3 ms·

Personal anecdata: In span of 6 months, I did eye exams at 3 different places and got 3 different prescriptions! All 3 claimed to use latest tech and they did m

Personal anecdata: In span of 6 months, I did eye exams at 3 different places and got 3 different prescriptions! All 3 claimed to use latest tech and they did manual exams as well.

jtwaleson 3y ago
This is pretty normal, depending on the amount of variation of course. Basically, for each calculate the spherical equivalent (SPHEQ) = SPH + 0.5 * CYL. If SPHEQ is within 0.5 diopters of each other it’s more or less expected. This is the short version and there’s a lot more nuance (like the AX and ADD values on the Rx), if anyone is interested or has questions I can add more. Source: I was CTO for an online eye exam and have some patents related to this.
- almostnormal 3y ago
  That limit is efficient for measuring and selling glasses. As a life-long user, glasses with an error of 0.5 are unacceptable for me. That's the amount of change over years when it is time to get new ones. Not all deviations are measurement errors. There are potential variable conditions of the eye (e.g., spasm of accommodation and sugar level). An online solution that can consider them properly is definitively worth a patent.
  - jtwaleson 3y ago
    Agreed on all points. Also the acceptability varies a lot. By your wording it sounds like you are quite picky about glasses and would A) not go to a random optician and B) return the glasses if you are not satisfied. I’m the same ;) There are many people who are not that picky.
    - qaid 3y ago
      A) How can I find a proper optician? B) how do you determine whether or not you’re satisfied? Throughout 30 years of wearing glasses, I’ve questioned many times whether the glasses are right for me. I may resist for a month or two but I always end up “adapting” to the new pair. When is this acceptable and how do I know when to speak up?
      - jtwaleson 3y ago
        First of: adapting to new glasses is normal and can take a couple of weeks. For A: I don’t really know, but use the ones that gives you B. Depending on the country, high end / non-chain stores can have better customer service and listen to your wishes, and answer your questions. There’s also smoke and mirrors and upselling so see if you trust the person. B: for simple distance vision (if you are under 40) do a quick pin hole test and look at tree leaves or something. If your vision quality increases a lot you should not be satisfied. Same if you notice eye strain when looking at things in the distance. Now for multifocal glasses it really depends on your use case (reading, computer work, etc), and it’s very difficult to get a really good correction. There’s no silver bullet. Find an optometrist or optician that you trust, so back to A ;)
DougBTX 3y ago
You should try the intro to Physics lab work where students are asked to measure the length of a piece of string, and get a different result each time!
- hef19898 3y ago
  One the hardest math problems I had, in practical terms, during my studies was carrying error margins from measurements along calculations in physics. Also, analyzing the accuracy of measurement tools and systems with regards to whatever is measured, is a core task of quality control.
runeks 3y ago
How much did the three different prescriptions differ?
tylerhou 3y ago
On the other hand, over the last 5 years, I’ve had my eyes examined 4 times at 2 different places (two at one, two at the other) and every time my prescription has been the exact same (modulo slight changes to my astigmatism angle, which is apparently normal).

Personal anecdata: In span of 6 months, I did eye exams at 3 different places and got 3 different prescriptions! All 3 claimed to use latest tech and they did manual exams as well.

jtwaleson 3y ago

This is pretty normal, depending on the amount of variation of course. Basically, for each calculate the spherical equivalent (SPHEQ) = SPH + 0.5 * CYL. If SPHEQ is within 0.5 diopters of each other it’s more or less expected. This is the short version and there’s a lot more nuance (like the AX and ADD values on the Rx), if anyone is interested or has questions I can add more. Source: I was CTO for an online eye exam and have some patents related to this.

almostnormal 3y ago
That limit is efficient for measuring and selling glasses. As a life-long user, glasses with an error of 0.5 are unacceptable for me. That's the amount of change over years when it is time to get new ones. Not all deviations are measurement errors. There are potential variable conditions of the eye (e.g., spasm of accommodation and sugar level). An online solution that can consider them properly is definitively worth a patent.
- jtwaleson 3y ago
  Agreed on all points. Also the acceptability varies a lot. By your wording it sounds like you are quite picky about glasses and would A) not go to a random optician and B) return the glasses if you are not satisfied. I’m the same ;) There are many people who are not that picky.
  - qaid 3y ago
    A) How can I find a proper optician? B) how do you determine whether or not you’re satisfied? Throughout 30 years of wearing glasses, I’ve questioned many times whether the glasses are right for me. I may resist for a month or two but I always end up “adapting” to the new pair. When is this acceptable and how do I know when to speak up?
    - jtwaleson 3y ago
      First of: adapting to new glasses is normal and can take a couple of weeks. For A: I don’t really know, but use the ones that gives you B. Depending on the country, high end / non-chain stores can have better customer service and listen to your wishes, and answer your questions. There’s also smoke and mirrors and upselling so see if you trust the person. B: for simple distance vision (if you are under 40) do a quick pin hole test and look at tree leaves or something. If your vision quality increases a lot you should not be satisfied. Same if you notice eye strain when looking at things in the distance. Now for multifocal glasses it really depends on your use case (reading, computer work, etc), and it’s very difficult to get a really good correction. There’s no silver bullet. Find an optometrist or optician that you trust, so back to A ;)

DougBTX 3y ago

You should try the intro to Physics lab work where students are asked to measure the length of a piece of string, and get a different result each time!

hef19898 3y ago
One the hardest math problems I had, in practical terms, during my studies was carrying error margins from measurements along calculations in physics. Also, analyzing the accuracy of measurement tools and systems with regards to whatever is measured, is a core task of quality control.

runeks 3y ago

How much did the three different prescriptions differ?

tylerhou 3y ago

On the other hand, over the last 5 years, I’ve had my eyes examined 4 times at 2 different places (two at one, two at the other) and every time my prescription has been the exact same (modulo slight changes to my astigmatism angle, which is apparently normal).