6 ms·
Early response to false claims in Wikipedia, 15 years later
- lmm 3y ago15 years ago is almost exactly the date I have in my head for when Wikipedia stopped being interesting or exciting. Remember when it felt like something new and exciting, something that would tell you everything about the whole world? And then somehow it got captured by a bunch of bureaucrats who decided they wanted it to be a free copy of Britannica, and it achieved that, and has since just sat there begging for money and throwing it into the endless pit of irrelevant projects that is the rest of the Wikimedia Foundation? More concretely, the new user experience got worse and worse: powertripping mods squatting their pet pages grew out of control, and all the notability/sourcing rules haven't really done anything to improve the quality of the content, they've just made it more tedious to contribute. And all this felt predictable at the time. The whole site took a massive wrong turn, and yet there never felt like any way to stop it.
- kmeisthax 3y agoI mean, the whole literal point of Wikipedia is to be a "free copy of Brittanica", so I wouldn't call that capture.
- ponderings 3y ago[citation needed]
- rfrey 3y agoThe name is literally a modification of "encyclopedia". It's an encyclopedia in wiki form.
- JimDabell 3y agoI think it ceased to be a wiki a long time ago. The whole point of a wiki is to have the lowest barrier to entry possible for editing so any non-expert can jump in and change something quickly. The word “wiki” is Hawaiian for “quick”. But these days, a huge amount of bureaucracy has sprung up around editing things on Wikipedia. There’s an immense number of rules; there are people with seemingly infinite time gatekeeping their favourite topics; there are protected pages; there are notability requirements; there are vast IP bans; and so on. Wikipedia has a bureaucracy fetish and an army of rules lawyers. You might argue that for the scale of Wikipedia this is required, and I’m sure there’s at least some truth to that, but that is incompatible with the idea of a wiki.
- somenameforme 3y agoThere's a major difference that makes Wikipedia fundamentally different than encyclopedias. Britannica was written primarily by experts ranging from Albert Einstein to Isaac Asimov, and everybody in between. And these writers would offer their own perspectives, insights, and expertise. It was a rich primary source. Wikipedia, by contrast, is not a primary source, and writers are supposed to do little more than paraphrase reliable sources. This is a good idea in theory to solve the issue of going from having articles written by Einstein to having them written by random people, but it doesn't seem to work so well in practice. The problem is that topics whose framing is seen as relevant by some group or another (which is an absurdly large amount) drags in partisans, corporations, politicians, intelligence agencies and the rest of the dreg. And it leaves Wiki really hurting for quality on these pages.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- diputsmonro 3y agoHow could you possibly call the largest encyclopedia in human history, freely accessible to all, and correct nearly all of the time irrelevant? There are imperfections to Wikipedia and the Foundation of course, but, what more can you reasonably expect? If you want old internet fun, we have neocities.org for that. Wikipedia serves a functional purpose and does is exceedingly well in most cases.
- hulitu 3y ago> How could you possibly call the largest encyclopedia in human history, freely accessible to all, and correct nearly all of the time irrelevant? Have you read the Hitchhikers guide to the galaxy ?
- lmm 3y ago> How could you possibly call the largest encyclopedia in human history, freely accessible to all, and correct nearly all of the time irrelevant? I didn't - I called the other stuff the Wikimedia Foundation does, the stuff that it spends the vast majority of its immense donation income on, irrelevant. > There are imperfections to Wikipedia and the Foundation of course, but, what more can you reasonably expect? I expected policies that better reflected what most users and contributors wanted, or that helped make something better. Almost everyone was against the notability rules (and, while it's a minor thing really, almost everyone was in favour of spoiler warnings; they may have had theoretical problems but they worked well in practice). All the measures to make it harder for new users to edit were based on a false assumption - actually new users are no more likely to be vandals or politically biased than anyone else.
- willdr 3y agoYou don't really understand the current landscape of Wikipedia.
- Affric 3y agoI don’t think that the parent commenter is claiming to have an understanding but is providing their perspective as a user. Do you have any good primers on the current landscape of Wikipedia? (Obviously not your job but who else to ask)
- Affric 3y agoAre you able to point to any concrete examples? I know that new user experience is awful now. Can’t even correct misinformation because my whole range of available dynamically assigned IP addresses from my ISP (the largest in the country) are blocked and I can’t find any way to sign up for an account that’s navigable compared to the benefit of a huge body of errata on a wide range of topics. That’s my example. Beyond that, a bureaucracy has arisen and much like the nomenklatura they exhibit many of the problems of the system they sought to replace. Wikipedia is still great. But the new stuff is not as fun. The user added photographs from 20 years ago pleasantly surprise me a lot more than the new stuff. But I don’t keep a file on hand.
- lmm 3y agoNo, I never kept any objective records either. Just my own subjective experiences, which seem to match yours.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- a_bonobo 3y ago>Karl Popper >While there, he lived on a cooperative farm. He later claimed that nothing prepares the mind for philosophy like milking a cow. These fibs are just too plausible to be detectable!
- anArbitraryOne 3y agoNot to be too epistemological, but how do we know he didn't say that?
- hp6 3y agoWhile the topic is intriguing, I dislike the use of "public services" for this type of research. For instance, adding substances to a water reservoir to study their effects is unacceptable, without permission or supervision. Similarly, conducting such research without Wikipedia's permission/supervision should not be accepted.
- kmeisthax 3y agoSomeone tried something similar but with higher risk: inserting security backdoors into the Linux kernel. They were caught and (AFAIK) their entire school was permabanned from sending pull requests.
- minetest2048 3y agoThis was also my thought. Search for hypocrite commits, and a link to an lwn article: https://lwn.net/Articles/853717/ https://lwn.net/Articles/853717/ . They did ban their whole school
- carbocation 3y agoThe department said they'd report their findings to the community[1]. I wonder if they ever did? 1 = https://cse.umn.edu/cs/statement-cse-linux-kernel-research-april-21-2021 https://cse.umn.edu/cs/statement-cse-linux-kernel-research-a...
- hakre 3y agoIsn't community plural? Perhaps they meant their own community but didn't say specifically which one?
- Pazzaz 3y agoIt's the other two links on that page: - https://cse.umn.edu/cs/open-letter-linux-community-april-24-2021 https://cse.umn.edu/cs/open-letter-linux-community-april-24-... - https://cse.umn.edu/cs/statement-computer-science-engineering-confirming-linux-technical-advisory-board-findings-may-9 https://cse.umn.edu/cs/statement-computer-science-engineerin...
- foolfoolz 3y agowikipedia is great for science content, old content that is research based. things where the sources can be find and cited clearly. wikipedia is not great for current events. there is a clear bias in wikipedias content. even something as simple as the did you know section on the homepage. for nearly all of 2022 and the early part of this year one of the 5 items in the did you know section was about ukraine every single day. i’m not trying to make a post about the war i’m really trying to say i wish wikipedia didn’t do this kind of stuff to portray a sense of “neutral information hub” rather than “wiki admin propaganda tool”
- willdr 3y agoDYK is a notorious part of Wikipedia from an editing POV and is rife with long-term accounts who all they do is curate it.
- Borgz 3y agoI arbitrarily selected the month of September 2022 and found that on only 5 out of the 30 days of the month was there an entry related to Ukraine or Ukrainians in the "Did you know" section. Of those 5, only 1 was related to the war. I disagree that 5/30 constitutes "nearly every day". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Recent_additions/2022/September#Did_you_know https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Recent_additions/202...... Furthermore, I don't see what's inherently wrong with including information in that section that relates to a topic people are likely to be interested in at the moment. Additionally, the "Did you know section" isn't really for current events. That would be the "In the news" section.
- ChrisKnott 3y agoThis surprised me but I randomly checked three days and none of them had anything relating to Ukraine in "Did You Know?" https://web.archive.org/web/20220715144903/https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page https://web.archive.org/web/20220715144903/https://en.m.wiki... https://web.archive.org/web/20220819171715/https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page https://web.archive.org/web/20220819171715/https://en.m.wiki... https://web.archive.org/web/20220902170516/https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page https://web.archive.org/web/20220902170516/https://en.m.wiki... (by chance one of the Featured Articles was "Confirmation Bias")
- gcanyon 3y ago> And even if a user from 15 years ago were still contributing Wikipedia, they would be much older now. My first contribution: 14 June 2004 My most recent contribution: 3 July 2023 ...I resemble that remark
- renewiltord 3y agoOctober 2007 to Aug 2023 for me so strangely coincidental haha
- p-e-w 3y agoSo the author, a philosophy professor, casually permitted themselves to vandalize a public resource "for science", with the only accommodation given to the public being that they generously fixed their own vandalism after 48 hours if others hadn't done so already. Not a single word about the ethics of all this in the entire article, as far as I can tell. It's not just that they decided to do this, spreading misinformation and wasting other people's time in the process – they seem to not even have considered the impact of it. Please re-take Foundations of Ethics 101 before presuming to teach others about philosophy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pacaro 3y agoBut first, please share the rules for Whistenschaft
- chx 3y agoThe actual falsification is far more subtle and usually is done with an entire cohort of admins. The Polish and the Croatians have been caught, the Hungarians not yet. We discussed this at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34747388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34747388
- anArbitraryOne 3y agoIt would be more interesting to have estimated the hazard function of the fibs. Here's my bogus estimation: A third of the fibs being removed within 2 days implies a half life of 3.5 days and an average fib duration of 5 days.
- incomingpain 3y agoI suspect wikipedia has peaked and shall forever be fighting with itself. Larry Sanger's article on how bad political influence has taken over wikipedia is revealing. Then you start to see how bad it really is on the subjects you know well. Wikipedia does sports teams stuff well. If you ever need to look up who won the Formula 1 race in 1990, you know wikipedia will have the right answer but soon as you dive even a millimeter into anything current events or political or religion and you arent going to find real information.