4 ms·
In a free market for books, the publisher sets a price and then the buyer compares that price with other options and makes a choice. They can choose to buy it n
by lolinder 3y ago
In a free market for books, the publisher sets a price and then the buyer compares that price with other options and makes a choice. They can choose to buy it new, buy it used, buy a substitute, or even not to buy any book at all. In this situation, piracy is absolutely unethical.
Textbooks are not a free market. The person making the decision in the textbook market is not the person whose finances are at stake. The student is often left with only two choices: buy it new or buy it used.
Knowing that they are very close to having a completely captive customer base, textbook publishers do everything they can to make "buy it used" no longer an option either. As soon the used price drops low enough that people stop buying it new, rather than lowering prices they shuffle the problems and trot out a new edition. No extra work was done by the author to merit this perpetual $200 price tag.
In this situation, I can hardly begrudge college students who try to find an affordable option to get out of this scam, even if it's illegal. The textbook industry broke the social contract, so our ethical obligations to them are nullified.
- fractallyte 3y agoI agree! I'm disgusted with authors who sign up to this. There are alternatives (such as self-publishing) that would hugely benefit the creators. But, even more important is integrity. New editions only when necessary. Fairly priced. The software industry introduced the concept of 'upgrades' - that's equally possible in publishing now; no excuses.