5 ms·
Cars and generational shift
- stcredzero 15y agoCommunity trumps commuting!
- orangecat 15y agoThe source of the unhappiness is not so much the commute itself as what it deprives you of. When you are commuting by car, you are not hanging out with the kids, sleeping with your spouse (or anyone else), playing soccer, watching soccer, coaching soccer, arguing about politics, praying in a church, or drinking in a bar. In short, you are not spending time with other people. I don't think that's it exactly. The problem with driving, especially commuting in traffic, is that it requires your constant attention but offers little mental stimulation. It's a boring section of life that you can't zone out and fast-forward through. Walking and biking are also (often) solitary, but I'd expect that people enjoy them much more than driving.
- polyfractal 15y agoAgreed about the "boring" aspect of commuting. If I have to commute, I prefer to walk or take the subway because I can listen to podcasts or read a book.
- _delirium 15y agoI think youth culture may have something to do with it as well, not just commuting; especially since the original article based its statistics on the rates of teenagers getting licenses, and I'd be surprised if those are primarily based on commuting preferences. In my dad's generation, having a car at 16 was socially a big boost, while I think it's just not as important anymore for teenagers. There was a heydey of "teenage car cool" in American culture with drive-in theaters and the like, and a long plateau where other car-centric things (like suburban malls) were at the center of teenage social life, but it's not clear that's (as) true anymore.
- peter_l_downs 15y ago> In my dad's generation, having a car at 16 was socially a big boost, while I think it's just not as important anymore for teenagers. > [...] other car-centric things (like suburban malls) were at the center of teenage social life, but it's not clear that's (as) true anymore. I'm a teenager. For what it's worth, being able to drive is still important for me and the majority of my peers. I think that you're right, teenage culture has changed since your father's generation, but cars are still a huge factor in teenage social life. Being able to drive is still important because of what it allows: a huge amount of personal freedom. EDIT: formatting
- aspec00 15y agoWe live in the "now" culture where everything is at our fingertips (at least online). Yet the one place we truly need (or at least should) get offline is when you are driving. Walking and biking also force you to get offline but you receive something worthwhile in return - physical stimulation. I think our generation is about efficiency and multi-tasking and driving (especially on long, traffic-filled commutes), does not allow us to do what we do at all other times.
- bstewartnyc 15y agoI live the burbs and commute to the city by train - but out here I love my car... I never need to drive in traffic.
- jostmey 15y agoThe problem with owning a car is that it takes so much time just to maintain it. Too many weekends have been spent taking my car to the mechanic, changing the oil in the car, preparing it for bad weather, ect. I own a car but I don't have time to actually use it. I will never be inclined to spend a lot of money on one.
- leoedin 15y agoPretty much this. I own a car that I essentially inherited. The cost of it to me in gas, insurance and tax is borderline unacceptable for the use I have for it. I can't imagine spending significant amounts on a new car because I can't see how the use it offers me would be worth it.
- leoedin 15y agoPretty much this. I own a car that I essentially inherited. The cost of it to me in gas, insurance and tax is borderline unacceptable for the use I have for it. I can't imagine spending significant amounts on a new car because I can't see how the use it offers me would be worth it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 15y ago> The move toward larger cities has been a trend all over the world for more than a century. It's hardly a distinguishing factor for people a certain age. What New York, Boston, Seattle, and Portland have in common isn't that they're big cities, but that they're dense and amenable to non-car transportation. Notice that he didn't mention Los Angeles or Houston, which are still big cities, but which are also relatively sparse monstrosities that are only navigable by car. > Further, oddly enough, there are lots of people, of all ages, who don't live in New York, etc. Why don't they move? Maybe because they don't want to. You're missing the point. A good way to measure the desirability of a given location is to compare rent, because rent literally measures the market value of living in that location. It turns out the market value of living in Seattle, Portland, New York, or Boston is pretty high, which is the free market's way of telling us that people want to live there.
- orangecat 15y agoNotice that he didn't mention Los Angeles or Houston, which are still big cities, but which are also relatively sparse monstrosities that are only navigable by car. I'll stick up for Houston a little bit. Yes, public transportation sucks and you need a car. But the near-complete lack of zoning means that most of the places you need to go are relatively nearby, so if you live close to work (usually possible because as you note real estate is cheap), you won't be spending that much time in traffic.
- rheide 15y agoLiving in central London I do not need a car to get around. I commute to work using the London Underground, and I have to say, it is the most unhappy time of my day to be a part of that system. I've lived in Tokyo for five years and have never been annoyed at public transport there, but after one year of London I've had enough. I'd gladly move to an open and wide space where I could get around by car. Unfortunately there is no such place in the UK (or anywhere in Western Europe) that offers sufficient employment options. Cars, public transport, it's a mixed blessing really.
- incongruity 15y agoNowhere in all of this do I see enough real data. Sure, there are statistics about purchases of new cars in the atlantic story and how that's decreased since a couple decades ago... Where's the data for used car sales? Where are the alternative explanations? Demands for disposable income are greater now, while actual earnings are lower. Student debt is at an all-time high and must-have devices like laptop computers, smart-phones, etc. didn't exist or didn't see the adoption rates that they do now. As for license rates dropping – if you knew you couldn't afford to get a car, wouldn't you be less motivated to get or renew your license? Further, America is growing more and more urban in population distribution – all of these things could conceivably roll in to a marked decrease in new car purchases without saying that it's an outright u-turn in "car culture". I may well be wrong, but the assumptions and unexplored alternatives make me less than convinced.
- forrestthewoods 15y agoLiving in Seattle a lot of my friend don't have cars. You don't need one to get around. The bus system will get you to and from work. They can walk or ride a bike to the grocery store. In short, it's not preferable but it's easily doable. The issue I have with this stance is that not having a car is fully dependent on friends having one! I feel like I'm subsidizing my friends because they chose not to have a car, even though money has nothing to do with the decision. (they make $100k+ working at Microsoft) Want to play board games? It'll take them 2 hours to bus, so only if I can give a ride. Want to see a movie? Sure, but the bus doesn't run late so only if I can give a ride. Want to go hiking? Want to go snowboarding? Go to a show? Get tickets for a sporting event? Can only do any of those things if I'm willing to pick up and drop off my friend. I do it of course because if I don't then I'll never see these friends. Maybe it makes me an asshole but honestly I find it just a bit selfish if you brag about having no car but constantly require rides from friends.
- jarek 15y agoHonestly I think this is an issue with your friends and possibly with where y'all live, not with living without a car. Do you live on opposite ends of town? The only trip I can imagine taking two hours one way is Ballard to West Seattle or something similarly silly. Going to movies? Going to a show? Even the Showbox in the middle of industrial wasteland is a 10 minute walk to the light rail. Hiking, snowboarding, sure, that requires going out of town. (Zipcar or rent.) Staying in town doesn't need a car. (And try parking in Capitol Hill and let me know about preferable.)
- sukuriant 15y agoI stand on the other side of this continuum. I'm 25 years old and I own a car. I _love_ my car; and, I often enjoy driving. I will often drive just to drive, even if this means being in relatively heavy traffic. Actually, I find that point where heavy traffic isn't a deadlock to be an especially fun time to drive because it hones my driving skills. I like feeling my car and being a part of my car as it goes down the road. When I'm alone, I like the privacy being in a car gives me as I can sing at the top of my lungs and no one has to hear me when I'm driving at free-way speeds. I'm even looking to the future where I can buy a new car that I'll be able to use on race tracks and in rally races for my own personal enjoyment. So, I like cars.
- politician 15y ago> I find that point where heavy traffic isn't a deadlock to be an especially fun time to drive because it hones my driving skills. I like feeling my car and being a part of my car as it goes down the road. For the well-being of the grumpy, late, and overworked commuters sharing the same stretch of road, please consider taking an adventure driving class instead of playing Need4Speed during rush hour.
- sukuriant 15y agoYou misunderstand me. I don't swerve between traffic at high speed, but I consider experiencing all of those cars around me and being mindful of even more things at the same time than normal while driving quite a bit of an experience :) Get to learn more about other driver's patterns on the road and all else so I can react even faster before poor situations come up, etc. Definitely a good concern, though.
- jarek 15y agoI don't know if that's a generational shift, but I don't have a car, don't want one, and actively look to live in places where I don't need one. I like driving. I like power; I like going fast; I like cornering just right; I like well-designed highways. But I can't imagine $200+ monthly loan payments or regular maintenance or breakdowns or getting ripped off on insurance because I am a male for the time being still under 25. If the vehicle I'm on breaks down, they bring in another one. If I want more freedom, a nice bike is the price of a beater car and a hell of a lot cheaper to run. If I want to go out of town, bus or rentals or shares will do the job. I don't know if that's generational. It seems common sense to me.
- eddy_chan 15y agoI really think the poster has missed one important difference between the baby boomer generation and their kids. The baby boomers have gone through a period of life where a car is absolutely necessity because they were raising families whereas to people under 30 a car is an increasingly 'nice-to-have' that affords personal freedom and social status both of which are becoming more questionable. The abovementioned 'period of necessity' changes your view on cars. I'm almost 30 with a pregnant partner and I've watched my car usage steadily increase over the last 12 months as my life is changing. I used to be a bike-to-work, walk-to-buy-groceries sorta guy who spent a period only using zipcars, taxis and public transport at necessary times and loved it. I really wanted this life to continue but... Throw having kids into the mix and all of a sudden you're visiting your own elderly parents a lot more, going to the hospital regularly, and I'll bet the car that as the kids are growing up they'll need ferrying to extra-curricular activities, friends places and driving holidays become much more economical. At first I tried to get by on a clunker but issues like your families safety come to the fore and I caved and bought a brand new car. It's just impossible to live close to everything. You'll have such a diverse range of destinations and reasons to go to those places (a lot of times at short notice which makes zipcar unappealing) that even if you take public transport to work or walk/bike you'll still _depend_ on a car unless you live somewhere as dense as Hong Kong, Tokyo or Manhattan
- jpdoctor 15y agos/cars/houses/g