4 ms·
How is something critical if it has been transgressed and we are still alive? Or on the very first moment every single one is past we all suddenly die?
by Acssux 3y ago
How is something critical if it has been transgressed and we are still alive? Or on the very first moment every single one is past we all suddenly die?
- Cerium 3y agoBreathing is critical to keep me alive, but I can hold my breath for a minute, and if forced by external means to stop breathing, will still be ok for a few minutes.
- hotpotamus 3y agoIt reminds me a bit of radiation poisoning - you can receive a lethal dose in moments. After that, you can carry on for a time; hours, maybe days feeling normal, but your death has already been ordained and your biochemical systems will collapse from the insult.
- musha68k 3y agoHokuto Shinken self-application; all the neuralgic points, and with determination and lots of force.
- netsharc 3y agoHa, good point, let's not focus on the main issue and instead argue semantics shall we... /s To ELI5 like you seem to prefer, the iceberg breaching the hull of the Titanic seems like a critical transgression, but the ship stayed afloat another hour or so...
- ricardobeat 3y agoThis is looking at changes over a scale of centuries, and the potentially irreversible effects of what we are doing right now. > Had Earth system remained forced by 1988 conditions (350 ppm and 85%/50%/85% of tropical/temperate/boreal forest cover remaining), the simulations show that temperature over the global land surface would not have increased by more than an additional 0.6°C in the subsequent 800 years > If climate and land system change can be halted at 450 ppm and forest cover retained at 60%/30%/60% of boreal/temperate/tropical natural cover, then the simulation indicates a mean temperature rise over land of 1.4°C by 2100 (in addition to 0.7°C between preindustrial time and 1988) and 1.9°C after 800 years as vegetation evolves in a warmer climate The latter is an optimistic projection assuming we will do more to stop climate change, the paper goes further into the odds of a >3C increase. To put that in context, a 1.5°C increase in average temperature is considered a doomsday scenario where wildfires and storms ravage the earth, killing over half of the global population.
- paint 3y agoEchoing the kind of climate change scenario 5 year old kids have seems kind of cruel the week thousands of people in Libya died of events that are exasperated by the climate crisis. People are already dying of climate related causes, like crop failures and natural distasters.
- swader999 3y agoMan-made dams broke.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- young_breezy 3y agoRight? The climate is fine as long as you don’t depend on man made objects
- paint 3y agoWhat you are saying is technically not wrong, but misleading, as it omits the fact the dams broke due to a natural disaster, Storm Daniel, which previously also "affected Greece, Bulgaria, and Turkey with extensive flooding.". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storm_Daniel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storm_Daniel
- swader999 3y agoNo kidding, but to say that climate change did this when hurricanes have been on the decline the last thirty years is misleading. This is weather and engineering failures. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24268-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24268-5
- Eduard 3y ago> No kidding, but to say that climate change did this when hurricanes have been on the decline the last thirty years is misleading. This is weather and engineering failures. > https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24268-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24268-5 This HN user categorically and obsessively has their own opinion on climate change, and how it is influenced by humans. Their "evidence research" is taking the first Google search result that they believe to support their position in the discussion at hand - even if it doesn't make sense (hurricanes in North America versus Mediterranean). If they don't invest in such sloppy research, their arguments hit rock-bottom Tiktok factoid niveau. one can better just assume nonsense/randomizing/lying and ignore this user for anything climate-related.
- chx 3y agoI'd recommend watching Margin Call, a movie set during the 2008 financial collapse.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lkbm 3y agoThe article says: > Boundary positions do not demarcate or predict singular threshold shifts in Earth system state. They are placed at a level where the available evidence suggests that further perturbation of the individual process could potentially lead to systemic planetary change by altering and fundamentally reshaping the dynamics and spatiotemporal patterns of geosphere-biosphere interactions and their feedbacks Probably would need to read more to get a clear understanding of exactly what they mean and how they're defined, but it sounds like we're to an unstable place. Perhaps somewhat analogous to skating on thin ice: you may not have haven't broken through yet, but you're in a spot where a break could happen at any moment and from any movement.
- haltist 3y agoCalifornia's climate patterns are already changing but the state has managed to deal with the problems and will probably continue to do so. Texas on the other hand is starting to see problems with their electricity grid during summers and it's going to keep getting worse as temperatures continue to rise.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoMy man, this comment is so wildly antiscience. I don’t know where to begin. I’m not sure if it would be with forest management, or the complexity and reasons that cut Texas has its own grid, separated from everyone else. I’m not sure I would say either directly applicable to this topic.
- autoexec 3y agoTexas throwing a tantrum and refusing to have their power grid under federal regulation will become increasingly applicable to the topic since the changes we're causing to our planet and its climate will put even more strain on their weak and inflexible power grid. People in texas are already dying from the heat in the summer and freezing to death in the winter and it's only going to get worse.
- autoexec 3y ago
- IKantRead 3y agoGive it some time. Good news is that "faster than expected" seems to be a very common saying among people studying these areas, so you might not have to wait as long as the geological time might suggest! Honestly, as someone who has been very concerned about climate for a while now, I'm surprised how much visible disruption of the climate system we've directly been able to observe. Earlier in my life I thought that, though dire, this was certainly a problem that would impact future generations but not so much ours. It turns out I might have been quite wrong on that front.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou have a funny definition of 'good news'.
- labster 3y agoGood news often comes in suppository form these days.
- jacquesm 3y agoThere was a somewhat funny joke about the hunger winter here in NL: "Kids I've got good news and bad news, the bad news is that we will eat flower bulbs, the good news is you can eat as much as you want".
- Borrible 3y agoBad news, you will face it in your lifetime. Good news, you won't face the time after.
- tuatoru 3y agoThe Club of Rome's "Limits To Growth" study in the 1970s, in its central scenario, had the 2040s as the time when we'd start to really feel the consequences of "pollution" (broadly conceived, including things like fossil water drawdown and soil exhaustion as well as the results of using fossil fuels). A little faster than expected maybe. Not all that much though.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> How is something critical if it has been transgressed I don't think the paper claims we've passed criticality. Instead, it talks of boundaries and risk, the latter reflecting that we don't know where the critical points are. > on the very first moment every single one is past we all suddenly die? Biosphere collapse could happen suddenly and without warning. That would throw the global south into political turmoil while prompting a global and destabilizing refugee crisis.
- elihu 3y agoThe Titanic didn't sink the moment it hit the iceberg, it took a little over two and a half hours. During a significant portion of that time it wasn't all that obvious that anything was seriously wrong. The ship was listing slightly to one side and the engines were off. The passengers weren't all affected equally either. A lot of first-class passengers made it onto lifeboats, whereas third class passengers mostly didn't. (The analogy breaks down a little in that we don't have lifeboats and the collapse of our ecosystems probably won't be as absolute and catestrophic as a ship sinking. The Earth's ability to sustain large numbers of humans may decline significantly though, and a lot of things we take for granted now may be gone.)
- autoexec 3y agoWe don't have life boats (yet) but I do wonder if some part of the massive increase in wealth disparity we've seen is due to uncertainty about the future, or if the reluctance to take meaningful action to slow/reverse the impacts we've had on the earth is because it's already clear that our time is running out and there's nothing that can be done to stop it.
- Iridescent_ 3y agoIf you have a pond with 1000 fishes, and each year the population of fish doubles, you can remove 501 fishes/year for quite a while. You are clearly in an unsustainable situation, yet it will take time for the population to completely collapse. These limits are in the sense that we cannot stay above forever, not in the we cannot go above ever sense.
- isotropy 3y agoWell, only for 8 years. 1000 998 994 986 970 938 874 746 490 ooops
- ricardobeat 3y agoA very insightful misguided comment, shows how easy it can be to disturb a system in equilibrium with very minor changes (1 extra fish).
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoIf you harvest after the reproductive cycle though: 1000 1499 2497 4493 ... it pays to be be patient!
- pixl97 3y agoIf the engines on your plane fall off mid flight, everyone doesn't die instantly. They die instantly after 30 thousand feet of screaming terror. This comment screams lack of education about complicated systems. For example take overpopulation in things like grazing mammals. The funny thing about being overpopulated is that it is not instantly deadly. Once the mammals eat enough of their food source that their food source cannot reproduce reliably the game is over. But they tend to have reserves of fat and muscle that last for some period of time. The weakest die first. Then the population reduces. But the population doesn't go back to what was previously considered at the over population limit. No, populations massively collapse because there is nothing to eat at all. 9 out of 10 members of the population can die. And if it's something like an island, extinction is on the menu.
- jacquesm 3y agoEven if not on an island extinction is on the menu depending on how large the population was to begin with and the velocity of the crash. This is because the males in the population can't reproduce by themselves and the weakest are often the young. So when food runs out, even if it is temporarily, you may see one last generation of very fit males and possibly some cannibalism and after that it is game over. Calhoun did some pretty gruesome (and borderline unethical) experiments that are the closest thing we have to lab controlled overpopulation experiments. The results presented are pretty sobering.
- myshpa 3y agohttps://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comic/st-matthew-island/ https://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comic/st-matthew-island/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_overshoot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_overshoot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrying_capacity#Planetary_Boundaries_Framework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrying_capacity#Planetary_Bo...