4 ms·
What happens to the water after they flood the field? It seems neutral if the fields in question are in the same basin. Same point is often made about flooded
by jeffbee 3y ago
What happens to the water after they flood the field? It seems neutral if the fields in question are in the same basin.
Same point is often made about flooded rice fields in northern California. The water "used" by this process, that is the water that does not return to the river, transpires into the air. For a given crop the transpiration is the same whether flooded or irrigated by another method. The crop is the problem, not the flood.
- geitir 3y agoFlooding an X area field is more water exposed to the air than direct application to a smaller Y area no? So by your own logic more water evaporates into the air with flooding
- codingdave 3y agoAnd once it evaporates, it will move east with the air, over the mountains, and into a different watershed. It is true that the water will flow somewhere, so isn't "lost", but the point is that the diversion decreases how much makes it downstream to the Salt Lake.
- reducesuffering 3y ago> over the mountains I thought the water cycle causes almost all of the precipitation to happen before going over the mountains? It's why the west side of the Sierras are wet and the east side dry.
- ericpauley 3y ago> For a given crop the transpiration is the same whether flooded or irrigated by another method. Is this true?
- jeffbee 3y agoYes? It’s a chemical process. A given yield of a given cultivar will transpire a fixed amount of water.
- buffington 3y agoI want to understand this better. Are you saying that flooding a field loses the same amount of water to evaporation as other, more targeted, means of irrigation? Or are you saying "alfalfa itself uses the same amount of water regardless of irrigation methood." If it's the latter, that makes sense. A plant can only use so much, and that rate of use is consistent for a given crop, but that doesn't address the water not used by the alfalfa. Wouldn't flooding lose more water to evaporation than other irrigation methods?
- ericpauley 3y agoThis is my beef as well. While the crop itself may use the same amount, this is a tremendously unhelpful metric for reasoning about total water use.
- thehappypm 3y agoYes, but, most of the water loss and flood farming is because there is water pulled up everywhere around the plants and a lot of it just directly evaporates. That’s why drip irrigation is so much better, you’re targeting water to the plants
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThe water carries minerals from the soil back into the river, which get more concentrated each time. Salt is a major concern (this is the source of ocean salt), and in major irrigation rivers like the colorado is a major issue that is controlled carefully for downstream users, for whom it would otherwise be too salty to use for irrigation. The US treaty with mexico dictates the salt content of the river at the border for this reason. The southwest US used to be home to a widespread desert irrigation agricultural people, the Hohokum, and failure to manage soil salt content is afaik still the leading hypothesis for their disappearance. So no unfortunately water that flows back into the river isn't neutral.