4 ms·
As I'd commented on the recent WTFH1971 article, the world was already facing an unprecedented rush on gold due to oil imports: "We made an agreement with Ibn
by dredmorbius 3y ago
As I'd commented on the recent WTFH1971 article, the world was already facing an unprecedented rush on gold due to oil imports:
"We made an agreement with Ibn Saud that we would give him gold. For every ton of oil we took out of his country we would give him gold. And we did at first. Then we got to be producing more and more and more, and we would try to find more gold shillings to meet the requirements so we could ship another ton. And we had to tell him we couldn't find any more gold. There wasn't that much gold. We had now such an enormous business that we cleaned the world of gold shillings."
From The Prize, Part 5: Crude Diplomat, at 31:24.
<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=k7g5UMxDZIg&list=PLYkO4hiKyrSRjZLQunIjgCsz4GrpDGPfN&index=4?t=31m24s https://yewtu.be/watch?v=k7g5UMxDZIg&list=PLYkO4hiKyrSRjZLQu...>
In: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37490086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37490086>.
Goldbugs and Austrians tend to assert that monetary devaluation feeds economic disruption. My argument is that it's the reverse: extraordinary economic demand, debt accumulation, and balance-of-trade imbalances drive* currency devaluations. This is most evident in the devaluation of specie-based currencies, such as the decrease of silver purity of the Roman denarius from 99.9% to less than 4%: <https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/104458039290116Y https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/104458...>.
I'd argue that the 1971 transition had less to do with EROEI than it did on more traditional balance-of-trade dynamics, but that yes, US mainland oil production did peak in 1971, and that peak was a harbinger of higher EROEI costs to come, as evidenced through oil extraction in Alaska, shallow-water off-shore in the Gulf of Mexico, deep-water, and oil and gas shale and tar-sands. But thanks largely to the vast (and cheaply-extracted) reserves of Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf states, those developments were largely offset by decades.
Still, energy costs for American manufacturers and the public exploded fourfold virtually overnight with the 1973 oil embargo, and were driven even higher by the 1979 Iranian Revolution. That impacted heavily on the ability to support high-wage industrial activity in the US, and many subsequent trends including offshoring of manufacturing, decimation of unions, financialisation of the US economy and especially sectors such as housing and real estate, etc.
Which the Austrian explanation answers quite poorly.