2 ms·
Do they identify bad schools? Or do they identify schools with children that are harder to teach? Test results are a measurement of how well educated the stude
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Do they identify bad schools? Or do they identify schools with children that are harder to teach?
Test results are a measurement of how well educated the student is at a point in time. That's all.
You can measure the effect of a school by studying value added - how well a student performs after education compared to how well they performed before. Or similarly, how well a student performs compared to statistically similar students.
You can determine that some subsets of students are harder to teach by correlating observable characters (parental income, race, gender, etc) with outcomes.
- DanBC 15y agoSo, carefully used, with a statistician doing analysis, they're useful. How often are they carefully used, with an honest statistician doing the analysis, and without politicians / reporters / etc mangling the numbers?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoTell you what - lets eliminate all government accountability, since we can't avoid politicians/reporters/etc mangling things. End the FOIA, CBO, GAO, etc? Shut down thomas.loc.gov, and stop reporting the federal budget? Or maybe we can accept that nothing is perfect, and stop letting perfection be the enemy of the good.
- DanBC 15y agoThere's a difference between something being "not perfect but useful" and something being "not perfect and harmful". Since there's very little research on the benefits or disadvantages of constant testing it's surprising that people are happy to spend so much time and money on it.
- acdha 15y agoEverything you mention is technically possible but it's unclear that they are actually well used, with considerable evidence (see NYC's recent data release) that the numbers are used by people who are completely unprepared to work with complex data. Even the value add comparisons are hard to draw correct conclusions from without more context: a student shows no improvement in math. Did they have a bad teacher, an attendance problem or was it something like being an ESL student who has never received the help needed to understand their classes? That's not the kind of analysis which happens when the tests are effectively a single number which determines careers.