3 ms·
Positive Geometries and Amplitudes [pdf]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qnleigh 3y agoFascinating that this is getting so much traction on Hacker News, given how technical and physics-specific it is. Guess there's a lot of physicists on here (hi all!) This PDF is a summary of a really interesting and surprising research direction in modern theoretical physics. It came out of trying to explain why certain extremely complex calculations gave unexpectedly simple results. People like Nima Arkani-Hamed thinks that it a sign of new/deeper principles underlying the current laws of physics, though not everyone follows the logic quite this far. See https://www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-discover-geometry-underlying-particle-physics-20130917/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-discover-geometry-...
- bloopernova 3y agoThat article is pretty mind blowing! "A sketch of the amplituhedron representing an 8-gluon particle interaction. Using Feynman diagrams, the same calculation would take roughly 500 pages of algebra." That excerpt is pretty wild. 500 pages "compressed" into one geometric shape.
- gexaha 3y agoHas there been any progress in the last 10 years since the discovery of amplituhedron?
- qnleigh 3y agoI'm not the best person to answer this, but my understanding is yes. The claim is that it's an almost ubiquitous phenomenon; many theories, I think even including non-supersymmetric theories, have something similar going on where a geometric object can determine the results of certain Feynman diagram calculations (maybe still only at tree level). There was even an example I saw in a lecture where some topics that would be taught in a first year quantum field theory course fit into this framework. Nima Arkani-Hamed has a bunch of lectures on YouTube that are pretty entertaining, and while they can get quite technical, he says a lot that can be appreciated without understanding the details.
- gexaha 3y agoThanks! I saw a couple of his lectures on YouTube, and it's very difficult to understand, whether it is just marketing, or there is some progress going on in the topic
- doener 3y agoChatGPT answer: Positive geometries and amplitudes, in the context of theoretical physics, refer to relatively new developments that have profound implications for our understanding of the universe. Here's a brief overview: 1. *Positive Geometries*: Positive geometries are certain geometric structures that possess only positive values when certain measurements are taken. These geometries have become central to the study of scattering amplitudes in quantum field theory. 2. *Scattering Amplitudes*: In quantum field theory, scattering amplitudes describe the probability for particles to scatter off each other in certain ways. The philosophical implications of these topics are manifold: 1. *Simplicity Underlying Complexity*: The fact that such complex phenomena (like particle interactions) can be described using simple geometric structures implies that there might be a deeper, simpler structure underlying the apparent complexity of the universe. 2. *Emergent Reality*: The geometric approach to scattering amplitudes suggests that the reality we observe might be an emergent phenomenon from more fundamental geometric entities. This is in line with other theories in physics, like string theory, where the fundamental entities aren't particles but strings. 3. *Unity of Physics*: Positive geometries and the study of amplitudes may bridge gaps between seemingly disparate areas of physics. If different phenomena can be described using the same mathematical framework, it might suggest a unified theory of everything. 4. *Nature of Mathematical Truth*: The success of positive geometries in describing physical phenomena raises questions about the nature of mathematical truth. Why do abstract mathematical concepts so accurately describe physical reality? Is math a human invention or a discovery of the fundamental structure of the universe? 5. *Determinism vs. Probabilities*: Quantum mechanics is inherently probabilistic, which challenges traditional notions of determinism. If scattering amplitudes represent probabilities, then we're accepting that at fundamental levels, outcomes aren't deterministic but probabilistic, reshaping our philosophical views on causality and determinism. 6. *Nature of Space and Time*: Traditional concepts of space and time have been continually challenged throughout the history of physics, especially with relativity and quantum mechanics. Positive geometries and amplitudes further hint that our classical understanding of space and time may just be emergent or approximate descriptions of a more profound reality. While these are just initial thoughts, the deeper exploration of positive geometries and amplitudes will likely yield even more philosophical implications as our understanding evolves.
- 3y ago