3 ms·
> My point is only how quickly americans adopt this "if someone's buying, it's excusable" morality as applied to business. I'm not sure why you're talking abou
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> My point is only how quickly americans adopt this "if someone's buying, it's excusable" morality as applied to business.
I'm not sure why you're talking about Americans, but my point is that the main thing a business does is create employment and useful goods or services.
> As-if politics were a place of heroic powerful individuals, and business merely a mechanism.
No, creating employment and useful goods or services is extremely important and heroic. It's just different to being the person who takes money from others on the sole basis that he/she will be impartial and not take bribes.
- AYBABTME 3y ago> I'm not sure why you're talking about Americans As a foreigner in America, I think America is culturally particularly business oriented and holds favorable views on business activities (until they get too large and obscure, then they become led by lizards or some such), and in particular I think the average person here is more prone to think that it's ok for a business or person to seek to maximize their position in the market by almost any legal means. As in, if the player is good at the game, you can't blame the player (up to a point).
- robertlagrant 3y agoThey should maximise by legal means. That's how you get better service, lower prices and better products. That's why computers aren't $1m each or still in the KHz CPU range. Or why every company is now making electric cars. Or... why most things are as good as they are.
- mjburgess 3y agoBut that's an naive ideological take on the virtues of business; whilst at the same time you offer a naive cynical take on the vices of politics. D'you not see this sort of double-think taking place? Exactly the same naive gloss can be given of policitians: their compromises are part of the democratic process by which competing power interests are balanced without oppression. There are no Company Stores, or Company Scrips because corporate power is given "an inch" but no more. And there are FDAs and the like because Society gets its two inches. And so on. Politicans are creatures of a mechanism as much as businesses. This "reduce one to mere mechanism, but not the other" is pure naive ideology. Business does not "offer better prices" etc. through this mechanism. It offers prices every bit as flawed as politics offers policies.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> But that's an naive ideological take on the virtues of business; whilst at the same time you offer a naive cynical take on the vices of politics. I don't think that's a virtue of businesses. It's their primary function, and their primary good: producing useful stuff or services for their customers, and employment to their employees. The more useful their product/service, the more money they get, and the better their customers' and employees' lives will be. If they campaign to make that easier by making regulation less onerous, that's in pursuit of those primary goals. That's different to a government job (e.g. in regulation-setting/enforcing) where their sole job is to set and maintain good standards in their area. They provide no value other than that, and if they aren't even doing that, then they're worse than useless. They're useless and they cost money we aren't allowed to refuse to pay.
- mjburgess 3y ago> It's their primary function, and their primary good: producing useful stuff or services for their customers This claim is a specific ideological interpretation of business, call it "consumer capitalism". You can reject than and believe say, "social capitalism" or "democratic capitalism". Where the purpose of business is to, on net, improve society -- and is given a licence to operate only insofar as, on net, it does so. > their sole job is to set and maintain good standards in their area Again, call this "noble bureaucracy". You could instead believe, "resolution bureaucracy" where the job of bureaucracy is to prevent conflict, not to resolve to an ideal.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> You can reject than and believe say, "social capitalism" or "democratic capitalism". Where the purpose of business is to, on net, improve society -- and is given a licence to operate only insofar as, on net, it does so. You could do, but then you have to invent a currency to award to people who you think improve society from your perspective. Or you could just use the existing one.
- 3y ago