3 ms·
> I assume that the argument is that a break in secp256k1 has an especially straightforward monetization Exactly. Considering the sheer effort put into Bitcoin
by Animats 3y ago
> I assume that the argument is that a break in secp256k1 has an especially straightforward monetization
Exactly. Considering the sheer effort put into Bitcoin, including volume manufacture of custom ICs, if this was possible, someone would have done it by now. It wouldn't even be illegal.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat I think your analysis misses is that the security of a cryptosystem isn't an absolute thing. All sorts of cryptosystems exist that haven't been broken, and may never be broken, but would likely get someone else broken if emulated in a different setting. So the reason cryptography engineers probably wouldn't use ECDSA in a modern signing system, if they had a choice, is that ECDSA includes a bunch of footguns that better signing systems avoid.