4 ms·
For me, it’s a matter of it’s none of their business. No one’s accused me of making meth, but here’s all my PII in a database “just in case”. It’s literally ha
by kstrauser 3y ago
For me, it’s a matter of it’s none of their business. No one’s accused me of making meth, but here’s all my PII in a database “just in case”.
It’s literally harder for me to buy cold medicine than a gun. I hate everything about that situation.
- tptacek 3y agoI mean, the reason they keep the database is especially clear here, right? They're just trying to enforce a rate limit. It's the most obvious public policy response you can have to "a drug that in small quantities is a useful decongestant, but in moderate quantities or above is an ultra powerful stimulant whose abuse is ravaging parts of the country".
- phone8675309 3y agoThe primary question to me is whether the risk of data breech outweighs the harm from not keeping the data, and while 20 years ago this tradeoff may have made sense, I'm not so sure it makes sense now.
- akerl_ 3y agoIf the data is breached, an attacker learns... that sometimes you have a cough?
- kstrauser 3y ago...and your SSN, and your driver's license info, and all the other personally identifying information they collect and store in the DB.
- phone8675309 3y agoGenerally not your SSN - I've never had to give it for Sudafed - but at least full legal name, birthday, gender, home address, driver's license number, telephone number, location(s) you've been to buy medication, and possibly email address. Much of which would be covered as PII and PPI, and, in combination with info from other other data breaches can tell someone a lot about you.
- phone8675309 3y agoIn addition to at least your full legal name, birthday, gender, home address, driver's license number, telephone number, location(s) you've been to buy medication, and possibly email address.
- tptacek 3y agoYou do not in fact provide an email address to buy Sudafed. The rest of that information is for most people already a public record. I'm not saying that makes it OK to assemble into a database, and I think the point about amassing PII is well taken, but I think people are probably overestimating the value/hazardousness of this particular data set.
- lazide 3y agoIt’s an attractive nuisance which seems to provide zero practical value overall, let alone for it’s stated reason to exist.
- tptacek 3y agoIt decreases the number of backyard meth labs, which are a danger to their surroundings. Despite the availability of overseas industrial meth, meth labs would make a comeback if you could simply buy pseudo-meth at the drug store to shake-and-bake in your garage.
- phone8675309 3y agoA more robust fix compared to keeping a list of cold medicine buyers would be to decriminalize or legalize hard drugs, ensuring that a clean, inexpensive supply is available for those addicted under medical supervision, providing a safe place for those who choose to use, providing judgement free addiction treatment, increasing invest in addiction prevention, and addressing the systemic issues that drive people toward drugs due to a lack of opportunity, lack of support, or lack of understanding the negative impacts of drug use.
- kstrauser 3y agoI get it. I just find it frustrating, and I'd like to know that my PII was removed after the rate limit period.
- tptacek 3y agoI agree with this!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bsagdiyev 3y agoI don't know where you live but I cannot buy a guy by just showing up. They take ID, they require a license and still run a check. The only exception is when you get your CCW which removes the license per handgun (not long gun/shotgun) but requires a background check.