3 ms·
Yeah, the "rock drums" example was like a student in a practice. I'll be impressed when it can sound like Danny Carey. From all of the hype, I want to be impre
by dylan604 3y ago
Yeah, the "rock drums" example was like a student in a practice. I'll be impressed when it can sound like Danny Carey.
From all of the hype, I want to be impressed with results. Instead, we get these mediocre at best examples of what it can do. They are not good sales pitches to me.
- chpatrick 3y agoSir, your dog can talk! Yes, but not very well.
- dylan604 3y agoYou joke, but even those videos of people saying their dog can talk is just like this. It's cute because it's a real dog making sounds we really want to believe when it's just them mimicking sounds because they get pettin's and treats. What I want is "AI" to do something impressive. Why are we trying to make the system generate the sounds itself? We don't make artists do that, we give them instruments. Give the models actual instruments, and then have it play them like a real artist. I will be much more impressed with an AI that understands composition and scoring, use of musical voices, key signatures. That would still be generative. I guess I just don't understand the point of the direction being taken. It's like a solution looking for a problem.
- chpatrick 3y agoWell, we found with Midjourney et al that these models can work very well despite having no pre-conceived or symbolic notions of composition, color theory, perspective or anything. Yet they can produce really good results in the image generation space. It's the same idea here, except much earlier days. In the same way, many successful musicians can't read sheet music or know music theory, they just know how to produce something that sounds good.
- dylan604 3y ago>In the same way, many successful musicians can't read sheet music or know music theory, they just know how to produce something that sounds good. Right, because they can operate the instruments that make the sound with natural talent, but they don't have to draw the waveforms. Audio generation is much different than image generation. It's just very odd to me.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoWe work with what we have. We don't have a lot of recordings of the physical movements of musicians; we have recordings. Similarly, we don't have recordings of the actions of painters; we have finished paintings -- but if you're not impressed with what AI can do in the visual sphere, your standards are, to put it mildly, high.
- dylan604 3y agoI'm not really sure how to take this. We absolutely have recordings of instruments. You can buy them as complete sets. You train on complete recordings, and then tell it how to use the sampled instruments to compose a song in the style of the trained data. Building something to make a waveform that looks like another waveform just seems like a very odd direction to take. Yes, my standards are if it isn't at least as good as what's available now, what's the point.
- hoosieree 3y agoHate to break it to you but there is a vast market for mediocre content, and even Danny Carey has a bad day once in a while.
- dylan604 3y agoI think you've confused the vast market's forced acceptance of mediocre because that's what's available with their wanting the mediocrity. Proof of that is seen with the emergence of places for affordably licensed royalty free options. The quality of production and styles today compared to those from the 90s/00s is amazing. There's been a few options on these sites that I would play in a set as DJ. This ain't yo momma's needle drop selections.