13 ms·
How mobile apps illegally share personal data
- mmwako 3y agonow try tiktok
- whoopsie 3y agoIf an IP is PII (it is for my regulated app in many jurisdictions), perhaps every app is at risk as SDKs generally phone home without being first routed through a server of ours.
- nomercy400 3y agoThis is about handling the PII. From what I understand, you can ask for an IP if it is required for the application's functionality, i.e. "due to technical limitations, we need to know where to send the response", but you cannot automatically use it for marketing purposes, i.e. "sell the IP to third-party advertisers which can then build a profile of that IP's site visiting behavior".
- whoopsie 3y agoYep. My fintech serves people with bad financial history. If you’re my customer, your credit score is low and you’ve got an active loan. Simply being my customer is PII. We should be guarding IP addresses as PII.
- tempodox 3y agoThe answer should be simple: Don't use SDKs that phone home uncontrollably.
- mdp2021 3y ago'noyb' = "[My Privacy is] None Of Your Business" https://noyb.eu/en/projects https://noyb.eu/en/projects https://noyb.eu/en/faqs https://noyb.eu/en/faqs > Max [Schrems, a lawyer and privacy activist] had had the idea of a professional privacy enforcement NGO (similar to consumer rights organizations) that brings cases against large corporations on behalf of the users for a while and was ultimately able to realize it through noyb https://noyb.eu/en/annual-report-2022-out-now https://noyb.eu/en/annual-report-2022-out-now
- imiric 3y agoOn the one hand, I'm glad that organizations like noyb exist. On the other, it's a testament to the failure of enforcing privacy regulations, where we need to have organizations hunt down flagrant perpetrators. It would be akin to relying on vigilante groups to enforce common laws, instead of having federal law enforcement agencies.
- Nextgrid 3y agoAgreed. All they had to do was to legislate a statutory amount someone could claim in case of a privacy violation and the problems would've disappeared overnight by companies set up to litigate on behalf of consumers in exchange for a cut.
- eitland 3y agoAnd we would be one step closer to US.
- Nextgrid 3y agoWould it be bad in this case? We have a chronic problem of lack of GDPR enforcement and it's clear regulators are underfunded/incompetent/overwhelmed/not interested in doing their job. If the regulators can't, let someone else do the job.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agothe fact that in the U.S you can sue larger and more powerful organizations for their having harmed you is a clear benefit in comparison to some European systems (the way this works can vary between land). In Denmark and I assume in Norway if you have been harmed by a governmental organization you have to complain and spend lots of time to deal with the problem and in the end get nothing for the time, you get a worthless apology and change of policy for what harmed you in the first place, and then wasted years, and nothing is done to right the hurt or damage you suffered. Better the American way as an opportunity, however limited, to make the powerful suffer in kind.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago> Under the ePrivacy Directive, the mere access or storage of data on the user’s terminal device is only allowed if users give their free, informed, specific and unambiguous consent I'm unsure what they mean by "storage of data on the [...] device" because you can't use an App without having first installed it (which uses your device's storage already), so doesn't the app have reasonable implicit permission to make use of the user's storage? ...while the part about an app being able to "access" stored data is ambiguous: does that include the app reading its own resource/assets data from its installed app-package/directory? Or if it's referring to apps reading from the user's own (i.e. private) data like Contacts database, photos, GPS sensors, etc - then as far as I'm concerned that's not a legal or policy question, but a clear and gaping security hole in the OS because the app was somehow able to break out of the sandbox to read into other data-stores on the user's device.
- Etheryte 3y agoThe whole article talks about users' personal data, it isn't about storing data on the device in general. If you read the article from the top I think it's pretty evident.
- cccbbbaaa 3y ago> so doesn't the app have reasonable implicit permission to make use of the user's storage? “Implicit permission” does not sound like “free, informed, specific and unambiguous consent”. Furthermore, the directive (ePrivacy, article 5(3)) states that consent is valid only if the user was provided with clear information about the purposes of the processing beforehand. > does that include the app reading its own resource/assets data from its installed app-package/directory? An app reading its own data will fall under the “strictly necessary” exception of the directive (cf. ePrivacy 5(3)). Reading other databases will depend on the purpose.
- verisimi 3y agoSounds like a good reason to roll legislation that legally mandates that all this data should go through a centralised authority. Which will make for even easier collection that would be enshrined in law. Unfortunately, all this stuff is going in one direction.
- v7engine 3y agoWondering if Apple shares my personal data to third-parties from Health and Fitness apps on the iOS.
- smcleod 3y agoThey don’t unless you explicitly choose to share it with a specific app. It’s in their T&C.
- heikkilevanto 3y agoWould be nice if there was a sandbox app that could run any app and produce a list of resources the app had accessed and actions it has taken. Bit like running a s program under strace on Linux.
- okokwhatever 3y agoYou would be killing the goose that lays the golden eggs of Apple and Google my friend
- nonrandomstring 3y agoFetch me a platter of Gänsebraten with a side of Foie Gras
- noirscape 3y agoAndroid technically offers that - the actual permission list that apps need to declare is a lot larger than what gets shown to the user. Google only shows the most egregious permission flags in normal Android builds. They also for some reason opted to bundle a few completely unrelated permissions into the phone call permission notification (iirc it's for example the notif shown if you want access to bluetooth devices). I think there's a few XPosed plugins that let you show prompts for the ones Google doesn't let you decide on if you don't want to go full custom ROM. They can also feed fake data so your personal data isn't compromised.
- jqpabc123 3y agoLong story short: There is nothing that actually prevents an installed app from collecting all your data. Progressive Web Apps on the other hard are actively restricted by the browser sandbox and are ganerally a preferred solution from a privacy perspective. https://web.dev/progressive-web-apps/ https://web.dev/progressive-web-apps/
- shmde 3y ago> There is nothing that actually prevents an installed app from collecting all your data. What if I use something like AdGuard to block reqs ?
- pdimitar 3y agoThe only reason stuff like PiHole / AdGuard DNS and many others work is because the service vendors have not bothered unifying ALL the network requests their service needs under a single domain. The one and only reason we can use those privacy-enhancing solutions is because the vendors are sloppy. The moment your favorite app starts using only `your-fav-app.com` domain for everything, ads and sending out your private info included, you are toast and you'll need a MITM proxy or any other on-device-network-payload-inspector-after-decryption-has-taken-place to save yourself. (So maybe Adguard's client app, I presume? But haven't ever tried.) Maybe Privaxy[0] will help -- haven't tried it yet and I got no time and energy for it for the moment, sadly, but DNS-level blocking in particular is just waiting for a few more resourceful vendors to do the right thing for their interests, and we're disarmed. [0] https://github.com/barre/privaxy https://github.com/barre/privaxy
- ignoramous 3y ago> The moment your favorite app starts using only `your-fav-app.com` domain for everything Not just that, services could end up using the same IP across providers: https://blog.cloudflare.com/addressing-agility/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/addressing-agility/
- jqpabc123 3y agoYour data can easily be sent to an IP collection point that is not on AdGuard's list. DNS blockers are better than nothing --- which is a pretty low bar and easy to jump over.
- alexvitkov 3y ago> How mobile apps illegally share your personal data There are many different methods you can use to share a file, including but not limited to Dropbox and floppy drives. Your data is a file, or maybe it's an SQL table! Sharing a file can be done by anyone, but be careful though, as sharing an SQL table needs to be done trained professionals. DO NOT ATTEMPT SHARING AN SQL TABLE WITHOUT PROPER SUPERVISION. Seriously, what's the news/content here? Is mobile apps not complying with EU regulations noteworthy in any way?
- whatatita 3y agoIt's not about the format of the data, but the content. Personal Information (PI) can only be shared with consent, and only for clearly specified purposes. That's the Bad Thing they're reporting on, albeit somewhat poorly. And there's strong(er) privacy laws is California USA, the EU, Switzerland, and the UK. That's just off the top of my head. So not just EU law being broken here.
- hnisforfascists 3y ago[dead]
- msravi 3y agoThe worst I've had is a clock/weather widget that seemed to give you a choice of ads/no-ads, but if no-ads were chosen, it would make your phone part of a network of proxies (oxylabs) without telling you, in addition to transmitting location info (which it told you about). No payment option to get rid of ads/data selling. Only way I found out was by looking at requests it made using netguard.
- MaxBarraclough 3y agoWould you be willing to name the app?
- msravi 3y agoSimple weather and clock widget by Difer. I think they've now removed the proxy and added a payment option, but I'd never trust them again.
- teakie 3y agomastodon inctances are prone to this. user data stored in plaintext, even PM are unencrypted and readable by design for moderation
- dncornholio 3y agoMastodon has no secrets. Never post secrets on Mastodon. It will get broadcasted and can be abused. Treat system as such and you're golden.
- teakie 3y agoIt's also bad for publishing (they now use the term too, anyways) all (I mean really like ALL of thoose tech savy people store their data in plaintext on someone computer, they not know what this thing does. there are many thousand on one instance. which disappears. maybe they where ethical people had no dirtmoney, couldn't exchange information to currency to pay the hoster.. I don't know. But you can get banned pretty quickly. Even when talking in private, a mod can decide it's creepy and ban you. they still have the data. you no access to your audience.
- jacquesm 3y agoBeware of companies that link 'monetization libraries' to their apps. Those are the worst.
- dbrgn 3y ago> These complaints are just the beginning: noyb is planning to file more complaints against mobile app companies in the future in order to stop the illegal sharing of user data. Gotta love what noyb is doing. In case you want to support their work, there are links on their website to donate or to become a member. I'm not affiliated with them in any way, but their approach to privacy law enforcement is precisely what we need right now. Companies that mis-use personal data (often in violation of European law) must know that there can be consequences (reputational, financial and potentially legal).
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIt's good work. Ultimately though we cannot base civic cybersecurity for the entire population on groups like NOYB or any number of vigilante policemen exposing malevolent companies one by one. It's neither scalable nor sustainable against a tide of technological abuse enabled by a culture of corporate entitlement and public apathy. In addition to legislation the problem requires active programmes of public education and information as is the case for all other public health or security issues. More lives are saved per dollar running a "Don't drink-drive" campaign than giving police money to arrest drunk drivers. "Don't install that app" should be a tag-line every mother and child knows, like "See it. Say it. Sorted.", just to get people to pause and think... "would I share all my all my personal data and access to my life with a random total stranger?" Because that's what you're doing when you install some dodgy app at a restaurant. Maybe groups like NOYB could do more work on sophisticated modern influential media to attack the root cause of the problem: a fundamentally flawed security model with a set of wholly inappropriate assumptions. Change the assumptions.
- Nextgrid 3y agoThis is analogous to solving murder by telling everyone to stay home since serial killers run free on the street instead of catching & jailing murderers. Maybe we could enforce the (existing!) laws against malware, fraud, spam, etc so that people can continue to install apps & use them and be confident knowing that nothing bad will happen, and if it does happen then the offenders will be punished appropriately? GDPR breaches aren't limited to apps btw, it happens on websites and even in real life (Tesco stores in the UK for example have a notice inside the store about data collection; presumably they're doing Bluetooth/Wi-Fi MAC address tracking - by the time you read the notice you're already being stalked, and there's no way to opt-out other than inconveniencing yourself by manually toggling the relevant radios before going to the store).
- mdp2021 3y agoI would like to see more attention to the increasing privacy issues in critical infrastructure, such as cars (see Privacy Nightmare on Wheels’: Every Car Brand Reviewed by Mozilla, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37443644 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37443644 ) or third party owned eavesdroppers. Some contexts are leaving little option (all products demanding privacy loss): this is where the big battle will lie.
- 3abiton 3y agoI used to use Viber for calls outside the EU, and briefly after the GDPR was implemented, I checked their data partners, I kid you not, more than 1000 data harvesting companies were listed there. Keep in mind, Viber has acess to so many permissions on Android, it's freaky even if they didn't have this many partners (I had XPrivacy back then). Can't imagine how compromised the regular users are.
- cezart 3y agoRead this and instantly removed Viber from my phone. Also will leave a scantling review with regards to this.
- milosmns 3y agoI uninstalled that malware a long time ago despite everyone around me using it. Years ago when I still had it, I found that they've been transmitting all my data - including messages apparently - to Facebook. I found this in the FB privacy console, as Viber would have never told me explicitly. To your second concern... can't you now disable all those permissions individually? Not allowing you to then proceed with using the app would break their Google Play developers agreement, I assume. I hope.
- NavinF 3y ago> they've been transmitting all my data - including messages apparently - to Facebook. I found this in the FB privacy console Got a screenshot to share? That's extraordinary
- voytec 3y ago> The companies’ apps illegally access and share users’ personal data with third parties for sophisticated analytics as soon as the apps are opened. Users don’t even have the choice to consent to or prevent the sharing of their data. This approach is unlawful. Unlawful - true. But also no different than your usual website attempting to load Google Tag Manager, Analytics or some Facebook garbage before user has a chance to consent.
- milosmns 3y agoWhat can I do as a developer to offer that choice to the user, before it loads? What can I do about the transitive dependencies that my dependencies load?
- martin_a 3y ago> What can I do as a developer to offer that choice to the user, before it loads? Implement a (sane) version of a cookie banner which sets a cookie containing the information that the user is fine with loading external libraries or not. That cookie itself is classified as a technical cookie if only used for that reason and will not require "permission" from the user. That's how this would be implemented in a GDPR-compliant way. If the cookie is set, you can load the respective external scripts and tools. If not, you don't. > What can I do about the transitive dependencies that my dependencies load? That's trickier one and probably more into the legal side, as in informing the user that those dependencies exist and how they correlate to each other.
- jampekka 3y agoOr even better if you don't do shady shit that people don't want (e.g. Google Analytics), you don't need any banners at all.
- jampekka 3y agoYou can for example use analytics that aren't spyware, and hence don't even have to try to trick users giving "consent" to things they don't really want. https://matomo.org/ https://matomo.org/
- langsoul-com 3y agoMobile apps are most the worse for data privacy. More or less designed to hover all your info and collect EVERYTHING. There's a very good reason why everything is a stupid app when it could do fine with a website or PWA.
- stareatgoats 3y agoMax Schrems and noyb have long been at the forefront of the privacy battles in Europe. Kudos! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOYB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOYB
- bertil 3y agoI get why you need legal arguments to prosecute organisations that abuse the system, but I’m worried that’s the wrong focus for now. Companies handling data will always have enough lobbyist to make their particular way of doing things technically legal (“we didn’t sent ID, we shared hashes”). What they should be judged on is whether people understand what they are doing, and if that clarity empowers people to support advertising approaches. Several generations of technologists have dreamed of a user-controlled platform to broadcast information, like “I’m in the market for a toaster” and get relevant offers. Ad markets and platforms would not make less money if they empowered users to tell you what they are interested in and to stop showing ads about crypto and gambling.
- mdp2021 3y ago> their particular way of doing things technically legal [... e.g.] shared hashes Yes, sometimes, but an important part of it is blunt: see the post in this page of the user who installed a controversial communication application (not WsA) and found that the messages were forwarded to FB... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37506851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37506851 ) > whether people understand what they are doing Yes. Partially it is a matter of awareness. But there is also a large part of the population which does not care about privacy - which also reveals a perception of the world that may be outdated ("nothing to hide to decent authorities" is the idea that many hold because usual to them).
- bertil 3y agoI would argue that if they think there’s no risk in sharing detailed personal information with authorities, they also need to understand. Privacy advocates are better at making that case, but it hasn’t always easy to hear.
- thefz 3y ago> Companies handling data will always have enough lobbyist to make their particular way of doing things technically legal (“we didn’t sent ID, we shared hashes”). > What they should be judged on is whether people understand what they are doing Nope, it's waaayy easier to regulate this at the root of the problem rather than going person by person asking if they understand a 15-page legalese EULA they did not read.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoA couple of years ago I read "The Age of Surveillance Capitalism." Zuboff of thorough and relentless. Couple this sociopolitical manipulation machine with new found AI and it gets even more frightening. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Age_of_Surveillance_Capitalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Age_of_Surveillance_Capi... https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5AvtUrHxg8A&pp=ygUGenVib2Zm https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5AvtUrHxg8A&pp=ygUGenVib2Zm
- earthnail 3y agoGenerally I like what noyb does, but I dislike how advertisement and product analytics seem to be thrown into the same basket. There are third-party companies like Mixpanel and Amplitude that you can send your users' data to, but they will only process it for you, and not for anyone else. Same with third-party companies like RevenueCat that help you with implementing in-app purchases. Very different situation than sending data to Google or Facebook who will then use it for everything they do. Not all third-parties are the same.
- Nextgrid 3y agoThe objective of the GDPR is to give the data subject better control over how their data is used. Maybe the user doesn't want you to stalk them for analytics or "product improvement" (biggest tech industry lie of the past decade), regardless of whether other third-parties also get in on the action?
- sixstringtheory 3y agoI hardly think something like a crash report diagnostic is stalking, though. Maybe you could make the case for transaction conversion funnels. That’s really a case by case basis for which analytics provider is being used and how the product owners consume them.
- uoaei 3y agoIf your crash report service is reporting personal data, then your crash report service is written incorrectly from the perspective of respecting user privacy.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoI’ve developed crash reporters for years now. The only way personal information is making its way into crash reports is if the app developers put it there. Otherwise it’s function names, the OS version, binary images that were loaded into the app, the time it happened. Certain termination reports do contain small memory dumps and/or register values, so theoretically could could contain decodable PII. This is something the OS vendor provides, not the developer of the app or the crash reporter.
- nemoniac 3y agoDuckDuckGo App Tracking Protection is an app which can raise your awareness of what tracking the apps on your smartphone are doing, and probably give you a fright in the process! Last week it blocked 31000 attempts to track me by apps on my smartphone. https://duckduckgo.com/duckduckgo-help-pages/p-app-tracking-protection/what-is-app-tracking-protection/ https://duckduckgo.com/duckduckgo-help-pages/p-app-tracking-...
- tredre3 3y agoI use and love DuckDuckGo Android app! The browser part suits my workflow very well. The pinned favorites, the tabs not accumulating forever like in Chrome, it's just great all around! But it's not as privacy-friendly as you'd think. For example all favorites and bookmarks favicons are routed through their server. Which would be nice as an option, but you can't opt out. They pinky-swear they don't log it, though. https://github.com/duckduckgo/Android/issues/527#issuecomment-510520040 https://github.com/duckduckgo/Android/issues/527#issuecommen...
- brindy 3y agoWe fixed this issue a long time ago. https://github.com/duckduckgo/Android/pull/878 https://github.com/duckduckgo/Android/pull/878 Thanks
- jbombadil 3y agoWe desperately need OS level user configurable firewalls. I need to be able to download an app and tell the OS “this app cannot access the internet in any way shape or form”. It won’t solve all the problems. But at least for apps like “alarm clock” or whatever that should be able to work offline, the OS should guarantee it remains offline.
- noja 3y agohttps://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html https://www.obdev.at/products/littlesnitch/index.html
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- yomlica8 3y agoIt can help, but most OSes are in on the scam so it often asking the fox to guard the hen house.
- intelVISA 3y agoProtecting your network only really works at the router level for this reason. Hence Google's push to normalize adtech like QUIC to evade this.
- akyuu 3y agoThere are several existing options: - Windows: Simplewall (uses native WPF for filtering), Portmaster (interactive firewall, uses custom kernel extension). - macOS: LuLu or Little Snitch (they all use a native filtering API, which unfortunately is not perfect: https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/2023/6/3.html https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/2023/6/3.html). - Linux: OpenSnitch, denying network permission to Flatpak apps. - Android: Rethink, NetGuard; GrapheneOS has app network permission natively. iOS is the only OS where no application firewall is available, although if you don't use Wi-Fi, you can block apps from using cellular data.
- 3y ago
- doublerabbit 3y agoThis is a reason to why I don't upgrade my iOS version from 15. Partly due to no jail breaks available. And yes, from a security standpoint with the recent exploits, I know. I have NetFence firewall installed and the amount of API requests to third party systems applications make, including bank applications is surprisingly high. These include sending metrics and telemetry to third parties. Location Data, whether GPS is on or off and these toggles can be seen within the API call. app.adjust.com app-measurement.com eu-aa-online-metrix.net firebaselogging-pa.googleapis.com Are just a few domains these app's make a call too. Why?
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- secretsatan 3y agoI think some of it could be the unthinking inclusion of 3rd party libraries that seems to go all through the mobile dev community. Just thinking of crashlytics, which is incredibly popular, and on it's own, isn't terribly invasive. But of course, google now owns it, so every time you go to your console, google is constantly pushing some further invasion of privacy to improve your insights. There's load of things, even apart from deliberately malicious libraries, that will use analytics to fund their free tools. What do you know about your easy to implement cloud synching db that saves so much time?
- air7 3y ago"Such extensive data collection allows the profiling of users in order to show them personalized ads and marketing campaigns to increase the revenue for the mentioned companies." On a bit of a philosophical tangent: Targeted ads increase revenues because they are focused on people with a higher proabability of responding positively to the ads. If you asume agency of the user then this is a good thing, a win-win. But by treating this negatively you are asuming that the user has no agency over their actions. They reply to the ad, but it hurts them or they don't really want to. And we should protect users from this "temptation". This is the line of reasoning behind banning the sale of addictive substances to minors. Note that I am not talking about privacy issues, only about the quoted reservation which is quite common.
- noja 3y agoWhat? You are seriously arguing that the illegal and consent-less selling of people's data is a win-win?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- partitioned 3y agoI don’t think anyone cares about this as an “issue”. The issue is privacy. The statement you’re quoting is their motivation to do so.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoIt’s not as simple as the dichotomy you’ve presented. I exercise all the agency I can summon to avoid seeing ads, yet still I am presented with them and tracked so that companies can present them to me. If I had the choice I would deny them any ability to track me. So, don’t I lack some agency here? Is it my fault? And if I see an image or text I am not prepared for, my lower perceptual faculties process it before my prefrontal cortex can reason about it. Advertisers and psychologists know this, it’s why they keep doing what they do, because it works.
- reb 3y agoI think you might appreciate this article (if you haven’t seen it already): https://meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/ https://meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/
- rq1 3y agoI decided to almost only use websites with adblocker and never install apps, for that reason.
- stvltvs 3y ago.
- miroljub 3y agoThat's why I always avoid installing any apps on my phone, if I can live with a website version. Yes, websites also try to collect as much as they can, but at least there I have a browser sandbox and a possibility to use an uBlock Origin. Of course, the issue is always with other apps that don't have a website version and require the internet to work. There, one needs to be much more careful about what he installs, and to prefer open source when possible.
- wkat4242 3y agoAnother issue is websites that incessantly push you to install their stupid app. Like, oh, pretty much all of them. LinkedIn, Reddit, insta. They mainly want you to use the app so they can collect more data obviously.
- wirthjason 3y agoRestaurants, particularly fast food, also do the same.
- wkat4242 3y agoOh yeah I never use them. I did notice McDonalds does try to push you to their app on their ordering kiosks, and they removed some kiosks to make it more difficult to order in person. But I didn't cave in :) I generally hate apps, I'm a real computer guy.
- billy_bitchtits 3y agoWhat’s the best way to figure out which apps you have are bad actors vs ok? iOS.
- coldcode 3y agoThis article explicitly mentions 3 apps running on Android. The headline creates the assumption it involves iOS as well, as well as other Android apps, but this does not appear in the article at all.
- hnisforfascists 3y ago[dead]
- wirthjason 3y agoAre there any guides or tutorials on how to do this kind of analysis on your own?
- _Algernon_ 3y agoIt is incredibly cheap to store data and regulations are ineffective or non-existent. Of course data collection will run wild and be abused. Change any of these factors and the problem solves itself: - More expensive storage media. - Remove the value that can be extracted from data (eg. nerfing the advertisment based business model) - Bigger consequences for mishandling data (eg. fines >100% or prison sentences for responsible leadership would be a good start). - Increased probability of experiencing consequences in the first place (eg. more effective enforcement of regulations). Effectively these are the levers that you can push on. 1,2 and 4 seem difficult to move much, which leaves 3.
- edgyquant 3y agoThe only one of these that will actually fix the problems is prison sentences (and increased probability of getting said sentences.) It’s the same with malicious spammers, why would they ever stop when the consequences are basically nothing.
- teeray 3y agoAlso, fines are an abstract punishment—even more so when applied to a business. The C-suites need to start evaluating decisions knowing their personal freedom is at stake—not a number on a balance sheet.
- j-a-a-p 3y agoUnfortunately, despite having appropriate laws for many years, these privacy rules are broken en masse. And why? If every EU country would simply check their top 1000 websites (and apps) pro actively, this would problem would not exist. Now we have the situation that everybody does it so you would be stupid not to follow. Something similar with unsolicited mailing (both snail and e), the rules are clear but trampled by small and large companies and institutions. It is not that this government lacks the expertise or creativity. Yearly aerial images are collected to search for illegal buildings and extensions. The same government's tax department actively scrapes the web and social media to collect and store personal data to create a fraud profile on all their citizens.[0] [0]: https://www.dutchnews.nl/2023/09/tax-office-scraped-social-media-for-database-info-nrc/ https://www.dutchnews.nl/2023/09/tax-office-scraped-social-m...
- miohtama 3y agoRegulation that is not thoughtful and enforceable is not good regulation. Spam was made “illegal” more than a decade ago in the US and in the EU. It did not reduce the amount of spam. The same thing with GDPR: only honest and good actors suffer, while dishonest actors or megacorps like Google get an advantage and because of this advantage they manage to grow their business.
- dylan604 3y ago>while dishonest actors or megacorps why the distinction? if spam is illegal, it doesn't matter your size or incorporation status. if you break the rules, you've broken the rules. the ability to spam doesn't really increase by size of corp. a single person can hire services to spam just as effectively has evilCorp
- GlickWick 3y agoBecause an inversion of responsibility happens at some turning point of organization size. A small company that wants to survive has to spend a lot of effort and engineering hours becoming compliant with the legislation. If they fail to do so, the following legal battle and potential fines have a high probability of bankrupting them. They must be proactive to avoid this. Large corporations instead get to be reactive. They comply where it’s convenient and otherwise operate on an “ask forgiveness later” mindset. Legal battles and billion dollar fines barely register and instead of becoming destructive events, just become minor taxes on doing business. As much as I appreciate the spirit of the legislation, the implementation has actually empowered large companies and is squeezing out small business.
- TheMode 3y ago> No Consent. Under the ePrivacy Directive, the mere access or storage of data on the user’s terminal device is only allowed if users give their free, informed, specific and unambiguous consent. Two out of the three mobile apps did not display a consent banner when launching the app. The third app presented a banner that theoretically gave the complainant the choice of giving or withholding their consent. In reality, the transmission of their personal data began without any interaction on their part – and before they even had a chance to think about consent. Why do nobody question the fact that it is possible for an application to access data without user consent to begin with? Why are we transforming it into a human problem? The tech is to blame.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIt does seem a bit surprising, I thought it was totally blocked on iOS without user consent?
- TheMode 3y agoI assume that it is dependent on the platform, and what you are accessing. The problem is that we first design platforms/APIs to automate everything, and secondly try to make it secure/explicit. We need the opposite.
- pixl97 3y agoWon't happen till laws demand it. Very few companies/programmers I know write 'secure first'. Most of the time it's "this shit isn't working, turn off the security stuff and see if it works then we'll re-enable it later"
- TheMode 3y agoWhat app developers want/do is irrelevant. I am saying that it should be impossible for any individual app to access or connect to anything without explicit user consent. We need to stop automating everything and then complain that companies aren't putting optional banners everywhere. This is beyond stupid.
- r053bud 3y agoI realized, after talking to a bunch of people about this, that people outside of Hacker News just don’t care about privacy. It’s unbelievably sad to me. I don’t see any solution in sight without regulation, and that simply isn’t even being discussed in the US (based on a cursory scan of active bills being considered)
- ianlevesque 3y agoIt really is an extreme echo chamber. I agree that the status quo should improve but by even being aware of the problem we're already outliers.
- nologic01 3y agoTen years ago digital privacy advocates had a tough job. The fact that they still do today, is one of the most glaring governance failures of recent times. Governments just can't seem to get their act together on this. Its pointless to revisit the spectrum of reasons ranging from incompetency to complicity. If you want a populist framing this is like knowingly lowering the gates of the castle and letting expert pickpockets rush in and have a field day with the unsuspecting citizens. Maybe stressing that this inaction undermines the future of the digital economy and society would fly better with the political class. Digitization is our bright "future", no? Economic actors will act according to the signals they get from government and its institutions as to what is allowed. If those signals are non-existing or mixed they will invest in the "wrong" direction.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoGovts enjoy buying the data.
- mostlysimilar 3y agoCorporate lobbying is the problem, not governments wanting data on citizens.
- pulpfictional 3y agoWhy not both?
- fieldbob 3y agoIt is not an operating system its a mining operation
- superlario 3y agoThe modern world has made a tangled mess of personal data. Is there any way to walk this back?