3 ms·
I think the burden of proof is in the other direction: if someone is going to use some sort of signal or test to determine if someone is eligible for employment
by kelnos 3y ago
I think the burden of proof is in the other direction: if someone is going to use some sort of signal or test to determine if someone is eligible for employment, it is on them to present evidence that the signal/test actually accomplishes the objective they expect it to.
In California, it is illegal to use a credit report in employment decisions (unless the position is in finance/accounting). Clearly lawmakers have decided that this sort of test isn't helpful, and is abused to deny qualified people employment.
- me-vs-cat 3y agoDo you think those employers want to turn away qualified people and keep the positions vacant?
- brewdad 3y agoNo, but they might want to turn away a specific employee for an otherwise protected reason. Don't want to hire a black employee? Run a credit check. Statistically, black individuals have lower credit scores than white individuals. Deny them a job based on their credit score.
- me-vs-cat 3y agoWhile that makes some sense, I'm apparently having a hard time getting over my conception that a private business would ever give the rejected candidate a specific reason they weren't offered the position. Surely this is cultural on my part.
- b112 3y agoIn the past, this was common. People would tell you why, and as a result, you might be able to respond with a reason, or, fix the perceived deficiency. Now everyone is afraid of being sued, and all sorts of court cases in the last decade or two, validate that fear. So now no one tells, and therefore, no one knows why. And so, you never get a chance to explain, or give context, or even prove a mark against you is in error. Sometimes, social justice solutions can backfire.