5 ms·
People keep mentioning this horizon broadening effect, I'm not sure where this comes from. My most horizon broadening experience at college was from learning t
by jiggy2011 15y ago
People keep mentioning this horizon broadening effect, I'm not sure where this comes from.
My most horizon broadening experience at college was from learning to look after myself and become more independent but that was not from the college itself.
Most of our classes were learning something about Java or about some algorithm etc.
Sure, some of it was interesting stuff that made you think but I don't think there was any extra value because I had taken a class vs having read a good book on the subject or participated in online discussion.
Most of college was people fretting over how much work they had to do for some individual class to avoid taking their average down.
The deep philosophical debates that everyone imagines happening at college seemed quite rare from what I experienced. I went to quite a good college too but most people were more interested in football, drink and women.
- pron 15y agoIt comes from literature classes; history classes; philosophy classes. Obviously not from data-structures class, although there's a lot to learn there, too.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThing is people still repeat this same thing in the UK where if you take a CS degree you will most likely take 0 classes in literature, history of philosophy since your degree will be focuses from the start specifically on the thing that you are studying. I believe most countries university systems work in this way too.
- arethuza 15y agoI actually found the more mathematical components of the UK CS course I did to have the "horizon broadening" effect - probably two-thirds of the classes we had were maths in one form or another. They didn't even really try and teach programming as a practical activity - you were pretty much expected to pick that up by yourself. Although we had to do a lot of development during the 4 years.
- hack_edu 15y agoThough can you opt to take these classes? That's the whole point, using the opportunity to broaden your own horizons and do what YOU want. If all you want to do is follow the script or syllabus, then yes, skip college.
- jiggy2011 15y agoPossibly but it's generally not encouraged. In my 3rd year I got to take 2 optional modules we were pushed in the direction of taking specific project management courses in the business school. I did take one module in English which was fun but nothing I couldn't have got from a creative writing class.
- wisty 15y agoSo, you learn to write an essay. "The question as to whether " ... "can only be answered by considering the subtleties, nuances and shades of meaning of both the question, and the state of" ... Then you write 3-300 paragraphs of purple prose expanding on this point.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoIndeed. Even though the liberal arts survey classes everyone was required to sample were by their nature superficial, they did provide at least some exposure to a world wider than engineering and math. I remember my American Literature class (at an engineering school), the first day the professor asked everyone to name the last fiction book they read. Every single person in the class, every single one, named a Tom Clancy novel. There was a benefit in pushing the horizons here.