3 ms·
> I don't know why Wayland gets so much hate. To me it feels very much like the systemd hate: I don't know why this needs to change; I was happy after all. I do
by yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago
> I don't know why Wayland gets so much hate. To me it feels very much like the systemd hate: I don't know why this needs to change; I was happy after all. I don't want to learn about a new thing, so I'm angry.
Yes, it's a very similar situation; in both cases people are really fond of pretending that the only reason you could possibly object is that you hate change just because, while ignoring the actual regressions that it's causing. For instance, Wayland does not support (and probably never will support) some accessibility tools that make my life much easier (because the desktop must be secured against programmatic manipulation).
- uecker 3y agoI use X remoting every day. Being told that I do not need it and it would not work anyway, is what makes me angry. Then I hate that decades of protocol compatibility are broken, which i think is sad and stupid. Finally, I saw people had issues with Wayland (screen sharing etc). Then - after 15 years of development - being somewhat usable also does not convince me that it is so much simpler because of an superior design. Regarding design, I think the monolithic design is inferior. Finally, I never found the technical arguments terrible convincing (such as that an unused old line drawing API in X somehow holds modern clients back - obviously this is BS.).
- esarbe 3y agoThanks for providing some context. I still don't get one point though; Nobody is taking X away. You can still run any DE and any application on X if you want to. You're not being restricted in your ability to run applications, quite the contrary; your are being given more options. So even if your use-case is not yet fully supported on Wayland, why hat on it? No one is taking anything away. But yeah; ever since Sun stopped founding it, the accessibility situation on Linux has been dire.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> You can still run any DE and any application on X if you want to. That's unfortunately incorrect; so far Waydroid is the only program I've hit that explicitly requires Wayland, but I expect the list to grow with time. > So even if your use-case is not yet fully supported on Wayland, why hat on it? No one is taking anything away. Because it's abundantly clear that a noticeable set of devs and maintainers would really like to take it away, or at least refuse to support it (if there's a difference); see ex. https://social.treehouse.systems/@marcan/110354541574112092 https://social.treehouse.systems/@marcan/110354541574112092 where the lead dev on Asahi Linux seems ready to drop Xorg completely until someone points out a11y problems with Wayland, or https://www.phoronix.com/news/Fedora-40-KDE-Plasma-6-Plan https://www.phoronix.com/news/Fedora-40-KDE-Plasma-6-Plan for Fedora looking to drop KDE+X11.