5 ms·
The conflict here is it costs a lot of effort (time and money) to do the hard work of figuring out what a good code should be. Used to be large cities (New York
by bluGill 3y ago
The conflict here is it costs a lot of effort (time and money) to do the hard work of figuring out what a good code should be. Used to be large cities (New York) would pay for it, and small towns would copy it - which meant if you lived in a smaller city you were freeloading off of New York (and in some cases you had to do something that made sense for New York but not where you were) which is unfair to New York's taxpayers. By have some organization create a standard towns can more equally share the cost of building a good standard.
Standards organizations need to pay the engineers who do all the complex calculations to figure out what works. However I think everyone agrees the law shouldn't be hidden from people who need to obey it.
- mistrial9 3y agoyou are not wrong, but missing quite a bit. In California and elsewhere, small variations in building and electrical code are used to stall, or make conflicting requirements using vague wording, that gives excess discretionary power to inspectors. In a large, wealthy city like San Francisco, inspectors routinely stall projects, or exert excessive discretionary powers over construction. Why? obviously it is an entry to corruption, but don't overlook the convenience to the city department of being completely and totally in control, to stall.. while being on salary.
- bluGill 3y agoMost places are not nearly as bad as CA. You are correct that codes are also used for corruption, but in many places they are closer to the ideal (they never hit the ideal) of ensuring safety so that you don't endanger the community or rescue workers with your property.
- helmchenlord 3y ago> Used to be large cities (New York) would pay for it, and small towns would copy it It will always be beyond me why literally every tiny town in the US seems to think they're a special snowflake with veeery different requirements than everybody else. There should be base codes for literally everything coming down from the federal or at maximum state level that you may be allowed to stricten in very specific points for very specific, publicly discussed reasons. The need to "develop" such a code more than once should never exist. Everything else is not just unfair to the taxpayers who paid for these developments, it's simply unfair to your citizens. Why should they have different rights just because they happen to live in a different federal state?
- pixl97 3y agoThen states need to make laws of shared governance for the entire state, and the tax base of the state is used to create and pay for said standards creation. Having hundreds of different hidden behind paywall standards for each municipality is not doing the population at large any favors.
- bluGill 3y agoSure, which is why states mostly have taken over from cities. State have them gone together to create/encourage these entities to create good codes they can just adopt so they don't have to pay the full price, while they get input into the process for whatever might be unique for their state. The idea of these entities doing the work is sound. It is just that they have a little too much ability to control who gets to see the result of their work.