3 ms·
> "The Libgen sites deprive plaintiffs and their authors of income from their creative works, devalue the textbook market and plaintiffs’ works, and may cause p
by lolinder 3y ago
> "The Libgen sites deprive plaintiffs and their authors of income from their creative works, devalue the textbook market and plaintiffs’ works, and may cause plaintiffs to cease publishing certain works."
This line was clearly not written for anyone who's ever been through college. I, for one, would love to see the textbook market devalued. The abusive practices employed by these publishers are thoroughly reprehensible.
When I was in college my physics professor had us use a Newtonian physics textbook published by Pearson (one of the plaintiffs) that was then in its 14th edition. He asked us to buy the 13th instead because it was affordable ($30 instead of $200), and he provided question mappings to the 12th edition, since the only thing that changed from the 12th to the 13th was the order of the questions.
If Pearson is really so worried about the textbook market becoming devalued, they should consider letting up on their abuse of college students. It's pretty much inevitable that faced with five $200 textbooks students are going to look for alternatives that don't involve paying Pearson what they think they are owed.
- metadat 3y agoFor decades, Pearson failed to invest and innovate in their market segment. Let them pay the market price -- It's only fair.
- pseudo0 3y agoTheir new trick is online assignments with automatic grading. The access code for the assignment system will be something like $230 alone, or $250 bundled with the textbook. Departments save a few bucks on grading and pass on the costs to the students. It's a pretty gross business model.
- anakaine 3y agoDepartments need to be helped to account by the student body. If your pricing is correct, and we are talking about a major 1st year class with 250 people, that's $57,500 for the privilege of issuing and marking assignments per session. For it to be saleable to departments I bet most assignments are already in the system and you just check off which one to issue. It's academic laziness at the expense of the students. The uni makes more money by saving on the cost of tutors to mark assignments in those bulk classes whilst the students are charged more. Its a gross financial abrogation of responsibility for the welfare of their students.
- pynappo 3y ago> For it to be saleable to departments I bet most assignments are already in the system and you just check off which one to issue. Yeah, think of Khan Academy but paid. The pricing I've seen so far in my classes (1 math textbook, 1 history textbook) is 100ish per semester for each textbook's accompanying service, 180ish for a yearly pass (eg. if you take 2+ math classes in consecutive semesters).
- qwerty456127 3y ago> and may cause plaintiffs to cease publishing certain works Okay, go on, stop publishing these. If a book is such nobody would voluntarily buy for a reasonable price DRM-free e.g. on Gumroad, it probably isn't worth existing. I doubt many people pirate content instead of buying it just because they can. People generally pirate what they can't afford easily enough and what they aren't excited about nearly enough to pay for (also whatever comes in ugly locked-in formats so a pirated version means better UX). In both cases they wouldn't be paying even if they couldn't pirate so there is no actual lost profit here. Except in cases when someone could unfairly force people to pay unreasonable prices which is the usual case with textbooks.
- goku12 3y agoWhile I completely agree with what you said, you shouldn't be surprised that these incumbents project themselves as a savior doing the masses a favor or as being some sort of victims. It's a pattern seen across the board with predatory companies - be it publishers, journals, hardware manufacturers, automakers, telecom.... The only unfortunate part is that politicians and the judiciary often buy into these posturing.
- stodor89 3y agoIs there some way to donate money to LibGen? Anyone who is hurting Pearson is a friend of college students.