3 ms·

This use case is well served by a non admin user as opposed to a machine where Dell is the root user. Furthermore what you desire for your grandmother is liable

This use case is well served by a non admin user as opposed to a machine where Dell is the root user. Furthermore what you desire for your grandmother is liable to be imposed on the rest of us if we want the privilege of banking or Netflix and in many cases grossly abused especially in less free countries including ours should we in the US fall into fascism. You would build chains for millions of people so that granny will have to give scammers her money some less convenient way. I'd rather not.

shadowgovt 3y ago
I think that really overstates the risk scenario. If we're going to descend into hyperbole, let's turn it around... If a free and open device is so important, won't some smart hacker always come along to build one? I'd rather my grandmother have an easy life and trust that Neo will be around to save the technorati eventually than make life easier on people who already know how to hack things they want to behave differently at the cost of my grandmother's sense of ease and well-being.
- michaelmrose 3y ago
  > If a free and open device is so important, won't some smart hacker always come along to build one? This just isn't how the universe works at all. We both grew up in the era roughly analogous to the early era of flight with 100 bad designs competing for most incompetent and are now moving into the an era of commercial jets and here you are arguing that planes wont make a difference in war. If you build an ecosystem where essential services like logging into your work, watching netflix, and banking require you to use locked down devices in which the OEM could be forced to build ANY restriction into the device but mostly use it to keep you from trivialities in the US and Europe you wont notice you've built a tool suitable for any oppression nor will you notice until the frog is well boiled. We have the bones of damn near total control in terms of difficult to root devices, remote attestation to ensure you actually are using such a device, AI to analyze data at scale. The difference between the tools we have now and 1984 is that the telescreen didn't sit in your pocket nor was Big Brother literally listening 100% of the time to 100% of the people. We are describing a literal system you could roll out without inventing anything purely based on existing technology and if you too live in the US then we are doing so in a country that has at least a 1 in 3 chance of descending into a fascist state.
  - shadowgovt 3y ago
    I mean... Netflix is clearly part of the larger control scheme in the scenario where the country is fascist, even as it is currently constructed. For everyone else, there'll be BitTorrent through VPN and good ol' fashion swapping of hard drives of bootlegs.

shadowgovt 3y ago

I think that really overstates the risk scenario. If we're going to descend into hyperbole, let's turn it around... If a free and open device is so important, won't some smart hacker always come along to build one? I'd rather my grandmother have an easy life and trust that Neo will be around to save the technorati eventually than make life easier on people who already know how to hack things they want to behave differently at the cost of my grandmother's sense of ease and well-being.

michaelmrose 3y ago
> If a free and open device is so important, won't some smart hacker always come along to build one? This just isn't how the universe works at all. We both grew up in the era roughly analogous to the early era of flight with 100 bad designs competing for most incompetent and are now moving into the an era of commercial jets and here you are arguing that planes wont make a difference in war. If you build an ecosystem where essential services like logging into your work, watching netflix, and banking require you to use locked down devices in which the OEM could be forced to build ANY restriction into the device but mostly use it to keep you from trivialities in the US and Europe you wont notice you've built a tool suitable for any oppression nor will you notice until the frog is well boiled. We have the bones of damn near total control in terms of difficult to root devices, remote attestation to ensure you actually are using such a device, AI to analyze data at scale. The difference between the tools we have now and 1984 is that the telescreen didn't sit in your pocket nor was Big Brother literally listening 100% of the time to 100% of the people. We are describing a literal system you could roll out without inventing anything purely based on existing technology and if you too live in the US then we are doing so in a country that has at least a 1 in 3 chance of descending into a fascist state.
- shadowgovt 3y ago
  I mean... Netflix is clearly part of the larger control scheme in the scenario where the country is fascist, even as it is currently constructed. For everyone else, there'll be BitTorrent through VPN and good ol' fashion swapping of hard drives of bootlegs.