3 ms·
Except that there are problems with the emergency scenario on both sides: - In an actual urgent emergency, getting in touch with the 3 people and getting the d
by crazygringo 3y ago
Except that there are problems with the emergency scenario on both sides:
- In an actual urgent emergency, getting in touch with the 3 people and getting the data might be difficult and take days/weeks. One is on vacation, another is going to take a couple of days to try to remember where they stored the USB key...
- And nothing limits it to emergencies. The 3 people can just get together immediately and examine the valuable information inside, whether it's account numbers, crypto keys, a will, etc.
So the only value here is in not having to remember a separate password. But I expect it's just as likely for people to lose the files entirely as much as it is for them to lose passwords. If you share a password-encrypted file with 5 friends, I wouldn't be surprised if 10 years later, only 1 of them still had it. In that case, better to store file+password per-person, rather than require 3 of them to keep it.
- UncleMeat 3y agoWorse than that. "Oh fuck, I lost that thing" is going to be a common occurrence in these scenarios. Data lost forever. You can then go to K-of-N schemes or whatever, but the truth is that if you don't have a professional obligation to keep some data safe and accessible, people will simply lose it (and this will still happen in plenty of cases where you do have a professional obligation).