9 ms·
NASA says more science and less stigma are needed to understand UFOs
- blastro 3y agoAfter the Grusch testimony in Congress, I've asked a few people what they thought about it. Across the board, no one even comes close to considering this possible to be real. Even those who I thought would be open minded to the idea. It's kind of fascinating. It's amazing how quickly they explain away seemingly credible testimony from a real intelligence officer. I've been surprised.
- apsec112 3y agoTestimony is often wrong. The testimony for the Mormon religion is just as compelling (arguably more compelling) than any UFO incident, yet the vast majority of people don't convert to Mormonism. https://archive.ph/RsStS https://archive.ph/RsStS
- nobleach 3y agoMajor difference being, you'd be hard pressed to find many folks who would call David Grusch "not trustworthy". Smith had already been convicted of "glass looking" to find buried treasure by the time he claimed to find these golden plates. Further, how many of the witnesses were not related? Lastly, how many of the witnesses later explained that their "vision" of the plates was in the spiritual realm, not the physical? If David Grusch had showed up with a bunch of family members who claimed to have seen UAPs being dismantled with their "spiritual eyes", then perhaps I'd put his testimony on par with Joseph Smith (and Oliver Cowdrey and David Whitmer)
- tsimionescu 3y agoHe's an intelligence official, so he is a priori untrustworthy, isn't he? There is 0 reason to take something an intelligence official tells you on trust.
- david-gpu 3y agoPeople are not asking to "believe" his testimony. We are asking to investigate the very specific classified information he shared with the ICIG, such as locations, directors, first-hand witnesses and project names.
- tsimionescu 3y agoThe poster above was claiming that "no one is claiming Grusch is untrustworthy". As an intelligence official, he is the epitome of untrustworthy-ness. To start detailed public investigations, you'd first have to believe that his words mean something. Of course, I would expect some internal investigation into if and why he is claiming these things, if it's not already known. But I don't see why anyone should spend any significant resources (let alone the public at large) going by the words of someone who is payed to hide things from the public.
- david-gpu 3y ago> But I don't see why anyone should spend any significant resources (let alone the public at large) going by the words of someone who is payed to hide things from the public. If there is a conspiracy inside the DoD to hide reverse-engineering projects from congressional oversight, as Grusch claims, then there is a good chance that no investigations will actually be performed without significant pressure from the public. That is why public engagement is important. Public apathy enables corruption.
- tsimionescu 3y agoAnd if there isn't, the investigation will be a massive waste of money and time, and it's only result would be to maybe send Grusch to jail. And given how vague and fact-free his public testimony was, even that is not guaranteed.
- empyrrhicist 3y agoExtraordinary claims require corresponding evidence - simple as that. There wasn't anything that isn't simpler to explain through some combination of grift and delusion. Edit: I am specifically talking about aliens, insinuation of aliens, hinting at aliens, waving one's hands vaguely at something that sounds like it might be aliens, and generally treating aliens as equally or nearly as probable as mundane explanations for various reports.
- mach1ne 3y agoI've always found that saying dumb. It's basically stating that this is the null hypothesis, and you have to have p = 0.001 to convince me otherwise. When dealing with complex questions of which we have but datapoints, the probability of scenario A vs B moves in a linear scale, not according to arbitrary requirements of "extraordinary evidence".
- tsimionescu 3y ago> When dealing with complex questions of which we have but datapoints, the probability of scenario A vs B moves in a linear scale, not according to arbitrary requirements of "extraordinary evidence". That may be true, but I the case of interstellar travel, we have mountains of solid evidence to prove it's not possible (essentially all of physics for the last 100 years or so), and some vague claims with 0 evidence claiming it's actually happening. To convince us that all that physics is wrong you have to bring some extraordinary evidence, not claims that you heard someone knows someone who saw something.
- mach1ne 3y agoInterstellar travel is possible even with the physics we know. A sub-light civilization could colonize the entirety of Milky Way in a million years or so. The question is what the probability is for an intelligent species to evolve per solar system, and the more complex questions of how long they would survive etc. We only have a single datapoint (us) which only gives us the knowledge that intelligent life can evolve, but no direction whatsoever as to its probability.
- david-gpu 3y agoMy experience has been the same. While I find the publicly available evidence rather lacking, I don't feel comfortable dismissing the testimony of high-ranking intelligence officials and would like their claims to be investigated seriously. As for the general public, their thinking appears to largely boil down to "if something as big as this was true, we would already know about it", together with the circular "there has never been any solid evidence, therefore everybody knows this is bullshit, therefore anybody who talks about it is a kook or a fraud, therefore it is not worth investigating". I hope either Avi Loeb's Galileo project or the UAP Disclosure Act included in the NDAA 2024 bill will bring some clarity to the subject over the next couple of years. There are rumors of witnesses coming out later this year with first-hand knowledge of reverse-engineering programs, but I doubt the general public will be swayed by testimony alone.
- tsimionescu 3y agoWe have no credible evidence of aliens, and plenty of rock-solid evidence that high-level intelligence officials can lie to congress publicly with no repercussions (Iraq WMDs). The equation seems pretty simple.
- david-gpu 3y agoThen why not have Congress investigate the very specific claims he made to the ICIG (locations, people, companies, projects) and send him to prison if he was lying? Why the passive "it must be false do let's refuse to do anything about it, including bringing him to justice" attitude?
- tsimionescu 3y agoBecause his claims, at least the public ones, we're actually very vague, and an investigation is very likely to not find the things he's claiming, but also not be able to rule them out to a level where he could be indicted (beyond a reasonable doubt). So there is very little upside to the huge waste of money and time.
- dragonwriter 3y ago
- robdar 3y agoI also find peoples generatal non-response strange, though, I don't find Grusch's testimony that compelling: he didn't actually see anything, or really have any evidence. I find the US Navy pilot observations to be both more credible, and more interesting. Those I know who have looked into it, both IRl and online, both seem to take any debunking of the videos by Mick West to be the final word on the subject, but to me the videos are just short views into much longer encounters viewed by multiple people. The response of the public at large seems both muted, and a bit off. US Navy pilots claim to see UFOs? The response largely seems to be "They're just Chinese spy balloons or something, who cares, yawn". But then actual Chinese spy balloons show up and the public/media loses their minds over it.
- mcpackieh 3y agoNavy pilot David Fravor, who has the most compelling story of any of them, has also admitted to perpetrating UFO hoaxes on people for shits and giggles. UFOlogists have decided to lean into America's "troop worship", holding up military personnel as paragons of virtue and honesty because respect muh troops, to turn these pilot witnesses into unimpeachable evidence. But David Fravor admitted on camera that he thought it was funny to create false UFO sightings with his plane. When this same man then starts making claims about UFOs "but totally for real this time", it takes serious credulity to take his claims at face value.
- seanw444 3y agoI'd find it more concerning if it came from someone else close to Fravor that he'd trolled people before, but not from Fravor himself. He spoke about it on a public interview. Obviously it's not something he's worried about being known, and he's not worried about it hurting his credibility. Sure, it seems unlikely that someone who has hoaxed UFOs in the past would be the one to have an actual encounter, but UFOs are pretty common in conversation and on peoples' minds, especially in the last couple decades. I'm sure many pilots have wondered what it might be like to encounter a UFO.
- robdar 3y agoFravors "Hoax" involved flying F/A-18E Super Hornets at low level, at night, over campfires they could see along their route and lighting their after burners. This was done in areas like Nellis where there are a lot of military jet activity. Anyone watching from the ground with any modicum of exposure to military jets would have immediately known from the site and sound exactly what it was. He was putting on a show. Did he otherwise publish videos, pictures, articles, or other media to try to otherwise "dupe" the public into believing that these were "UFOS"? No. The context of the discussion in Fravors interview he was more jokingly describing some of the cowboy stunts that military pilots do that might be mistakingly interpreted as UFOs.
- nobleach 3y agoI am one of those, "I have no idea how I feel" types. Sadly I'm a bit apathetic. Perhaps there's life out there, perhaps each of these incidents has a rational, "it's a secret government project" explanation. But, what I noticed about that whole exchange with congress, was how willing folks were to detail information in a SCIF and how that's where it ended. Similarly with the NASA stuff, I'm hearing they were only willing to discuss public info and nothing that's classified. I'm not sure of the usefulness there.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- the_only_law 3y ago> It's amazing how quickly they explain away seemingly credible testimony from a real intelligence officer. Yes because intelligence officers would never lie to congress or to the public. They are established paragons of integrity and should trusted unquestionably.
- david-gpu 3y agoNobody is asking you to take Grusch's testimony as gospel. We are asking Congress to investigate the very specific claims he made to the ICIG, including locations, people and projects.
- lakomen 3y agoWhat I wonder, why would someone go out of their way and trying to discredit Grusch because he had PTS? Is that all part of the game to make his testimony seem more plausible? Or just a bad attempt at smearing his reputation? Idk.
- blastro 3y agoYou've misunderstood my point - I'm not saying he's trustworthy. I'm saying deciding whether or not he's trustworthy isn't such a black-and-white issue, and that I'm surprised at how black-and-white so many people are trying to make it. What if reality is more complicated and we're filtering out valuable information? What if he's not completely wrong, nor completely right? Just surprised at a lack of willingness to consider the grey areas.
- empath-nirvana 3y ago> It's amazing how quickly they explain away seemingly credible testimony from a real intelligence officer. Really depends on what your priors are. For almost everyone, the existence of aliens has a much, much lower probability than the probability of someone lying about it or being mistaken about it. As a sanity check, imagine a person with a similar background testified to congress that elves are real and have been kidnapping children and replacing them with changelings. How would you rate the relative probabilities of that being the truth or him being a liar or mistaken? This isn't really arbitrary -- there are plenty of people in the world who deeply believe in the existence of elves and little people.
- david-gpu 3y agoWhen you refuse rigorous research to be conducted in a subject, you can't act surprised when the existing evidence is lacking in rigor. Your priors are that it is unlikely to be true, and I respect that. My priors on the existence of dark matter WIMPS is also fairly low yet I don't dismiss people who are trying to find them.
- empath-nirvana 3y ago> When you refuse rigorous research to be conducted in a subject, you can't act surprised when the existing evidence is lacking in rigor. Alien fans say stuff like this all the time, but where is the evidence that rigorous research on this is being blocked? We spent like a billion dollars on SETI. There are volumes and volumes of actual science looking for extraterrestrial life. _It's not out there_. It's not like the skepticism about aliens is based on a refusal to look at the evidence. If aliens were real and they were visiting earth, you'd expect all of the instruments we have scanning outer space constantly would find _some_ evidence of ships or communication or life or _anything_. There is _nothing_. People don't take the supposed evidence of UFOs seriously because in the context of _everything else we know about outer space_, it's extraordinarily unlikely that our _only_ evidence of extraterrestrial life would be some grainy video of a lozenge shape object taken from an airplane. (which isn't to say that there's no life anywhere else in the universe, maybe some level of microbial life is common, I don't know, but if there were civilizations capable of interstellar travel, it would be a lot more obvious) Any scientist would dearly love to find any extraterrestrial life. It would be world fame and an instant nobel prize. It'd be one of the most important discoveries in the history of mankind. The idea that scientists aren't looking for alien life is just silly.
- GhostWhisperer 3y agopriests tell folks god exists, and folks don't believe them, does that surprise you too?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pmorici 3y agoThe timing of the testimony was pretty suspect with respect to other news about political scandals bubbling up around the same time.
- seanw444 3y agoTrue, but we can't let its strategic timing destroy its validity. We take in the information while still focusing on the scandals.
- david-gpu 3y agoThey also said that they are all for transparency right before keeping the name of their director of UAP Research secret; they thankfully recanted hours later. And while they also insisted that the stigma around UAPs must be left behind, the head of NASA described people who want more information about Roswell as "kooks". Therefore, I think it is fair to say that their messaging has been mixed, even within the confines of yesterday's presentation.
- flangola7 3y agoIt's possible Roswell is known to be nothing while modern UAPs are still unexplained.
- mach1ne 3y agoRoswell isn't known to be anything to the general public. The public has a similar fog-of-war on Roswell as it has on the modern unidentified aerial phenomena. Therefore stigmatizing one group unfortunately stigmatizes the other group as well.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe 'Roswell incident' is known to have been a Project Mogul balloon, covered up at the time for obvious reasons. Go look at the debris pictures that were published in newspapers and started the public obsession. It's a bunch of sticks and foil, obviously Mogul debris and obviously not a spacecraft. Anybody who still believes Roswell was anything extraterrestrial is either oblivious or a kook.
- flangola7 3y agoNot to the public but to internal agencies. They might know for a definitive fact that Roswell is bullshit, while UAPs continue to be an unknown variable.
- empyrrhicist 3y agoLet me rephrase that for you: NASA uses public obsession with conspiratorial nonsense to try and obtain more funding for real shit. It would shock me if there wasn't life elsewhere in the universe, but space and time are stupid huge, and the credulous nonsense from UFO enthusiasts is incredibly annoying to me. Like, sure - anything we don't understand should be investigated, and NASA is criminally under-resourced in all areas, but don't get annoyed when it still isn't aliens.
- edgyquant 3y agoIt’s amazing how more and more organizations are stating this is a real thing and every time detractors have a spin because they don’t want to have been wrong claiming everyone who was interested in UFOs was a batshit conspiracy theorist.
- empyrrhicist 3y agoIncorrect - I 100% believe that UAP are real phenomena, and that there are strong military and science cases for investigating them. I am annoyed at all the enthusiastic people actively presuming that it's aliens. Like... that's in no way a reasonable null assumption, and until strong evidence shows otherwise it's actively harmful and counterproductive. Meanwhile it's a substantial moneymaker for a lot of people, which is still more grating.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoIt's just https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps anything you can't explain must be aliens.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> It’s amazing how more and more organizations are stating this is a real thing It's amazing how exaggerated claims like that are. When you try to track down these organizations saying "ayy lmaos are real" you actually come up with organizations saying things like "the video is real" (and incidentally, shows an airliner 30 miles away) or "there are UAP" (translation: "It's an areal phenomena that we can't identify because the video quality is shit, and we certainly don't have any reason to conclude that it's aliens but we're going to call it a UAP because that's literally what it is.") The direct claims of it being aliens are all coming from obviously batshit kooks repeating things they claim they heard other people say. e.g. David Grusch.
- dvh 3y agoJust like I have predicted here 4 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21859896 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21859896
- cooldrcool1 3y agoNothing you predicted has been proven. Although I agree that is the most likely scenario.
- JoshTko 3y agoThis might be most plausible theory. Presumably going to US public also can leverage entire us population as a surveillance mechanism. Granted there would be a ton of noise. Timing also seems to make sense in that there has been heightened concern of surveillance by other countries. Could be simply fundraising.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIf NASA cares about understanding UFOs so much, why don't they assemble a small team of people to do what Mick West does? Take videos of ostensible UFOs, figure out where and when they come from and cross reference them against flight logs from airplanes to rule out most of these videos. Why is one retired ex videogame developer able to do this while entire government organizations sit around on their asses for years saying "oh gee we just aren't sure what these videos show, but we know we need more funding!"
- david-gpu 3y agoData that is gathered informally with crappy handheld equipment will always be of very poor quality. If you want to find out what, if anything, is out there then you need a systematic process of gathering data using calibrated equipment and a robust subsequent analysis of that data. We don't do astronomy by pointing our iPhones at the sky either.
- micromacrofoot 3y agobecause that guy is doing it for free, pretty much everything NASA does needs to be line up with government approved funding
- paganel 3y agoThe perfect 3-letter-induced psy-op (or maybe even 4 letters, if we were to let NASA in on this). Interesting how alien life has only bothered presenting itself as UFOs over the territory of the United States, people from other parts of the world don’t seem to have the same obsession (and back when they had it was mostly via US media and movies anyway)
- empath-nirvana 3y agoNon-scientific explanations of almost any phenomenon are going to be highly culturally dependent. It's not like it's new that people have seen unexplained things in the sky -- just prior to the modern understanding of the cosmos, people explained it as gods or spirits or omens or whatever. It used to be, in fact, that many more things in the sky were 'unexplained' (Comets, super novas, aurora, lightning, etc) and now we're reduced to a much smaller number of unexplained things. It's a normal thing for people to look for the intentional action of some entity for anything that's unexplained, and in a lot a people it takes on a religious or spiritual character. For some people, aliens (and conspiracy theories in general) are their religious explanation for things they don't understand. I think for us to have a scientific explanation for any of this stuff that _actually_ lands on aliens, you're going to have to systematically eliminate every other possible explanation, and the eventual theory would have to then go on to explain a large number of other phenomena in consistent ways.
- celtoid 3y agoThe Military-intelligence sector has a long history of pushing things out that are less than true, often for the benefit of the national security state. This UFO/UAP guff is great cover for the advanced AI piloted aircraft/spacecraft sightings that will be inevitable in the coming years. Bonus: The Controlled Disclosure Campaign Plan [0] [0] https://www.congress.gov/118/crec/2023/07/18/169/123/CREC-2023-07-18-pt1-PgS3009.pdf https://www.congress.gov/118/crec/2023/07/18/169/123/CREC-20...
- RandomLensman 3y agoEvery generation for the last 80 years or so we seem to go through some "UFO phase" with agencies, politicians, etc. getting airtime or funding etc. - seems like it always needs rediscovering that there is nothing relevant there.
- qiine 3y agoMaybe its because people can't accept that there is just nothing, its too boring to the human mind.
- julianeon 3y agoThis reminds me of something I’ve never understood about the UFO conversation- especially about people who believe in it. Shouldn’t the conversation primarily be about radar and sensor evidence? Not videos or (worse) eyewitness accounts, which should be the thing we talk about last. Whenever there is a field which is too complicated or hard to track accurately by humans, we turn to computers. A good example: high frequency trading. Another example: the calculations and work machines do in all kinds of factories. It’s too fast for the human mind to do and also it would be inaccurate, so we design machines that can do it, and rely on them. I think the UFO conversation should primarily be about conversations like this: “We have this radar data which we consider trustworthy (explain why). It doesn’t have any pictures to go along with it, but if you look at the numbers, it shows a vehicle accelerating at very high speed. It isn’t much for the senses, BUT because of the way the data is collected, we have very, very high confidence that this vehicle acted in exactly the way described. It’s definitely not a hallucination, which isn’t possible on a radar system, and here are the reasons why it’s not an error…” It seems to me that this is where most “serious” UFO conversations of the type NASA is describing should start. Yet I can’t name a single one which fits this description.
- david-gpu 3y agoI agree. Unfortunately military radars are classified systems, and civil radars do not currently publish any such information systematically either. So we are left with anecdotes. If people started demanding such data to be collected systematically and published, then it could be researched. But for the most part the stigma around the subject makes people not bother asking for these sort of things.
- ignorethefacts 3y agoIf NASA puts their satellites in space with their new fancy UFO detectors, and they start detecting many UFOs in the absence of eye witness accounts, do you believe them? It is very dangerous to discredit human accounts and trust a process that cannot be verified. Be skeptical of any claims that aliens are real, no matter who is making the claim.
- nvm0n2 3y agoThat's already happened many times. It doesn't really lead anywhere because if radar tracks are all you have there's nothing to investigate. But for example US air traffic and military radar control has had a bunch of cases like that.
- bdw5204 3y agoUFOs are likely either hallucinations or top secret experimental DoD projects. Some of them might also be spying devices from foreign governments like that suspected Chinese spy balloon that the government shot down earlier this year. I can't blame NASA for using the obsessions of conspiracy kooks as a rationale to push for more funding for things that would actually be worth looking into. It is also obviously worthwhile for the government to know what is flying in its airspace. I do think it's pretty much a certainty that alien life exists somewhere given how many earth-like planets exist but it clearly lacks either the technology to or the interest in contacting us. It is also plausible that faster than light travel might be flat out impossible which would make intergalactic travel more or less completely infeasible given how the nearest known galaxy is 25,000 light years away. Even light speed travel would mean over 4 years of travel just to get to Alpha Centauri (or to communicate with it) which is not feasible to maintain any kind of effective political control over colonies.[0] If extraterrestrial life has developed faster than light travel and wishes to contact us, they will contact us and we will know about it. That isn't something the government will be able to cover up. They also aren't going to be able to determine which countries are the most powerful countries before they contact us because this would not be obvious to an outside observer with no preexisting knowledge of human society. [0]: A perfect example of this being how the orders of European monarchs were routinely ignored in their American colonies when it took mere months to travel between Europe and America. A very significant portion of the abuses during colonial times happened in direct defiance of the relevant king's orders because there was virtually nothing his majesty could do to stop rogue colonial officials given the communications difficulties. Any interstellar colony would, without faster than life travel, be de facto completely independent and unaccountable to Earth. Even if there was a Hitler tier criminal running an Alpha Centauri colony who was genociding the native population and carrying out wars of aggression against other colonies, who would commit to an approximately 9 year or more round trip from Earth to defeat and arrest this criminal?
- osigurdson 3y agoHow can likelihood that another earth like planet exists be “a least a trillion”? Probability should be expressed as a scalar in the range 0-1. Do they mean there are at least a trillion other planets or probability is 1 in at least a trillion?
- xeromal 3y agoYeah, that confused me too. I'm not sure what a trillion means in this context.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lakomen 3y agoI've been following this, not seriously, since I was a teen, then on the internet in forums, on Winamp video, on ATS and then the disclosure project, when was it 2000, 2001? Funny, I just tried a Google search, previously it was an easy result, now I have to specify Greer in the query and even then the results are bad, as if they were removed. So after some specific searching, it was on May 9th, 2001. There it was, a UFO press conference with military and ex-military people. However it was always missing hard evidence. And the best, access to further information required donations. The more one donated, the more information one could access. Fishy AF. And soon it was more or less forgotten. If they really wanted disclosure, they wouldn't had locked the information behind paywalls. Meanwhile this group around Greer produces a new film ever 1-3 years and puts it on Amazon Video. They have sessions and even a "CE5" app. Contact of the fifth kind. Of course you need to install an app to make contact... Sus af. He also has a YouTube channel. It's always, big announcements, breaking news. This year, 2023, they did another press conference, 2 days after the pride parade (which was wild) in Washington DC. Again, no hard evidence, drawings. No fotos. Touching stories but no evidence. It was either in this conference or in his YouTube videos that he said that there were various groups who wanted disclosure and that they'd make a move in the next 3 years. That their patience was at an end. But it's interesting what he says. Essentially that all research into free energy and anti gravity was brutally ended and stolen by those "black projects" powers/groups/people. Remember the Czech guy with the encryption that couldn't be broken, what was it called again? Truecrypt, right? The project was halted under mysterious circumstances. If you read between the lines, he was threatened. Greer team claims the same has happened to those free energy and anti gravity projects. And that it has been going on since around ww2. On one hand I have wishful thinking that there really is free energy, Tesla is cited and his confiscated work. On the other hand... Why is there always this secrecy? Weird enough a few months after the 2023 disclosure project press conference, Grush and the other 2 (sorry forgot the names) testify under oath. Reflecting, I'm at that point now that I doubt or let's say, that those testaments under oath are no big deal for me. Was that maybe Greer team's purpose? To make actually real testimonials seem implausible? I don't know. Fact is that this planet, that we're destroying our environment. That this will lead to death, wars. And that we're still not stopping those cars to drive and we're still doing nothing against the freaking elephant in the room, cars and fossil fuel consumption by them. Day in day out. As someone without influence all I can do is watch, helpless. And talk about it. But the powers that be are too intimidated by the oil mafia. Probably also in their pocket. Imagine Germany without a car industry. I fear there needs to be the big bang first before something changes. How many floods this year alone? Record sea temperatures. A good lie always has some truth in it. We're in this age where you can't believe anything anymore, I read that's also part of how KGB did disinformation. You just flood people with opposing information, so they can't determine what's true anymore. All I know is, hard evidence is missing. And everything else is just entertainment. Show us the evidence.
- Gud 3y agoInterestingly, the top comment is nothing but stigmatizing UFO research and hand waving away this as NASA wanting to ride on the public’s current UFO curiosity for other motives.
- ignorethefacts 3y agoArticles like these exist primarily to shift the Overton window. One day they will convince you aliens are real. They are not real.