6 ms·
It seems like these attempts to enforce fairness/impartiality often hinge on making the information-release as simultaneous as possible... But I can't help but
by Terr_ 3y ago
It seems like these attempts to enforce fairness/impartiality often hinge on making the information-release as simultaneous as possible... But I can't help but feel dissatisfied with that, it feels like a cheap-and-dirty fix.
It just shifts things from "free money to whoever has the best spy-network or paid preferential access" to "free money to whoever builds a system to place orders milliseconds faster than others."
- pixl97 3y agoIt turns out that the speed of light its the limit to causality and your 'closeness' to the source is always going to matter. Lets imagine it on a planetary scale, you have planets in this particular layout currently. A - B - C If planet A releases news, planet B will get the news and be able to reply to it before planet C and there no way to do anything about it unless you come up with superluminal travel. Now, some number of months, years later as the planets orbit you can get A - C -B in which planet B would be left out.
- matthewaveryusa 3y agoYou could try to make it fair by having planet A encrypt a payload to B and a payload to C such that the transmission time and decryption time from A - B is the same as A - C. You could need encryption that feeds the previous block to the next (so CBC), and some trusted computing solution such that additional compute cannot be added to accelerate the decryption.
- pixl97 3y agoThis depends if you're doing full cycle trips of two way 'trading' to planet A. You not only have the time for full information to get to planet C, you have to withhold information from B until planet C's reply is already in flight back to planet A.
- Terr_ 3y agoI think this is more about which activities (ex: industrial espionage) ought to be economically rewarded and which should not. It's true that "Being Much Closer On A Closer Planet" might someday be part of that debate, but I think we've got plenty of closer non-spacetime issues to tackle first.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bagels 3y agoThere is a better kind of closeness, eg. for reports/financials, being on the inside and getting the information on human timescales (well ahead of the public)
- Arainach 3y agoIt doesn't have to be for everything. Disclose whenever and disallow action on the information for a period of time. This is why company earnings are disclosed after the market closes for the day - everyone has several hours to receive the information and decide what to do.
- underlipton 3y agoDoes that really help, though? During the trading day, many (I want to say most, but can't confirm it) trades don't affect prices; odd lots and trades internalized on certain trading platforms don't effect NBBO IIRC. On the other hand, pre-market and after hours trades of even single-digit shares can move the price. This is why volatility can be so high then, and why you'll often see things like stock prices moving 10, 20, 30% within a few moments of close. Sometimes it snaps back before the next trading day. Sometimes, it doesn't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw0101b 3y ago> It turns out that the speed of light its the limit to causality and your 'closeness' to the source is always going to matter. Evidence for this is that in 2012/2013 insider trading was detected due to the latency between DC and Chicago: * https://www.cnbc.com/2013/09/24/some-traders-got-no-taper-decision-news-early.html https://www.cnbc.com/2013/09/24/some-traders-got-no-taper-de... * https://www.theverge.com/2013/10/3/4798542/whats-faster-than-a-light-speed-trade-inside-the-sketchy-world-of https://www.theverge.com/2013/10/3/4798542/whats-faster-than...
- BoiledCabbage 3y agoThe easiest way to fix this would be to say (in an extreme case) trades can only happen on 4 hour boundaries (time to get from the sun to neptune). So as long as news is released early in the period, then everyone has plenty of time to receive the information. Again assuming you're talking about planetary scale within the same solar system. If you're talking about within the US or on earth, you simply give a buffer for speed of light to transit across the us and "very sufficient" time for computation/calculation. There will always be some delta. Ie a company near wall st had 5mins minus 1 millisecond to calculate, while a company in california had 5 mins minus 100 milliseconds to calculate. But if they have 5 mins to digest and calculate the news, the difference those few milliseconds make isn't really important anymore. Investing should prioritize making the correct decision over making the faster decision. Right now, too much of profit is simply being able to make the faster decision. It's like playing an RTS against and AI with horrible strategy but has APM through the roof. Yes they're winning, but it's not really interesting or beneficial insights it's providing. But if you have a strategy that can win with only 10 APM you must've come up with something really deep and insightful about the game.
- esafak 3y agoYou could mildly quantize the order processing to give everybody enough time to act on it, and eliminate a lot of unproductive HFT.
- Terr_ 3y agoYeah, another possibility might be an exchange where there is some time-fuzzing in the system, such as if every order gets a (provably) random hidden delay. This would discourage people trying to play around incidental timing issues in favor of bidding what they "really think is right." I suppose users might try to avoid that by breaking up a buy/sell order into a bazillion tiny orders, but that could be curbed by transaction-costs.