3 ms·
I am stunned that you think history is just a list of dates. It's an understanding of motives and events. WWII isn't just "from here to here", it's why each of
by vacri 15y ago
I am stunned that you think history is just a list of dates. It's an understanding of motives and events. WWII isn't just "from here to here", it's why each of the Axis powers did what they did. why the Allied powers did what they did. It does not matter that Pearl Harbour happened on Dec 7 1941, what matters is why the Japanese attacked, how it came about. Understanding both the US and Japanese points of view around that event. Understanding the different arguments for and against "I have in my hand a piece of paper", of leibensraum, of making the trains run on time (or at least saying you did)...
An understanding of history is essential to understand both why and how politics works in the modern day. To toss it all aside as 'dates, names, and places' is just... uneducated. From the rest of your comment, it sounds like you're a hard science person doing the usual thoughtless dismissal of the soft sciences.
- viraptor 15y agoI think you're just confirming his position. He says he learnt because the tests required it. That information is what tests would require - dry facts, not understanding. And yeah - that would be uneducated. Isn't that why the tests exists - so that we aren't?
- slowpoke 15y ago>Isn't that why the tests exists - so that we aren't? False. Tests don't serve education, they hinder it. That's my entire point.
- tomprince 15y agoOr perhaps simple presenting the view of history that was acquired from school. Demonstrating the limited viepoint that standardized testing promotes.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- slowpoke 15y agoI'm sorry, I might have miss-phrased my comment or poorly expressed myself. I didn't mean to say that what I described is actually history. I'm well aware that history is about a lot more things than just dates. What I described is the crippled shadow of history that they cram into kids in school. Anyways, it was just an example, and maybe a bad one. My point was that the current education system is most efficient at destroying any semblance of real interest in the subjects which are taught. Actually, I should have chosen math as my example, which is by far the worst offender. That thing called "math" in school (and which has nothing to do with real math) made me loathe the subject, and now, as a CS student, I still have a hard time to get rid of this attitude towards it.