7 ms·
> The implication that these are comparably impactful constitutional questions is risible. A century of a growing administrative state and sweeping anti-democr
by rayiner 3y ago
> The implication that these are comparably impactful constitutional questions is risible.
A century of a growing administrative state and sweeping anti-democratic social changes that have no basis in the constitution is pretty impactful.
> Further: zero is the number of Republicans that would accept the constitutionality of the argument you're making were the roles reversed.
Maybe, but the roles are rarely reversed because they’re not nearly as creative in their legal positions. Even here—imagine what more you could justify by looking at the “penumbras” and “emanations” of that clause of Article II! (Or the second amendment, or the tenth amendment, etc.) Just imagine a 6-3 conservative Supreme Court that all approached the constitutional text the way Breyer did.
> This whole thread of argument you're making is, and this is saying something, distinctively hard to assume good faith about.
I’ve thought direct election of the President (and Senators) was stupid ever since 1L constitutional law. The GOP is just finally coming around.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Even here—imagine what more you could justify by looking at the “penumbras” and “emanations” of that clause of Article II! You could justify a theory of an immense array of independent Presidential powers hidden within the penumbras and emanations of the phrase “Commander-in-Chief”, despite that phrase being simply a limitation on who has the apex command position over the military under the regulation Congress is clearly and explicitly given the power to provide for it. Just to pick one example of where the Right has demonstrated the exact creativity you deny that they exercise.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Even here—imagine what more you could justify by looking at the “penumbras” and “emanations” of that clause of Article II! To look at a different clause of Article II, you could justify a theory of an immense array of independent Presidential powers hidden within the penumbras and emanations of the phrase “Commander-in-Chief”, despite that phrase being simply a limitation on who has the apex command position over the military under the regulation Congress is clearly and explicitly given the power to provide for it. Just to pick one example of where the Right has demonstrated the exact creativity you deny that they exercise.
- tptacek 3y agoI'm not interested in the grievances. Both poles of American politics have grievances. Your argument that those grievances justify overriding the vote is risible, and the way you know that's true is that if Biden tried it, every Republican in America would justifiably go apeshit. Please stop trolling. Just: please, stop. Whatever problem you're trying to solve with this stuff, you can't solve it on HN.
- rayiner 3y agoYou asked about the “impact” of those interpretative questions. I’m pointing out that ginning up a fourth branch of government and overturning popular legislation left and right was pretty impactful. And I did not suggest anything was “justified,” because frankly that’s irrelevant. What matters is what the constitution says and means. It invests the ultimate power to “appoint” electors in state legislatures. States may choose to put that to a vote as a matter of state law, but I struggle to see anything in the constitution that would prevent them from overriding that law, even after an election. If a school principal puts something to the students for a vote—something that the law entrusts to her discretion—can she ignore that vote and do what she wants? Probably! Finally, I’m not “trolling,” I’m being quite serious. In the US, the state legislatures select the President, just like the EU President is selected by the European Commission. Direct election of the chief executive is a stupid idea, and most civilized countries don’t do it that way. State legislatures taking the power to appoint electors back after holding an election is politically messy, and may violate state law depending on the particulars. But there’s nothing unconstitutional about it. Neither as a matter of the text, or the underlying principles. (As to Senators we should repeal the 17th amendment, but that at least has a textual footing.)
- klyrs 3y agoI see now, thanks for clarifying. You're clinging to the independent legislature theory even after Trump's picks agreed, it's batshit stupid. Despite the profoundly idiotic nature of the theory, it still does not support the efforts of Trump to overturn the election through fraud and violence, which the Republican party has given its full-throated support to. But yeah, folks are still pretending that it's the Democrats who hate the constitution and rule of law. Good show.