4 ms·
Can affluence and affordable housing coexist in Colorado’s rockies?
- oh_come_on 3y ago[dead]
- dghlsakjg 3y agoCan it exist? Yes. Will it exist? No.
- purpleblue 3y ago100% agree. For example, theoretically a housing crash will lower prices. But it won't because hedge funds will come in a swoop up all the houses so that people become renters. The 0.1% won't be happy until everyone is giving them money every day for something that they own a part of.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoUS housing, especially in its most fungible form, the single-family house, is probably the most favored asset class in the history of human civilization. Act accordingly, and expect others to act accordingly. Expect others to act accordingly when you try to break that. Unfortunately, housing the investment business only looks like , and often moonlights as, housing-housing.
- swader999 3y agoIt does when I used to sleep in my car in the ski hill parking lot. Why the down votes? Lol, that's often the way it works. I was working two hours a day at the hill, free board and accommodations in a bus another time. Best month ever as a young adult.
- GoldenRacer 3y agoHow long ago was that? All the ski towns are now filled with signs saying overnight parking is prohibited. I'm sure you can still find spots if you're in the know but if they ever get popular, they'll be quickly shut down.
- swader999 3y ago1991, 2018 at a small hill. 2020 in banff and Canmore, agree it's getting more difficult.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoSomeone working part time for a few hours to get a ski pass, and otherwise living rough is different from people working full-time and still not being able to afford housing. Being a ski-bum is fine (I was one in college), but that's not what is happening.
- swader999 3y agoI agree, I was just pointing out the only way is live in car. It's a problem for the towns and businesses. I hire coaches for ski clubs and it's brutal. The other factor is the rental pool is going largely to airbnb so there's very little long term rentals in these areas.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoTotally. I'm just remembering back in the late-2000s when it was possible to get a room for $350/mo and a job for $9-10/hr in places like Durango. It wasn't luxury living, but it was viable to NOT live in a car, ski every day, and still have some fun money.
- Eumenes 3y ago[flagged]
- orange_joe 3y agoMy apartment in Manhattan houses as many people as a square mile does in Colorado using 1/10,000th the space. At a certain point we have to acknowledge that the government would rather you just be poor.
- Loughla 3y agoI don't understand how those two things are connected. Could you please explain?
- orange_joe 3y agoThe point is that it's absurd for us to ask if it's possible to provide housing for workers in these extremely small towns with vast amounts of open space. The point is that we have the technology, the means and the capital to solve this issue without visibly effecting the landscape of Colorado. A few small apartments would go a long way to helping workers live decently, instead we have chosen privation. If you wanted to double the population of Vail by adding apartments of the size I laid out (a midsized, 5 story building) It would take up .2% of Vail's legal area. I'm not really suggesting that -- but pointing out that the government would rather the working people of these towns to live out of their cars, or live in overcrowded dorms rather than allowing people the basic dignity of an affordable place to live.
- pif 3y ago[flagged]
- gtowey 3y agoThe name is a reference to the TV show Futurama. I don't think it's declaration of politics.
- orange_joe 3y agoit's Futurama, I really really loved the show. ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-K7o-bSLCHk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-K7o-bSLCHk
- 3y ago
- gottorf 3y agoSome places become more valuable as you pack humans more densely in it. Some places become more valuable with the opposite. "Idyllic mountain towns", of course, are the latter. Naturally beautiful places whose beauty in part depends on them not being highly developed will always have this tension between the vacationers, the rich second-home owners, and the people who work in the tourism industry. Tourist town economics are a reality.
- jlhawn 3y agoI don't think this is true. Demand and Agglomeration effects will always increase land/location value. The question is whether or not there is an increase in land value per capita. When you limit density then only those most willing and able to bid up the price of locations will increase the land value per capita. If you allow density the land value per capita will decrease (more affordable) while the total land value still increases. Edit: Any perceived amenity affect from limiting population density is really just a scarcity effect.
- orange_joe 3y agoThe workers are already there, they just don't get to live dignified lives.
- jlarocco 3y agoThe workers are not always there. A lot of resort companies, like Vail Resorts, will bring in H2B and J1 visa workers [0] and put them up in employee housing for the winter. They could hire plenty of US workers if they'd pay enough, but H2B workers are cheaper and complain less because getting fired means getting deported. Even the local workers are unlikely to live in town. Sometimes you'll see 4 or 5 lifties or ski instructors sharing a small apartment, but a lot of times they commute from cheaper towns nearby. [0] https://www.summitdaily.com/news/vail-resorts-h2b-workers-unsatisfied-with-response-to-covid-19/ https://www.summitdaily.com/news/vail-resorts-h2b-workers-un...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cschneid 3y agoThere's a common complaint I see across many local housing discussions, which goes something like: "We need affordable housing, but we shouldn't build to become <nearest metro>!" and of course the shorter "We're full!". But that then ignores the fact that the United States doesn't have internal movement controls. If somebody wants to move to a city, they can. The richest / most motivated group of those people will purchase housing until the housing is gone. In extremes this means knocking down old housing stock and rebuilding new (but not new density), or massive gut & remodels. Assuming the city is desirable enough (ie. a mountain town). You get this, and you must choose two: * Allow people to move into your city (Must choose this one). * More units / Affordable Units * Keep city 'character' by avoiding density. Some places choose character. Much of the Bay Area for instance, with 1.5 million dollar single family homes, and not one apartment as far as the eye can see. And others choose to build lots of units, although it's hard to find examples in the US. Tokyo is the one that comes to mind. Many people in Japan wants to move to Tokyo, and they build tons and tons of apartments to support that. The character of course was already big city, but it's grown into mega-mega city.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThe unstated assumption is that we aren't going to build new towns. Vail is a post WWII development. It used to be nothing. Colorado still has A LOT of undeveloped land. Water is an issue, but residential use is pretty small, and it doesn't matter if my residence is in Vail or a new town, I still am going to need water. The problem is that opportunity is, for some reason, being geographically limited to fewer and fewer places.
- gottorf 3y ago> Colorado still has A LOT of undeveloped land. Not just Colorado! I live in a state that's pretty much middle of the pack for size and density, and there's no shortage of open land around here. No water concerns, either, with plenty of rainfall. > opportunity is, for some reason, being geographically limited to fewer and fewer places. I think the economic history of the past few decades (at least) has been one of trading away resilience for higher efficiency; bigger and more geographically centralized economic engines that are more efficient, but are more vulnerable to shocks, as the recent supply-chain issues have shown. Covid and its aftereffects may reverse that trend.
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.md/gWaV2 https://archive.md/gWaV2
- zeroCalories 3y agoI don't blame someone with prime real estate for trying to protect their asset, I just wish they would be more honest about what they're doing. They want to hurt the working class to maintain their own wealth/lifestyle, but they'll use the left's language to pretend they aren't the problem. It's such a funny meme at this point. Oooo that's gentrification, that's like, racist, man. Don't you know it's the billionaires' fault? Subsidizing demand? Brilliant! High density housing? Don't you know that's just gonna drive up costs!
- agentofoblivion 3y agoThis article works hard to paint one picture, and then presents arguments and evidence to the contrary. It’s basically a sob story about local musicians and ski lift operators not being able to afford housing, as if that’s a new problem. Then: > Even as Summit County adds waves of remote workers, it has experienced net negative migration since 2020 You click the link of that data and it talks about how the local government is desperate to attract workers and full time residents, rather than having mostly vacant second homes. I presume they want to attract wealthy workers, given the choice, since that spending will be local and help the economy. So, assuming they get what they want, which is an influx of wealthy, employed people, it’s entirely clear what will happen to real estate prices. I’m sorry, but no one ever said you’re entitled to only having to play guitar in coffee shops to support themselves. That’s what college kids do, who don’t own houses.
- zeroCalories 3y agoI agree that no one is entitled to a home, but it also feels a little odd that people will turn around and feel entitled to an increasing property value and neighborhood character. The market giveth and the market taketh, except when it wants to take from me, right? Then suddenly democracy and taking care of the community is important.
- FireBeyond 3y agoAbsolutely. My areas is in one of the highest appreciating parts of the country, and has a housing shortage. The city started exploring "the missing middle" - medium density housing - we are either single family, or apartments. Commissioned studies, and the worst case of those showed year-over-year appreciation decreasing, from 12% to 9.5% per year. To be clear, people's property values were still going to be increasing nearly 10% a year, if fully implemented, and "worst case", but holy hell. You'd think the city was talking about taking people's grandmothers into the street and executing them, the screeching was so fierce about "protecting my investment". Never knew there was a constitutional right to double digit "returns" on property ownership, but to these people, apparently there is.
- peterlk 3y agoI’ve lived in and around mountain towns my whole life. There’s a relatively simple solution to this: taxation. If you don’t live there full time, you get to pay hefty taxes to the city/county. How do you verify this? Voter registration. If you’re not registered to vote at that address, you pay massive taxes. So, if you _really_ want to have a second home there, fine, but it’s going to be much less expensive for people who actually live there
- tricolon 3y agoNot everyone can vote or is registered to vote.
- gottorf 3y agoFor the purposes of shaping public policy, shouldn't the focus be on those who can vote? They comprise the body politic, after all.
- everybodyknows 3y agoThat's a fair point -- justice would require admitting alternate forms of evidence of residence. Maybe receipts from over-the-counter credit card transactions at local businesses could serve.
- peterlk 3y agoYeah, perhaps alternatives like permanent address on a government issued ID would be better. But exceptional circumstances should be the exception; the more exceptions are made, the more loopholes creep in
- thehappypm 3y agoI’m not sure. A mountain chalet is already a property tax bonanza for a small town. A $10m Deer Valley slopeside house would bring in a ballpark of $100k in property tax per year, and the people rarely being present means they aren’t even using community services very often. I don’t know if money is the problem. I think it’s more systemic; places like Aspen will NIMBY against any attempts to do meaningful housing projects.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoThere's a simple material angle that people aren't talking about enough with all these discussions Population growth has outpaced home construction (in the USA) for the past 20 years https://usafacts.org/articles/population-growth-has-outpaced-home-construction-for-20-years/ https://usafacts.org/articles/population-growth-has-outpaced...
- xnx 3y agoOne of the areas I don't see get enough attention in the housing affordability debate is the role of minimum size requirements. On top of the restrictions against multi-unit housing, even those apartments are larger than many would choose to live in given the option of something cheaper. Consider how many currently choose to live in vans, and would happily move to something of similar size with running water. https://www.planetizen.com/news/2022/05/117222-how-minimum-size-requirements-hamper-housing-production https://www.planetizen.com/news/2022/05/117222-how-minimum-s...
- xnx 3y agoWidespread availability of private and service-based self-driving vehicles is the wild card in all of this. By making long-distance transportation much cheaper (both in dollars and time), it effectively shrinks the distance between remote and desirable areas. The impacts of remote work, widespread use of delivery services, and self-driving cars are still actively working their way through the housing situation.