way. Many people think of fish flesh and meat as being different things. Words are made up and all categories are artificial, whatcha gunnuh do.
- retrac 3y agoTechnically speaking, tomatoes and chilis are fruits, while strawberries are not fruits (they are fruit clusters - each "seed" is an individual fruit). This is such a point of contention (apparently) that there's a whole "culinary" vs. "botanical" fruit distinction made. Logically, eggs are meat. It's a giant animal cell. Culinarily speaking, meat refers to the tissue of mammals, particularly muscle tissue from pigs and cows and other ungulates. Fish usually excluded, poultry is often excluded, and offal may be excluded as well. It's for the same reason why we call blackberries and strawberries both fruits (even though they are not). Culinarily speaking, they're similar. Used in a similar way. Deer, beef, and pork are interchangeable in many recipes. Beef, chicken, and salmon, are not.
- maxbond 3y agoI agree fish are animals, but it's perfectly ordinary to use lay definitions rather than scientific definitions. Most people don't call fish animals, and that's fine.
- danielbln 3y agoUh, citation needed. I don't know anyone that doesn't call fish animals.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoNot necessarily scientific fact, but religion has historically differentiated between fish and other forms of animal meat (e.g. land meet). During lent, Catholics don't eat meat on Fridays but can still eat fish. In fact, some people practice it all year long.
- danielbln 3y agoOh, I wouldn't think of fish when I hear "meat", but that's separate from thinking of fish as something separate from "animals".
- maxbond 3y agoYou sure? Have you asked? Most of the people in my life have a strong interest in biology, my friends are nerds who are liable to use binomial names they picked up in Seek. But I doubt we're reflective of the broader culture. I think a lot of people couldn't tell you the difference between a kingdom from a phylum, and again, that's fine, it doesn't make them stupid or something. See also this comment for some citations about how they are categorized in the context of commerce: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37542165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37542165
- danielbln 3y agoThe differentiation you've linked is about meat vs seafood, which I would go along with. This is about using the term "animal" for fish, no?
- firecall 3y agoIt's idiomatic American and International English, and a perfectly reasonable distinction in conversation. :-)
- labrador 3y agoGPT-4 agrees with you and I: Q: Is common for English speakers using colloquial English to refer to fish as animals? They technically are animals, but people don't often refer to fish as animals in every day speech. Is this correct? A: In colloquial English, people often categorize living organisms in ways that may not align perfectly with scientific classifications. For example, many people might refer to "animals" as creatures that are mammals, birds, or reptiles, but might not immediately include fish in that category during casual conversation. This is despite the fact that, scientifically speaking, fish are indeed animals. In everyday speech, people might say things like "I saw some animals and fish on my hike," separating fish from what they casually refer to as "animals." This is similar to how people might separate "birds" or "insects" from "animals" in casual conversation, even though both birds and insects are technically animals as well. So, while it's scientifically accurate to refer to fish as animals, colloquial usage often makes distinctions that aren't scientifically rigorous. This is a feature of everyday language, which is shaped more by cultural norms and common understanding than by scientific taxonomy.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoIt's not the first time I've seen people claim to be vegetarians while eating fish. What's even weirder is the amount of people that don't know insects are animals. Some people have a really limited idea of what animal means.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThe issues are manyfold. Farmed fish, including salmon, and other seafood can contain nematodes that aren't killed by freezing in residential freezers. Your best bet is to source seafood from a reputable market, know where it comes from, and that it's sustainable. Wild caught is usually best, with lower parasite levels. https://www.cdc.gov/parasites/anisakiasis https://www.cdc.gov/parasites/anisakiasis https://scdhec.gov/food-safety-freezing-parasite-destruction https://scdhec.gov/food-safety-freezing-parasite-destruction https://www.seafoodwatch.org https://www.seafoodwatch.org
- labrador 3y agoI get mine frozen from Trader Joe's, Costco or Walmart
- olivermuty 3y agoGot a source for the wild has less parasites claim? I have heard the opposite a lot and have seen studies backing it. Curious to know if thats changed.
- murderfs 3y agoMy understanding is that wild-caught fish have more parasites, but they're required to be frozen for sufficiently long to kill the parasites, whereas farmed fish are exempt from this requirement: From the 2022 FDA Food Code (https://www.fda.gov/media/164194/download https://www.fda.gov/media/164194/download): 3-402.11 Parasite Destruction. (A) Except as specified in ¶ (B) of this section, before service or sale in READY-TO-EAT form, raw, raw-marinated, partially cooked, or marinated-partially cooked FISH shall be: (1) Frozen and stored at a temperature of -20°C (-4°F) or below for a minimum of 168 hours (7 days) in a freezer; [other temperatures/durations elided] (B) Paragraph (A) of this section does not apply to: [...] (4) Aquacultured fish, such as salmon, that: (a) If raised in open water, are raised in net-pens, or (b) Are raised in land-based operations such as ponds or tanks, and (c) Are fed formulated feed, such as pellets, that contains no live parasites infective to the aquacultured FISH.
- laurencerowe 3y agoThe article quotes an infectious disease expert saying, "If you are someone immunocompromised keeping an eye on these things and avoiding those high-risk activities and foods." It would be interesting to know whether the patient involved was immunocompromised.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoWikipedia says men are more often seriously impacted because estrogen is protective against the infectionthry think she had, so I would bet she's probably immunocompromised or has one of the other medical issues which increase the risk.
- hxii 3y agoWhat is it with geolocking content? Here’s a link through 12ft for anyone getting the “not available in your region” message: https://12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.kron4.com%2Fnews%2Fbay-area%2Fsan-jose-woman-loses-limbs-battling-bacterial-infection-from-tilapia https://12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.kron4.com%2Fnews%...
- bombcar 3y agoNews sites in the USA are terrified of the GDPR for unknown reasons.
- uoaei 3y agoI tried signing in to CoveredCA.com from an EU IP and was met with a plain-HTML "too much traffic or configuration error" page. Makes me wonder what kind of tracking they're doing (and what data they're selling)...
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoThe EU wants to claim worldwide jurisdiction so it just isn't worth the hassle for many companies.
- dvh 3y agoIs this specific to tilapia or is the species of fish incidental in this particular case?
- userbinator 3y agoAccording to the Wikipedia link to the bacteria posted in another comment: "Vibrio vulnificus is the most common cause of death due to seafood in the United States, causing over 95% of deaths that are known to have occurred due to ingested seafood." No, this seems to affect raw or undercooked seafood in general.
- mongol 3y agoThis sounds like one of the worst things that can happen to you. It is the worst nightmare. And it can also destroy your face, like your nose, lips, ears... How can you preserve the will to live under these conditions?
- uoaei 3y agoLook on the bright side, you could become an IRC celebrity (with speech input or other means) and no one ever has to know what you look like.
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y ago> How can you preserve the will to live under these conditions? You probably don't. I cannnot speculate about someone else and I don't know what's in her head but if it happened to me, I would hope I quickly die and my family can move on with their lives rather than watch me suffer for God knows how long.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoShe has children. For some people, that will keep them going. In her case, as a quadruple amputee, it would be difficult to arrange an unassisted suicide. So she may keep going simply because checking out is not really an option, especially during the immediate aftermath when people are more likely to feel incapable of living with this.
- zingababba 3y agoUnfortunately the will to death has also become quite difficult.
- nvy 3y agoHonestly the most distressing part about this is that in the world's most advanced economy, this freak accident which has already cost her all four limbs is probably also going to bankrupt her, and if her kids' educations aren't already paid for probably impact those too. It's like a literal game of Russian roulette. Completely baffling.
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoIf she lived in Europe, the impact on her kids would be much lower. I.e. she wouldn't go bankrupt and her kids would still have access to free higher education.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoThat's true for the commonwealth countries also. In many ways the US is the least developed of developed countries.
- ericfrazier 3y agoBut Russia isn't about to take the U.S. over, so there's that...
- nvy 3y agoRussia isn't about to take anything over.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoIncreasing seasonal ocean temperatures and low-salt marine environments like estuaries favor a greater concentration of Vibrio within filter-feeding shellfish; V. vulnificus infections in the Eastern United States have increased eightfold from 1988–2018. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibrio_vulnificus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibrio_vulnificus So this (likely) is another consequence of climate change.
- blumomo 3y agoSeasonal temperature changes != global warming
- DoreenMichele 3y agoIncreased ocean temps have been in the news a lot in recent weeks, so I don't grok this reply. Edit: Later in the Wikipedia page: Increasing seasonal temperatures and decreasing salinity levels seem to favor a greater concentration of Vibrio within filter-feeding shellfish of the U.S. Atlantic seaboard and the Gulf of Mexico... According to the CDC, V. vulnificus infections in the Eastern United States increased eightfold from 1988–2018 and the border of where these infections occur has migrated 48 km Northward each year.
- userbinator 3y agoI wouldn't trust "the news" all that much these days, given how much scaremongering brings in the views and ad $$$. As for the trend, what about the years before 1988?
- bagels 3y agoI think what that phrase means is that the temperature in one or more of the seasons has been increasing over the years.
- dendrite9 3y agoVibrio worries me, probably more than it should. There's also Amnesic shellfish poisoning from Domoic acid that can cause amnesia, brain damage and death. And Ciguatera poisoning.
- shmde 3y agoI had no idea Talapia posed the risk of carrying infections this severe. Me and my dad used to catch a lot of Tilapia in a nearby pond because they were dumb as rocks. Put in the same atta/wheat dough bait and they would come to the exact same place their fish friends got hooked. The fish tastes like absolute ass though, I dont understand why its so popular in the US.
- maxbond 3y agoIt's like tofu, it tastes like what you season it with (though maybe there was gross-tasting algae in the pond which they were snacking on?). Tilapia will survive in water that's nearly mud, at high population densities. Their natural habitat is lakes that recede dramatically, concentrating them and making the water quality poor. That makes them very easy to farm. If you manage the pH and nitrate/nitrite concentrations to ensure the water isn't toxic, they'll put up with very high densities and abysmal water quality (read: recirculating water that a thousand fish are pooping in, with an aerobic digester and perhaps brine shrimp to break it down but not a filter that needs replacing). They also grow very quickly. Tl;Dr they're cheap and can be flavored any way you please. (To be clear, I've looked into that chocolate milk water, and I ate a fillet of tilapia earlier today; personally I'm comfortable with it, if we're going to farm animals, we should probably do so efficiently. My feelings on whether that's humane are much more mixed. I'm 99% a vegetarian, this was a bit of a cheat day.)
- readthenotes1 3y agoMy first memory of tilapia was a tour guide pointing to a fish farm at the confluence of 2 extraordinarily polluted rivers. To the best of my recollection, I've never eaten it. I have the same picture in my head for most farm raised fish.
- verisimi 3y ago> “The ways you can get infected with this bacteria are one-you can eat something that’s contaminated with it the other way is by having a cut or tattoo exposed to water in which this bug lives,” said UCSF Infectious Disease Expert Dr. Natasha Spottiswoode. I understand exposing a cut presents a potential risk, but why does a tattoo? Is this person am expert or not?
- maxbond 3y agoGuessing they meant a fresh tattoo? Which basically is a cut.
- verisimi 3y agoWhy mention tattoos at all? Someone who has had one knows they are a cut. It's just wierd thing for the expert to say.
- userbinator 3y agoPerhaps there are many who think "it's just a painting on my skin".
- dancao 3y agoShe miss spoke. It is only for new tattoo and the skin is healing. A case like this happened to a man in Texas.