13 ms·
> Unity lit money on fire for decades to buy a market advantage that overrules the basic economic incentives that supposedly ensure free markets work best for c
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Unity lit money on fire for decades to buy a market advantage that overrules the basic economic incentives that supposedly ensure free markets work best for customers. It was successful in doing that because it's very hard for a sustainable business to compete against one that is fine losing billions of dollars.
This right here is the most notable part of the article, and it is entirely correct - it has been for years. Venture capital is fine to use for actual ventures, to create new markets or hell, to break into a market with entrenched powers... but when it is used on a long time purely to undercut and destroy legitimate prior businesses (taxis/Uber, hotels/AirBnB, game engines/Unity), authorities should step in.
It's time to revive anti-trust, anti-dumping and other anti-predatory politics.
- dirteater_ 3y agoThey have won "market share" I'm not sure exactly which competitors they've undercut in the process? Are there any examples of a legitimate competitor that failed because they couldn't compete on price?
- MrStonedOne 3y agoEverybody points to uber but uber won against taxis because they had an app and taxis had a phone number that often wouldn't even accept a downtown cross st. As a seattlite who got tired of hunting for a building that still had a street number just to get a cab on 5th and Jackson or what ever I'm glad uber killed taxis
- brucethemoose2 3y agoIn Austin ~2012-ish, we had Austin Cab. It had an app. It was like Uber, but worse in every way you can possibly imagine and outrageously priced. I don't like an Uber monopoly either, but it doesn't mean the status quo was better before.
- bombcar 3y agoThis is exactly it. It would be like if no pizza place had mobile ordering and a new one started that had it; that was the killer feature. Everything else (I personally believe) was hyped up by Uber so that the taxis wouldn't realize what the real competitor was until too late. Now there may be taxi hailing apps, but nobody knows the name of them, and they're different for every city.
- Pulcinella 3y agoThis part of the article needs a citation. Unity has been setting money on fire, but it hasn't been buying a market advantage. It's been burning money on highly, highly, highly questionable (at best) acquisitions like buying Weta and Iron Source as well an insane hiring spree and then paying those people for years for work and churn that Unity never actually manages to ship in the engine.
- EricE 3y agoThey are trying to buy market advantage for their Iron Source acquisition - if you agree to use it then the per download fee's magically go away.
- yterdy 3y agoThe other elephant in the room is that the owner of Unity's main competitor is quite a bit larger than it is. I can't say that anything Unity buys would give it a market advantage.
- meheleventyone 3y agoSecond place and the niche for mobile which is lucrative and ‘XR’ which isn’t but could be isn’t too much to sniff at. I think it’s a mistake to think a healthy market is two companies or that the only thing spending buys is absolute dominance.
- yterdy 3y agoI don't disagree. Please don't take my statement as a defense of Unity. The intended implication was, "A market sans Unity is not a robust and competitive space, it's Unreal as a monopoly." I don't know if there are many other options for mobile, but for XR (in this phase where UX norms are being hashed out), I really hope that people look beyond the two, and even dark horse Apple, to what Snap is doing. Even further: look at what people are doing with Dreams on the PS4/PS5 (https://twitter.com/MartinNebelong https://twitter.com/MartinNebelong). Part of why this hurts is that we let ourselves be taken in by a singular platform... again. Maybe standards with plenty of authoring options instead of cottage industries, next time.
- fidotron 3y agoThe immediate follow up question is can corporate support of open source projects count as product dumping? We live in very interesting times while all this unravels.
- mschuster91 3y ago> The immediate follow up question is can corporate support of open source projects count as product dumping? For what it's worth, I'd classify true open source as the only exception to anti-dumping laws. If you want to burn money to fuck over everyone else, give up your competitive advantage.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> The immediate follow up question is can corporate support of open source projects count as product dumping? It can when the competitors are dead, and the patron yanks all funding and support from the project. I can't imagine trying to prove that in court though.
- CamperBob2 3y agoUber isn't a good example. They came up with a business model that literally required customers to get into strangers' cars. Eighteen nanoseconds later, the taxi industry was dead. There is no other possible conclusion to draw, except that the taxi industry had it coming. Fast-forward to today. The venture capital has long since run out. Taking an Uber costs at least as much as the taxis ever did. Yet, do you foresee any way for the taxi industry to make a comeback, except by holding the rest of us at gunpoint?
- _moof 3y agoWhen Uber started it was black cars only. Very, very different experience.
- Rapzid 3y agoI suspect it's still cheaper than Taxis would have been without it existing especially counting for inflation. But then, the biggest issue being solved wasn't price it was availability. You could call for a Taxi at a craft-beer pub in Texas in 2010 and it was a crap shoot the thing ever arrived or if it did maybe an hour later.
- turquoisevar 3y agoThat’s a decent amount of revisionism. Uber used VC money to heavily undercut the taxi rates, heavily inflate driver pay and decided to speedrun breaking as many laws as possible As for getting into strangers’ cars, getting in a taxi is no different. Do you think Uber was able to become as ubiquitous as it is if it didn’t heavily subsidize both sides of the equation and abide by the laws? I doubt it. Like you aptly describe now the fares as on par if not more than taxis, because now that they’ve attained dominance over the market by burning VC money, they can squeeze the customers and drivers alike. I’m not even sure if they’re turning a profit yet.
- finite_depth 3y ago[dead]
- justinclift 3y ago