3 ms·
Another philosophical tangent: we should protect humans from advertising on principle. Our minds are sacred, our cognitive functions are inalienable. Not a sin
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
Another philosophical tangent: we should protect humans from advertising on principle.
Our minds are sacred, our cognitive functions are inalienable. Not a single corporation on this planet is entitled to this. Our attention belongs to us. It's not currency to pay for services with. It's not a commodity for them to sell to the highest bidder. They don't get to insert their brands into our brains without our consent. That should be considered mind rape and any measures taken to stop it should be considered legitimate self-defense.
- passion__desire 3y agoSide note : I consider adverstising to be like a friend's recommendation if the options are curated, researched and non-scammy. If you have nothing against influencer economy, you should have nothing against advertising. I just want ads to be done ethically.
- Rygian 3y agoMy (actual) friends have never spent a single dime in recommending a product to me, and they never talk about products where they have a personal stake. So I can't relate to your perception. Advertisers spend money with the aim of convincing strangers. There is always a conflict of interest.
- passion__desire 3y agoAds have suggested lot of life improvement products for me i.e. better bedsheets, duvets, aromatherapy products, etc. I love those. I would have never checked those out. After trying them, I have suggested them to my friends. Lot of minor improvements. Here's the thesis, if we consider youtube recommendations and instagram recommendations to be so good that they are addictive, the same can be said about ad recommendations. Buy-conversions track whether the product has been effective and could be recommended to similar demographics. People have no problem choosing life-partners based on how algos recommends profiles on dating apps but they have issue with ads. They want this particular aspect to be "organic" what a irony.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> I would have never checked those out. Why not? Can't you go to a store and ask to see products? Open an app and see what they have to offer you? When you seek the products out, it's not advertising, it's information.
- passion__desire 3y agoI didn't seek them out. For me, it could be said they never existed. Ads recommendeded them. I am not dumb to blindly purchase any recommendation.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoWell, I search for products I want constantly. I'll describe what I want to Google or an actual salesperson and see what comes up. Then I'll refine the results if necessary. I don't consider that advertising. I'm looking for information and others are supplying me with it.
- passion__desire 3y agoWell then you are dependent on the particulars of the search engine algorithms and what it surfaces to you. This is similar to Walmart preselecting 3 products from a category and asking you to make a choice among them. I would love to have some diversity in it.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoDiversity is provided by friends and family. Trusted human beings. Not the highest bidder in the auctions for our attention. Also, without advertising, search engines and the web would be a lot more trustworthy than they are today. When searching I used to get many real websites created by humans, now I see ad-funded AI-generated utterly worthless SEO spam. Advertising is literally the root cause of the enshittification of the web.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI consider advertising to be fundamentally different from word of mouth networks and friend recommendations. Friends do not have conflicts of interest. They recommend things to you because they like it and think you would too, not because they stand to make billions in profit. Advertisements are inherently untrustworthy: you must assume ads are showing you the positives and hiding the negatives.
- passion__desire 3y agoPeople are generally exposed to reviews by third parties. They do their research and only then buy. Most products can be replaced / returned if you are not satisfied. Limited friend circle and their limited exposure to existing and new products should not be a determining factor in deciding what should I like or not. It should be my personal decision. Politicians / media are inherently untrustworthy. Yet society chugs along.
- smoldesu 3y ago> It's not currency to pay for services with. Tell that to the people who need to watch a YouTube video and don't want to punch in their credit-card info. Unless someone is picking up the hosting and delivery costs, advertising will always make the most sense. Now, don't get me wrong; ad-free YouTube at no cost would be great! It's not a business though, and without advertising arguably none of those services would exist. I don't know what you are proposing if not completely tearing-down our relatively accessible status-quo.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> people who need to watch a YouTube "Need" is too strong a word. Nobody "needs" to watch a YouTube video. Maybe they want to watch one. > without advertising arguably none of those services would exist Then let their existence cease. They're corporations. They don't have human rights. They aren't entitled to life. > I don't know what you are proposing if not completely tearing-down our relatively accessible status-quo. It's exactly what I am proposing. A status quo where mind rape is normalized for the sake of convenience should not be allowed to exist.
- smoldesu 3y ago> "Need" is too strong a word. Nobody "needs" to watch a YouTube video. Circumstantially, maybe not. In high school and college, I had plenty of homework assignments that involved a YouTube video. After classes, YouTube continued to be the biggest asset to my professional development. Having access to conference talks and long-form tutorials changed my life. For the sake of argument, let's just say I'm fixing my sink and the first result on 5 search engines is a YouTube video. What do you expect the average person to do next? > It's exactly what I am proposing. Well, good luck with that. I'm very curious to see who shows up to pick up the bill in your new world. It sorta sounds like your mental model feigns the existence of capitalism and free will, though.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> I'm very curious to see who shows up to pick up the bill in your new world. I will pick up the bill for my own consumption. I have less than zero tolerance for advertising but I still buy a lot of stuff. The difference is I do it on my own terms. I won't have them actively advertising to me. When I want something, I'll ask them. When I actively seek out their products it's not advertising but information.
- KMnO4 3y agoI’ve spent some time thinking about this. A lot of things in life can be avoided if you have more money. Waiting in long lines, having uncomfortable seats, doing regular chores, etc. But it seems advertising can’t be completely avoided (as much as I’d like it to). I’ll go out of my way to spend money wherever it removes ads (eg YouTube, podcasts, etc), but no amount of money will remove the billboards I have to drive by on the way to work. I’ll never be able to go to a sports event without advertisers bidding for my attention. You would think at least some of those issues could be avoided by living somewhere “more expensive”, but it seems like affluent areas actually have more ads. What measures can we possibly take? Nb: I recently took a trip to the USA and was appalled that they play full volume video advertisements while you’re filling up with gas. At least that’s not a practice that’s caught on elsewhere.
- PopAlongKid 3y ago> At least that’s not a practice that’s caught on elsewhere. Including elsewhere in the USA.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> What measures can we possibly take? We build technology. The number one example is of course uBlock Origin. It shows people a better world with no strings attached. So good it should be built into browsers. It can't block ads in videos... Yet. How long until someone makes an AI video filterer that deletes ads from video streams though? Have the AI watch ads so we don't have to. Given this technology, how long until augmented reality glasses with adblocking builtin start showing up?
- jcpst 3y agoIf I go to a gas station and there’s video at the pump, I do not go to that gas station again.
- teddyh 3y ago> no amount of money will remove the billboards São Paulo got rid of billboards in 2006: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cidade_Limpa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cidade_Limpa>
- hutzlibu 3y ago"They don't get to insert their brands into our brains without our consent." You consent by going to free youtube. Big ads in cities are more difficult to avoid, but then again, someone wearing a sports shirt of his favourite soccer club is doing advertisement. Someone wearing a cross for his religion, etc. I don't think drawing a arbitary line and saying "this is mindrape" and "this is legit" is really working. That being said, I do want to paintball big ads and alike.
- ParetoOptimal 3y ago> Big ads in cities are more difficult to avoid, but then again, someone wearing a sports shirt of his favourite soccer club is doing advertisement. Someone wearing a cross for his religion, etc. Yeah, but those give more room for consent than something like a youtube ad. You passively see those advertisements while doing something else. When you see a television or youtube ad, your full attention is much more likely on the computer and on that ad.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"Yeah, but those give more room for consent than something like a youtube ad." Who forces you to watch youtube?
- iamacyborg 3y ago> You consent by going to free youtube. You consented to being touched by wearing that clothing.
- hutzlibu 3y agoYes, but other persons do not consent to view that ad. But my point was, that it is not so simple.
- witx 3y agoThat is a very eloquent explanation, for an opinion I share and wasn't able to put so plainly! I always get weird looks when, watching TV, I change channels during ads.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThank you. It's an opinion I've refined over time via conversation with like-minded people here. I don't change channels when watching TV, I mute it and pick up my phone until it ends.